4 ms·
> Retain sufficient in-house production manufacturing that it is possible for future engineers to acquire the skills needed to develop new products, without whi
by ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago
> Retain sufficient in-house production manufacturing that it is possible for future engineers to acquire the skills needed to develop new products, without which all businesses will fail. Even the work that is out-sourced requires internal expertise to write the specifications.
That's the biggie. I think the entire US tech industry has done a gigantic face-plant, when it comes to this.
We have not only outsourced the work, but we have interrupted the transfer of knowledge and expertise.
I have friends that run manufacturing businesses, and they explained how they believe that the US will never regain what it has given away, in the last couple of decades.
- josho 3y agoI've seen a variation of this problem firsthand. Working at a cable company where they contracted out to vendors most of their software development. They had a few internal systems that they developed in-house and would only hire 'senior' developers. I was curious how they expected to have a steady supply of 'senior' skills without ever hiring, training, and promoting a junior. I also saw they had no idea how to manage their vendors, partly because they didn't have in-house skills to serve as a sanity check on what vendors were charging. As a result, their vendors profited hugely from the company's ignorance (I know because I also switched to work for one of the vendors).
- stalfosknight 3y agoThis has been my pet peeve for a long time now. Just about every job listing insists on seniors only and they companies complain there aren't enough developers.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago> seniors only But under 35 (they don't usually say that part, out loud, though). That's my pet peeve.
- ploxiln 3y agoIn software in particular, thresholds have fallen. Maybe "Senior" today is like a junior 15 years ago. (Some interns out of college are really sharp, and some can basically work at the "senior" level immediately. Basically, they think logically, and they know how to write software, which they've been practicing through high school and some college.) Put another way ... most companies just really suck at hiring software engineers, and the ones they hired before weren't good enough, so it seems they need to hire at a higher level ...
- kypro 3y agoI've seen exactly the same thing at a couple of companies I've worked at in the past too. One specifically outsourced all of their development because it was deemed to be cheaper (which it was), but after a few years without any in-house technical expertise to oversee development they'd run into all kinds of issues with bugs, outages, slow load times, etc. For a period when these issues occurred the business could say that they wanted the issues patched, but they never understood why there were so many issues to begin with. It was only until they brought a few people in house to try to bridge conversations between the business and the team of outsourced developers that it was finally raised that the code was completely unmaintainable. And following this an in house team was recruited to bring development back in-house. Of course, when we sorted 90% of the problems the business started questioning why we were needed again and we were all outsourced for a second time... But this same thing obviously happens in a lot high-tech industries. Without people who are technically competent overseeing what's happening you can only dictate requirements at a high level. You cannot dictate all of the NFRs because you simply do not have the knowledge or ability to oversee them. So what you have is something that at a surface level does what you wanted, but the execution is so horrendous that it's unsatisfactory and no amount of saying "please fix this", "please fix that" will actually resolve the fundamental issue at play. And the problem is even worse when you want to be an innovator because innovation is impossible when you don't know what is and isn't possible. To push boundaries you first need to know where the hard limitations are and what's just a engineering problem.
- vegetablepotpie 3y ago> You cannot dictate all of the NFRs because you simply do not have the knowledge or ability to oversee them This is a key point, and I believe the reason why software projects are always late and why it’s impossible to estimate them generally, in a non-domain specific way. You cannot aggregate all the estimates and recorded performance of past work and use regression towards the mean to have any predictive capacity of how long a new project will take or cost, even when it has similar high level requirements. This is why 10xers exist, or the perception of them exists. There are people who have seen similar pitfalls in the implementation stage enough times to know how to avoid them and they don’t need to redo things as much. This is why rewrites are dangerous, even when existing code bases are cumbersome to deal with and expensive to develop. The deep magic of low level NFRs will ruin attempts to replace them. Some are clever and try to use linters and static analysis tools to avoid this, but these will always be opinionated, domain specific in some way, and incomplete. They can frustrate development when taken outside their domain.
- ryandrake 3y agoI feel like the executive business class of this country has this dystopian vision: that the future of American business is just a handful of CxO and SVP people running around making $xxM dollars a year with all the actual labor doing the actual products and services being done by as-cheap-as-possible, expendable offshore workers. This is the end game they are shooting for: They want us in an Elysium hellscape with a few of them enjoying everything and the remaining 8 billion people in squalor.
- TheOtherHobbes 3y agoThat's exactly the problem. It's purely a status play, in the narrowest and meanest sense. It's unthinkable and insulting that some of the lower orders might have actually have valuable skill or important agency. The primary product of corporations has always been hierarchical status for the owners. But sometimes there's been some sense of generosity and mutual obligation. Now there's none - just myopic selfishness which often leads to disastrous consequences, sometimes affecting those afflicted by it.
- mschuster91 3y agoMost of them are going all-in for automation of everything these days, either classic robots or some fancy iteration of "AI". Chinese labor got too expensive, even Apple is fleeing, most of Asia is too unstable politically given the potential for multiple hot wars in the entire region (most involving China, but there's also India and Pakistan), Southern America is too unstable as well with either lunatic politicians or drug lords running the show, most of Africa just doesn't have the infrastructure required for either low-skill industry work or IT offshoring plus the looming effects of climate change and, again, multiple hot wars going on. Oh, and machines don't go on strikes or demand market wages. So, the result will be even worse, with people not even having jobs and left to fight for scraps instead. Or maybe one of the hot wars will eventually go global and humanity will be nuked down to 1% of the population, Fallout style. Who knows.
- lacrimacida 3y agoNukes arent even nrcessary for a drastic fall in population. A worldwide famine would be just enough do that
- bossyTeacher 3y ago> I know because I also switched to work for one of the vendors) Is that legal in the United States? In many European countries, you can't just leave your employer and go work for a client/partner due to the potential of you using the business secrets to disadvantage your former employer
- p_l 3y agoEven in Europe it can be legal, depending on exact contracts. Especially moving along outsourced "trusted" companies, sometimes it's seen as essentially divestiture of business unit into another company, etc.
- db48x 3y agoAbsolutely. You can leave your employer any time you want, and there is nothing they can do about it. You don’t even have to give notice, although it is polite to do so. And you can go work for their competitors too, unless you signed a contract ahead of time in which you promised that you wouldn’t. Even then, that may not be enforceable.
- pm24601 3y agoThis statement is true in some US states (California for example) However, it is not universally true. From the FTC rule finding (1/2023): https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/federal-register-notices/non-compete-clause-rulemaking https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/federal-register-no... > "About one in five American workers—approximately 30 million people—are bound by a non-compete clause and are thus restricted from pursuing better employment opportunities. A non-compete clause is a contractual term between an employer and a worker that blocks the worker from working for a competing employer, or starting a competing business, typically within a certain geographic area and period of time after the worker’s employment ends. Because non-compete clauses prevent workers from leaving jobs and decrease competition for workers, they lower wages for both workers who are subject to them as well as workers who are not. Non-compete clauses also prevent new businesses from forming, stifling entrepreneurship, and prevent novel innovation which would otherwise occur when workers are able to broadly share their ideas. The Federal Trade Commission proposes preventing employers from entering into non-compete clauses with workers and requiring employers to rescind existing non-compete clauses. The Commission estimates that the proposed rule would increase American workers’ earnings between $250 billion and $296 billion per year. The Commission is asking for the public’s opinion on its proposal to declare that non-compete clauses are an unfair method of competition, and on the possible alternatives to this rule that the Commission has proposed. "
- toast0 3y ago> I was curious how they expected to have a steady supply of 'senior' skills without ever hiring, training, and promoting a junior. You can do it, but since you're relying on others to build the pipeline, you're going to have to pay a lot more salary to the seniors than you would if you promoted them. Maybe that makes up for the salaries of juniors and the portion of time spent by seniors on mentoring juniors. But then some seniors want to do mentoring, and you're not providing that opportunity, so more reason for them to demand more pay. IMHO, it's workable, if not necessarily desirable, if you want a small team. If you want a big team staffed with only seniors, I think it's going to be a challenge.
- ta1243 3y ago> You can do it, but since you're relying on others to build the pipeline, you're going to have to pay a lot more salary to the seniors than you would if you promoted them. Not really, because people aren't loyal to companies, it's not the 1980s. If Company A trains a junior to a senior and fails to pay senior rates, what stops that new senior moving to Company B? Company A and Company B thus have to pay roughly the same, who did the Junior->Senior transition doesn't matter
- toast0 3y agoInertia helps. It's common knowledge that you'll get paid more if you switch jobs. Which means Company A gets a discount until the person leaves (but maybe they'll take a matching offer)
- ta1243 3y agoThat's the normal stickiness of a job, but if you are a junior and you've levelled up to senior you'll likely be looking at a wide number of roles far more than a senior staying still. Some things are easy wins for retention -- my company gives extra holiday as tenure extends for example, and people of a certain age still have a defined benefits retirement plan which has significant value. The extra holiday costs companies nothing, but an extra day each year really helps, start with say 28 days, but after 5 years you're on 33 days. It's harder to put a monetary value an extra day off, so harder to make the jump-ship calculation.
- JeffSnazz 3y ago> they explained how they believe that the US will never regain what it has given away, in the last couple of decades. Sure we can. It requires pivoting into stealing or otherwise replicating China's insane level of industrialization, but it's a little funny seeing people become despondent at the idea of merely losing clear economic hegemony over the world and becoming #2. We didn't lose anything in the last 5 decades we can't gain back faster. Here's hoping China's reign comes with fewer invasions.
- bluGill 3y agoThe US has not lost industry. We have lost unskilled and semi-skilled grunt labors, but there is a lot of manufacturing happening here and a lot of expertise. If you want to cut a piece of metal by hand to high accuracy - sorry we have moved all that to CNC (often laser) cutters and nobody remembers how to do it anymore. However if you want to take those cut parts and assemble them into something - there is plenty of expertise to be had.
- wkat4242 3y ago> If you want to cut a piece of metal by hand to high accuracy - sorry we have moved all that to CNC (often laser) cutters and nobody remembers how to do it anymore. That's just the tooling keeping up with the times. The Chinese don't do this by hand either. They're just way better at doing it at volume.
- bluGill 3y agoOne cnc today machine does the work of 100 1950s men. (1950 so no women) that is the point, those factories still exist in the us, but with far less people in manufacturing
- JeffSnazz 3y ago> The US has not lost industry. Compared to China's absolutely staggering industrialization it has!
- hinkley 3y agoI came to say much the same thing, but specifically about IT. I used to run architectural ideas by operations people who would - and occasionally did - tell me I was full of shit. Maybe 1 in 10 of us are brave enough to to this, 1 in 6 if we are generous, but now there is nobody to tell us we are being stupid before we steer the ship toward an iceberg.
- steveBK123 3y agoYes, it feels like a certain project that was foisted upon me. Fixed price SOW with a vendor to build a thing my firm didn't have domain knowledge in. Paid them to design a thing, then paid them to implement the design, as well as project manage themselves. SOW lacked meaningful acceptance criteria / objective tests. Of course, it was non-stop debacle of new things being discovered during implementation. Weekly status calls just turned into recrimination sessions with fingers pointed in all directions as to who is responsible for the time/cost. You can't rent knowledge.
- bboygravity 3y agoSame in Europe. I've worked at 2 companies now that have been eaten by bigger ones and pretty much instantly moved to lower income countries. Both in manufacturing, one in aerospace.
- cabalamat 3y agoMore simply: don't outsource activities that have a complex interface to your organisation. Having to write complex specs for an outside organisation to implement is an anti-pattern, because: - the more complex a spec the harder it is to write and understand - there's potential for endless disagreements / lawsuits on what was actually promised and delivered - the overhead of having a complex spec that must be understood by people in both orgs.