5 ms·
The Flappie AI cat door stops your pet from gifting you dead mice
- petee 3y agoI was under the impression that pet microchips have an incredibly short read range, like you have to actually rub against the reader, and on target. The cat would have to be already passing through the door to be scanned. Are they just jacking up the transmission power, which makes me wonder why all the existing chip readers wouldn't do that as well if possible? I briefly looked at building such a chip reader until I saw the disance specs and realized it wasn't going to be practical to train a cat to rub the mid/back part of its neck on some protruding antenna
- bo0tzz 3y agoThe read range on the chips is definitely enough that it can be used for cat flaps. There's a few well established brands in the locking cat flap space, like Petsafe and Sure Petcare.
- ajb 3y agoHave a couple of these devices - the way they work is that they make the reader coil enormous compared to a flat RFID reader. The cat basically walks through it. Reading seems to work fine, although I'm not sure if it would if the chip had migrated far down the torso.
- logbiscuitswave 3y agoThe microchips are basically little RFID widgets that are about the size of a grain of rice. The chip can migrate from between the shoulder blades to anywhere else, and the range is really poor - basically near-contact range. I once tried a pet feeder that would read a cat’s microchip to determine if it would allow that cat to use it. It worked by having an arch with an RFID sensor that the cat would pass under and it would uncover the food for the matching cat. For one of my cats, it worked great because the chip was still between her shoulder blades in the usual spot. For my other cat it had migrated near her ribs and it didn’t work at all.
- f4c39012 3y agothe neighbourhood cats where i live are highly territorial - do cats really try to enter into other's houses, or are rfid locks to protect against other animals getting in?
- dangus 3y agoDon’t let your cats outside was the advice my vet gave me. They’re an invasive predator and their lifespan faces threats from human activity. Indoor cats live longer healthier lives. If you can modify your house to have a fancy cat door you should just go all the way and build a catio.
- hombre_fatal 3y agoJust put a jingle bell on their collar. My family cats growing up never caught anything since.
- thealistra 3y agoMy family cats just got stealthier with the bells and still brought pray and additional problem started - you could trip over the stealthy cat that came near you
- mschuster91 3y agoThese things are just as abusive to cats as cow bells are to cows. Imagine you would produce a noise every time you make just the tiniest movements during sleep - most people don't bother to put them off once the cat comes back into their house.
- darth_avocado 3y agoAnimals have different sleep patterns and attention spans than us. Cats and dogs usually tune out the sounds they know are not important.
- mschuster91 3y agoCow bells have been shown to reduce the amount of food the cow eats many years ago [1]; however the mechanism (sound vs weight) isn't clear. Farmers militantly oppose any attempt to get rid of cow bells though. Some claim that they aren't an issue for the animals, some whine about "traditions" getting endangered (which is even worse IMHO, to torture animals despite knowing better just because it looks good - ffs we managed to ban breeding of dogs and cats that we know to suffer), and others whine that they can't find escaped cows (just as ridiculous, even the 500g of a small cowbell is enough for a year-long battery and RF sender...) [2]. [1] https://www.schweizerbauer.ch/tiere/milchvieh/sind-glocken-fuer-kuehe-gefaehrlich-2 https://www.schweizerbauer.ch/tiere/milchvieh/sind-glocken-f... [2] https://www.fr.de/panorama/tierschuetzer-fordern-verbot-kuhglocken-11194617.html https://www.fr.de/panorama/tierschuetzer-fordern-verbot-kuhg...
- bo0tzz 3y agoTwo other recent examples of AI cat doors like this are https://www.onlycat.com/ https://www.onlycat.com/ and https://www.yourpawly.com/ https://www.yourpawly.com/.
- basil-rash 3y agoThey say the false-negative rate is 10%, i.e. 1 in 10 presents will be allowed through. But what about the false-positive rate? I would certainly not want my cat locked out indefinitely because some AI thinks a spot on its side looks mousy.
- chuckadams 3y agoThey'll sit there and meow for a bit, and if you're not around to let them in, they'll wander off and try again a little while later. I'd be more concerned about complicated gadgets like this breaking down completely.
- basil-rash 3y agoAnd if you’re away on vacation?
- chuckadams 3y agoIf the false positive rate is not 100%, their next try is likely to succeed. Unless, as I mentioned, the contraption just breaks entirely, which is why I'd be reluctant to have one of them in the first place.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> If the false positive rate is not 100%, their next try is likely to succeed Assuming they’re randomly distributed. If it’s 20% of cats getting rejected 50% of the time, that could be a problem.
- basil-rash 3y agoWe have no evidence that the failures are randomly distributed. What about when the failure mode is such that any time there’s not a massive blizzard outside, it works great. But when there is… icecat.
- 3y ago
- dsign 3y ago> So if your pet has been microchipped, you can make it so the cat door only opens for your specific pet. That's horrible! Won't the cat be allowed to bring their friends in for parties and cat-fights? What if the cat falls in love with a raccoon and wants to bring the raccoon and its friends for some interspecies sexy times? What sort of human is so intolerant?
- throwup238 3y ago> What sort of human is so intolerant? In my experience? Cat owners.
- wlindley 3y ago"Giving." (sigh)
- adhesive_wombat 3y agohttps://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/gift#Verb https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/gift#Verb And here's an use of it from 1670, so it's not a recently-verbed noun: https://archive.org/details/nature00lucy/page/137/mode/1up?q=gifting https://archive.org/details/nature00lucy/page/137/mode/1up?q...
- karaterobot 3y ago> Eventually, Flappie says that pets are likely to be trained that they can't enter when carrying something, and when they drop the prey the door will promptly unlock so they can get inside I guess a dead mouse on the porch is better than inside the house. $400 better?
- vidarh 3y agoMy brother has two cats, and the biggest problem is not the occasional dead mice, but the live ones, and when they bring other live animals, like birds. Particularly when they then lose interest in the animal after having let it loose in the house.
- TheChaplain 3y agoI'm starting to feel reeally old when I couldn't stop rolling my eyes over the fact "a cat door with subscription".