3 ms·
> At the same time, many, many people love it. Sure. That's what people tell themselves. Realistically, most people would prefer to live in a less dense area,
by cyberax 3y ago
> At the same time, many, many people love it.
Sure. That's what people tell themselves. Realistically, most people would prefer to live in a less dense area, but they can't do that because there are no jobs for them there.
> In NYC alone millions of people pay astronomical rents and mortgages for the privilege of living in tiny spaces in close quarters, no yards, etc.
Exactly. And it's getting _worse_ with every generation, right now NYC is at 530 square ft. per capita, down from 700 in 1980. It's even worse for Manhattan.
> It's not 'misery central', just something where you have a different preference.
Yes, it's misery central.
> Where does that come from? I understand we won't all have data all the time (I sure don't always), but until then, it's words.
I analyzed a database of all real estate sales in the US for the last 25 years. There is plenty of other research that found similar results. The _best_ outcome was something like transient single-digit percentage decreases in rents near new construction.
I don't have the links on my phone, but you can google the "Supply Skepticism" paper from the Furman Center. It's a nice overview of the literature, and it's written from the viewpoint of pro-density (to prevent questions about bias).
- wolverine876 3y ago> Realistically, most people would prefer to live in a less dense area, but they can't do that because there are no jobs for them there. Do you have evidence? I have the evidence of millions of people and the demand for downtowns. Otherwise, you possibly are assuming that people must feel like you do.
- cyberax 3y agoPlenty of surveys indicate that: https://time.com/3678811/millennials-suburbs-cities-survey/ https://time.com/3678811/millennials-suburbs-cities-survey/ https://app.hedgeye.com/insights/110394-americans-prefer-the-suburbs-more-than-ever?type=stock-and-policy https://app.hedgeye.com/insights/110394-americans-prefer-the... And so on. People really don't like cities.
- jubalfh 3y agoperhaps fucking americans hate fucking american cities?
- cyberax 3y agoNope. People in general prefer to avoid large and dense cities ( https://afry.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/new-survey-shows-majority-young-europeans-want-live-in-small-cities https://afry.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/new-survey-shows... ). It's just that only the US offers an affordable option to live in spacious suburbs. Europe simply doesn't have anything similar.
- jubalfh 3y agosure, jan. (and may i recommend reading the links that you post before you post them? it's bloody useful.)