I completely agree with your point about Pigafetta only writing from his own perspective. Perhaps a more poignant example was his naming of modern-day Guam as “

I completely agree with your point about Pigafetta only writing from his own perspective. Perhaps a more poignant example was his naming of modern-day Guam as “Isla de Los Robos” (island of thieves) because he could only perceive their communal society as one where people are constantly stealing from each other, despite spending over a month living amongst them while giving accounts of their harmonious society. As for the general state of academia, I would opine that modern scholarship’s “dark mass” is rooted in postmodernism, and the most successful way to operate as a modern academic is to present all evidence from a racial/colonial perspective. Although your guess is as good as mine, as is the BBC’s, since people also need to contend with the potential Internet backlash from presenting their views nowadays.