2 ms·
> "Unsecured AI also has the potential to facilitate production of dangerous materials, such as biological and chemical weapons." > "You could ask them to desi
by echelon 3y ago
> "Unsecured AI also has the potential to facilitate production of dangerous materials, such as biological and chemical weapons."
> "You could ask them to design a more deadly coronavirus, provide instructions for making a bomb [...]
Moreover, I call total bullshit.
I'd like for these people to show me how an LLM can instruct them to make a better virus.
Where's the hypothetical open source LLM that understands viral genomics? At the level of a PhD student?
Where?
Please show me. I'm waiting.
- EForEndeavour 3y agoIsn't the point here the potential risk? By definition, nobody can point to a textbook instantiation of the risk because it hasn't happened yet, and the question is whether and when it might in the future. It strikes me as similar logic to "you're saying I might get injured if I use this chainsaw without protective equipment? Well, show me the injury then!"
- echelon 3y agoOutside of very specific workplace safety regulations, nobody is trying to regulate chainsaws. Speaking of potentials, there's also a potential risk of outer space alien invasion, too. Yet our preparation here is appropriately scaled proportional to the risk. Where is someone going to get a BSL4 lab with the necessary inputs to follow through with these wacky James Bond plots? Maybe raise the alarm when splicing viral genes becomes a regular household occurrence. (And you don't even need to invoke the specter of LLMs for this scenario.)