6 ms·
Pinker was right, I was wrong
- williamcotton 3y ago[flagged]
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y ago[flagged]
- notso411 3y ago[flagged]
- mardifoufs 3y agoWell that's one hell of a whatboutism. Just for your info, Israel killed more civilians since October than Russia did in Ukraine since 2014. That's why we focus on them. If anything, the complete lack of western official condemnation regarding that is a perfect example of just how much slack is given to israel. Also, Israel is extremely open about its plans which also makes it easy to be really quite alarmed. What more is needed? >On October 10th an Israeli official told a television station: “Gaza will eventually turn into a city of tents. There will be no buildings.” Daniel Hagari, an idf spokesperson, boasted that “hundreds of tons of bombs” had been dropped on Gaza. Then, he added: “the emphasis is on damage and not on accuracy.”
- bitcurious 3y agoI see this curious bit of misinformation repeated quite often, but believing it requires one to be quite credulous. You have to believe Hamas casualty numbers but ignore IDF, AND you have to believe Russian casualty number but ignore Ukraine’s. Weird, right? If you listen to Ukrainians, who I have to believe are at least as credible as Hamas, something like 25k civilians died in Mariupol’ alone.
- dralley 3y ago> Just for your info, Israel killed more civilians since October than Russia did in Ukraine since 2014 Just for your info, that's complete BS. The people making this claim are comparing the deaths in Ukraine which the UN has independently confirmed (and discriminated from military casualties) against claims which have not been independently confirmed nor discriminated from military casualties. Russia does not allow investigators behind their lines, so the official figures are a significant undercount - a fact which the UN themselves have specifically called out themselves as being the case. It is entirely possible and even likely that more Ukrainian civilians died in Mariupol alone than in all of Gaza. At a minimum, as of more than a year ago, there were 10,300 new graves dug around Mariupol, as seen from satellite pictures. Pictures of those graves suggest that many of them contain more than one body, which was also the case in Lyman when the mass graves there were excavated. But none of the new graves in Mariupol are in the UN statistics because they cannot be considered "verified" without access. And the stories of what has been going on in Mariupol from the handful of people that managed to escape and get back to Ukraine are every bit as bad as Gaza if not worse. And that's one city. https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-war-erasing-mariupol-methodology-f74b28016b8dea4b82811655f14931f2 https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-war-erasing-mariup...
- mardifoufs 3y agoTo be clear I'm not trying to minimize Ukrainian deaths. My point was more so that it was at least comparable, and in the same order of magnitude. Yet the international reaction to one is completely different to the other ( I mean, in terms of concrete action against Israel and Russia). That's the double standard and the unlimited "slack" given to Israel that I was talking about. The IDF can come up with any excuse for bombing any number of civilians, with absolutely 0 proof given and again, they are just automatically believed. I mean, they are cautious about civilian deaths... they told us so!
- dralley 3y agoThat isn't at all clear from your comment, your claims are pretty direct and concrete.
- williamcotton 3y ago[flagged]
- Arn_Thor 3y agoThe Western media is so focused on it—over other conflicts—because we (in the West) are witnessing an ethnic cleansing committed by a country whose population has strong familial and cultural ties with the West. (Obligatory notadefenseofhamas)
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoCareful, comments like that get flagged around here
- bitcurious 3y ago.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- seesawtron 3y agoIn today's environment, moralists would argue "it's immoral to not have an opinion, i.e. if you are in a position of power and are not actively using your voice to reach out to your audience in order in favour of populist opinions, you are in the wrong." I don't know what to make of it. I think it's great that people fight for what they believe in but at the same time, "inaction" is becoming more and more difficult.
- brnt 3y agoInaction is unfortunately rarely neutral, let alone objective. I think is right to point that out, even if not always done tactfully.
- cs702 3y agoThe author is Andrew Gelman, whose posts are popular on HN. He agrees with Steven Pinker, whose posts are also popular on HN, that universities do NOT have a mandate to tell society what emotions to feel in response to events, nor what the correct moral position should be in response to them. In the OP, Gelman announces he has changed his mind and now agrees with Pinker that university administrators should "shut up and do their job" (Pinker's words), providing the most impartial forum possible for professors and students to argue these issues, i.e., adopt the "Kalven Principles" (https://president.uchicago.edu/from-the-president/announcements/2006-2021/100520-kalven-report https://president.uchicago.edu/from-the-president/announceme...). --- EDIT: Added quotes around "shut up and do their job" to make it clear that those are Pinker's words, not mine.
- lapcat 3y ago> Gelman announces he has changed his mind and now agrees with Pinker that university administrators should shut up and do their job No, that's not what he said. This is what he said: "The problem is not with academic leaders “having a foreign policy” in the sense of expressing opinions and seeking to achieve political change; it’s with expectations or demands such as Emanuel’s that academic leaders should have a foreign policy, that it’s part of the job, that it’s a matter of leadership." In other words, condemning atrocities is fine, but it's optional, not a required part of the job. --- EDIT: The title of the article is clearly tongue-in-cheek. If you don't realize that, and you take the title 100% literally, you've missed something crucial. It should be clear when the author begins by talking about "wearing earth tones, driving Priuses", which he still thinks is an absurd stereotype by Pinker. Also: "So here’s where I agree with Pinker. Or, to be more precise [emphasis mine], where I agree with his implicit point [emphasis mine]." Further quotes to show what the author is really talking about, which is the demand that university leaders make statements: "The trouble is, there are so many issues out there? How much “leading” does he demand that university leaders do?" "But then there’s the question of where to stop, which atrocities to condemn. You wouldn’t want a university president to become the equivalent of an outrage-of-the-week blogger." "Again, my problem is not with university leaders, or business leaders, or church leaders, etc., expressing views, but rather with the idea that this is what they are supposed [emphasis mine] to do." The coup de grâce: the author says in the P.P.S. that he was still right on this one, this one being a link to an article titled, "Steven Pinker is a psychologist who writes on politics."
- pierat 3y agoEvery time one of these an article comes up that says that what Israel is doing (and has been doing for decades) against Palestine is *WRONG* , people come out of the woodwork to call it "antisemitism". (look in "showdead") Yes, the WW2 Holocaust happened. That doesn't entitle the current Jews living in Israel to "1 free holocaust" coupon. I took "Never Again" to actually be just that. But in reality it's "Never again to us, and anybody who denounces us is antisemitic!"
- practicemaths 3y agoIf you read the history of the conflict, Palestine only exists today because Israel gave them land that they (Israel) won from wars that neighboring countries started. Additionally, Israel called dibs first, that is Palestinian/Arabs could have declared themselves a country as soon as the British mandate ended but chose not to. Instead Israel did first and was attacked by neighboring countries which caused the majority of the Palestinian diaspora.
- cool_dude85 3y ago>Palestine only exists today because Israel gave them land that they (Israel) won from wars that neighboring countries started. The internationally accepted borders of Israel are based on the 1949 armistice. Israel did not "give" Gaza or the West Bank to Palestine, those are simply the borders. Israel started the 6-day war in 1967 that led to the present occupation.
- practicemaths 3y agoThat's inaccurate. Egypt was shutting down Straits of Tiran which started the war: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straits_of_Tiran https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straits_of_Tiran
- cool_dude85 3y agoClosing the straits is not a reasonable justification for war. Would Cuba be justified in invading or bombing the US under your rationale?
- bjourne 3y agoThat American universities have "foreign policies" is pretty damn obvious given how different the treatment of Russia's war and occupation of parts of Ukraine is from the treatment of Israel's war and occupation of Palestine.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoOnly if you lack any understanding of how these conflicts came about maybe. They are not equivocal at all.
- dron57 3y agoLet's see. One is a brutal, colonial invasion with the intent of totally replacing the local population. And the other is Israel responding to the rape and murder of hundreds of their civilians.
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoBy killing 23,700 Gazans so far, mostly women and children? And possibly this came about because the Israeli government allowed money to Hamas to split the Palestinian governance? And possibly the Palestinians don't like being treated in the same way that blacks were treated in South Africa (i.e., second-class citizens)? And wasn't there something about government supported attacks happening in West Bank? Israel does have a right to defend itself. It also has an obligation to be humane, and if it wants to continue existing without internal conflict with its neighbours, perhaps this is not quite the best way to do it. "“Colleagues who have managed to make it to the north in recent days describe scenes of utter horror: Corpses left lying in the road. People with evident signs of starvation stopping trucks in search of anything they can get to survive,” Martin Griffiths, UN Under-Secretary-General for Humanitarian Affairs and Emergency Relief Coordinator, told members of the UN Security Council on Friday. " - https://edition.cnn.com/2024/01/12/middleeast/gaza-corpses-on-streets-un-official-intl-hnk/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2024/01/12/middleeast/gaza-corpses-o... Does any of that matter to you? Edit: @josephg "The Health Ministry in Hamas-run Gaza said Saturday that 135 Palestinians were killed in the last 24 hours, bringing the overall toll of the war to 23,843. The count does not differentiate between combatants and civilians, but the ministry has said about two-thirds of the dead are women and children." - https://www.chicagotribune.com/nation-world/ct-aud-nw-israeli-airstrikes-gaza-strip-20240113-tehtoxw4ubh23krjr4jiyivzxa-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/nation-world/ct-aud-nw-israel... "For years, the Qatari government had been sending millions of dollars a month into the Gaza Strip — money that helped prop up the Hamas government there. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel not only tolerated those payments, he had encouraged them... Allowing the payments — billions of dollars over roughly a decade — was a gamble by Mr. Netanyahu that a steady flow of money would maintain peace in Gaza, the eventual launching point of the Oct. 7 attacks, and keep Hamas focused on governing, not fighting." - https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/10/world/middleeast/israel-qatar-money-prop-up-hamas.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/10/world/middleeast/israel-q... (edit 2: snotty comments removed)
- kamikaz1k 3y agoThe problem with some of these abstract arguments is that people forget to carve out exceptions for circumstances, and shifting norms. Nobody likes busybodies who calls the cops for the most mundane of neighbourhood infractions. But what happens when a bunch of people with different values move in? Will the people who just mind their business say anything? Do anything? Agree with both Gelman and Pinker here, around expectations of people having “an opinion”. But what’s missing from Gelman’s critique of the other fellow, is that you do also need leaders to enforce some norms. There should be some values. And if you can’t agree to what those values are, there definitely is a problem. Times have changed, there’s too much lazy tolerance now, and people do need to organize around some common values that isn’t just what is the progressive de jour.
- _a_a_a_ 3y ago> And if you can’t agree to what those values are, there definitely is a problem I don't see how that's the case. The only way we could agree entirely on those common values is to be entirely homogenous as a group, and that is not the case and in my view, deeply undesirable. (I suppose another way we could agree entirely is to be entirely conformist, but that doesn't seem very attractive either). > Times have changed, there’s too much lazy tolerance now, and people do need to organize around some common values that isn’t just what is the progressive de jour. Well that comes across as "I want more of my values in society, not yours because they are wrong". If you gave some reasons for why yours are correct and mine aren't, I'd be interested.
- azinman2 3y ago[flagged]
- phmqk76 3y agoThis is disingenuous. The issue isn’t, in a vacuum, whether college leadership needs to weigh in on the Hamas massacre. The broader context is that university leaders jump in with both feet regarding literally everything else. The question isn’t whether universities should be opining on every issue - it’s that they do, and have for years, and the explicit omission here was itself a signal that Jewish life means less than others.
- steveBK123 3y agoPrecisely the model minority problem
- 34750987234 3y agoI would love to be able to read more about the personal journey people have taken to arrive at their opinions. Like how does one person end up on one side of the debate, and then someone else on the polar opposite. They are both human. How did the process differ between the two. There was a time when they had no opinion, and then there is a time when they are waving flags in the street and thinking about it all the time. What are the critical moments? What are their contact points with news and propaganda? Why don't journalists ask about this? Instead we hear each side explain their understanding of the situation in a subset of points that ChatGPT could basically have written. What is more interesting is to ask people why they think other people have a different opinion.
- analog31 3y ago>>> Should a university have a foreign policy? Was it given a mandate to tell a grateful nation what emotions to feel in response to a national event, or what the correct moral position is? At Harvard, many colleagues & I will urge the university administration to shut up and do their job of providing an impartial forum for profs & students to argue these issues Harvard is not "a university." Harvard profits from the disproportionate amount of attention that it receives, and the power that it confers to its graduates. Sure, it should be responsible for its foreign policy. How about the public university down the street from my house? Should it have a foreign policy? Yet our university will suffer from the political backlash against Harvard's shenanigans.
- hackandthink 3y agoGelman rejects the idea of having to march in step and recite the official slogans in the right tone of voice at the right time. He approaches the matter somewhat indirectly. These people are more direct: https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2024/01/03/kpiz-j03.html https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2024/01/03/kpiz-j03.html
- imjonse 3y agoA clever title to serve as a starting point for an insightful post, but he's not actually disagreeing with what Pinker wrote, and he did not actually change his opinion that much recently. The conclusion is as I understand it is that he feels academics should be free to have political opinions and it's good to be involved in trying to affect change, but they should not be expected to have public opinions on every hot topic and especially align them with those of the government, mass media or various think tanks.
- JohnCClarke 3y agoSilence and/or neutrality support the powerful. If the powerful are acting morally and well, then all is good. If not, silence and/or neutrality are harmful.