6 ms·
Would Luddites find the gig economy familiar?
- verisimi 3y agoGreat article - captures my understanding and sentiments exactly. There's nothing wrong with technology. But if the whole emphasis is extractive, taking from those with only a little power and wealth, for the benefit of those who have the abilities to constructs world-spanning businesses, this is entirely dystopian. Eg - who wants privacy? Everyone. But, if you have governments and businesses acting in tandem to force everyone to be de-anonymised, this is dystopian. Alternative eg - people talk about what happened to the early internet - well it is all sandboxed now, in extractive corporate sites eg facebook, snapchat, insta, etc. Its hard to see too, because the plan is unfolding over decades - incrementalism towards dystopia is the name of the game, apparently.
- is_true 3y agoThis is sad. I built a solution to help thousands of small business owners make a living and the moment I offered the service to one of those business owners that had a lot of money, he wanted to buy the solution and cut off everyone else.
- dotcoma 3y agoNot sure. Luddites knew a craft; most of the people ‘employed’ in the gig economy lack knowledge and real skills.
- femiagbabiaka 3y agoCitation needed.
- dotcoma 3y agoI wish I could help you. Citation needed regarding what? That Luddites knew a craft? I thought this was known and/or accepted. The revolt was largely against new machines that delivered lower quality products at a much lower cost, with workers being paid a fraction of what they were used to. Or regarding that most gig economy workers don’t have qualifications? I thought this, too, was accepted. Not many are SWEs earning 1k a day or more. Most deliver you pizza or stand in line so you can have the newest iPhone on day-1. There’s even a website called TaskRabbit. It doesn’t sound like gigs offered there are very qualified.
- hef19898 3y agoYou seem to live in quite a bubble. Working in the gig economy is more about a lack of options than a lack of qualification. And the Luddite movemebr was as much about working condition as it was about pay, e.g. having children do maintenance on running machinery being maimed and crippled. Luddites were no backward people, they wanted a livelihood, one the lost during the industrial revolution. Maybe that is too hard to research and understand, when you are so qualified and busy making 1k per day as a software whatever.
- dotcoma 3y agoIf you are referring to me, I am not a software engineer and I make nowhere close to 1k a day. Nor do I think Luddites were backward people — not at all. On the contrary, I think that, mutatis mutandis, we could learn quite a bit from their struggle.
- jampekka 3y agoOr their knowledge and real skills don't get used because we've decided they are better exploited as servants for overpaid paper pushers, like us programmers, who can't bother to even move themselves to a restaurant.
- gumballindie 3y ago> overpaid paper pushers Oh don’t worry, that’s changing.
- jampekka 3y agoYep. Sooner or later capital makes sure that working doesn't pay off.
- eru 3y agoThat hasn't happened so far ever. What makes you think it will happen soon?
- jampekka 3y agoHas happened many times before and is happening again right now. https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/employment-and-growth/a-new-look-at-the-declining-labor-share-of-income-in-the-united-states https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/employment-and-gr...
- eru 3y ago> The labor share of income in 35 advanced economies fell from around 54 percent in 1980 to 50.5 percent in 2014. 3.5% in 34 years is not exactly something to get all luddite about. Also keep in mind, that it's not the capital share that's expanding at the expense of labour. It's the share that goes to land that's taking from labour. The capital share is relatively stable. (Alas, few apart from the Georgists care about differentiating between land and capital.)
- franga2000 3y agoThe equivalent of the Luddites here aren't all the gig workers, they're the people who are "rising up" against gig work. Many of them are now themselves gig workers because they had nowhere else to go (like former taxi drivers driving for Uber now), but their skills and training are no longer valued and they get the same inhumane wage as those who have none. Meanwhile the rest of us get lower quality for a lower price and no ability to pay more if we want.
- eru 3y agoYou can hire a driver without using Uber. You can pay more for better service. (And you can even give Uber more money to get better service, within some limits.)
- al_borland 3y agoYou can pay Uber for a nicer class of car, service seems like it would always be a roll of the dice, as that is up to the personality of the driver. Even when going with the cheapest option on Uber, getting a nicer car is luck of the draw. On my last weekend trip where I took a few Ubers, I always picked the cheapest option, and we had 3 new Teslas, Model S, X, and Y, and a new Benz. No beat up old Toyotas. I’ve had people pick me up in luxury SUVs who mention they are Uber Black, but took my fare because I was close, it wasn’t any better than an UberX with a friendly driver. I’d be curious to know how many people actually pay for things like Uber Black. How long is someone going to be in the car where it’s really worth paying 2-4x the price? It seems like it’s more of a status or ego thing.
- franga2000 3y agoOutside of the super high end, the middle ground is simply not available any more where I live. Even the old taxi companies, under pressure from our regional Uber-copycat, have switched to an app-only, quantity-over-quality, throughput-focused model. I can't call and book a ride at a specific time in advance (this used to be possible, of course with a waiting fee), the drivers will no longer let us make detours or stops on the way because their next ride is already booked by the time they pick you up, they drive like maniacs to hit their time targets, all while constantly fiddling with the three phones stuck to their dashboard viewing and accepting rides from the three platforms they "work for". All of this for a 20% decrease in fees (which started rising back up the moment a near-monopoly was established) and having them "all in one app", even though there are now 3 "all in one" platforms, each with their own set of quirks that you need to remember just like we had to remember for the different taxi companies before.
- randomdata 3y agoYet the canonical example of gig work is the Uber driver – a job that requires a tremendous amount of knowledge and skill. The trouble, economically, is that most people have had a vested interest in acquiring that particular knowledge and skill, making it common, and thus, by the properties of supply and demand, not terribly valuable.
- brandall10 3y agoI'm having trouble parsing this comment... if facetious not following the point. If not, what is the knowledge and skill outside of having a driver's license and the ability to work a smartphone?
- randomdata 3y agoWhat are you asking, exactly? Driving clearly requires a lot of knowledge and skill, from the workings of vehicles to the rules of the road, and a lot of practice to be able to develop the skill necessary to move the vehicle around in the framework. Nobody is born able to drive and nowadays most jurisdictions require a lengthy apprenticeship under another experienced driver before one is able to move into being licensed to drive on their own accord because history has proven that it takes a long time to develop the necessary skills. Even then, it is questionable if drivers are skilled enough, but such is life. Indeed, it is a common skill[1], at least in car-centric North America where there has been a strong incentive for all to learn those skills. That makes it not particularly valuable to offer as a service. Why pay someone to do work you can, in most cases, just as easily do yourself? It has to be quite cheap for you to consider it. But that's something else entirely. [1] Albeit a dwindling one. While ~85% of American adults have their driver's license, only ~60% of 18-year-olds do, down from ~80% in the 1980s. The youth today are backing away from obtaining this particular skill as compared to the past.
- HPsquared 3y agoSpeaking English (or any other language) is an even bigger, more complex skill than driving - and we take it for granted too. Basic electrical service in houses is the result of a huge effort to build infrastructure. There are many examples of these "complex but ubiquitous" resources.
- hatenberg 3y agoJesus that’s a peak techbro comment that couldn’t be more tone deaf. You will find out what it means to have your valuable skills replaced by technology soon enough - just as for example translators have found out.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- pylua 3y agoI would argue taxi driving was a craft before it got commodified. Being a good taxi driver especially in a big city required specialized knowledge of the city. Before cars also got more common driving skills were more of a craft. I wonder if the day will come where this happens to lawyers and doctors with ai. The main point is that the bar is constantly rising and most people can’t stay above it.
- zer00eyz 3y ago"You don't need a formal conspiracy when interests converge." - George Carlin The luddites are also what happens when a group of people who have a historical corner on a market revolt. IF we let them have their way a shirt would be 8k (at 15 bucks an hour) https://www.sleuthsayers.org/2013/06/the-3500-shirt-history-lesson-in.html https://www.sleuthsayers.org/2013/06/the-3500-shirt-history-... Further, those looms, they evolve to jacquard looms (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacquard_machine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacquard_machine) , that are backed by the punchcard. Primitive numerical control at its finest! The fountainhead for Babbage and Lady Ada to conceptualize computing! IN the end the luddites were skilled labor (the gig economy for the most part isn't). They were being displaced by mass production. Something that happens over and over again (bricks, files, pots...). Industrialization led to us all having enough free time for vacations, the internet and hacker news. The price of progress, haiving to keep up with it.
- sgu999 3y ago> Industrialization led to us all having enough free time for vacations, the internet and hacker news. I believe you forgot to mention that it also led us to ruin our environment in the process. Not trying to argue that we should always oppose "progress", but maybe there was a better middle ground of shared prosperity a bit before Deliveroo, Amazon and Shein.
- hef19898 3y agoThe reason we have vacation, health care, a social net, <70 hours, Edit: no more (the pleasure of writing on mobile sometimes...) 6 day work weeks and all that is because workers (blue collar, as oppossed to pampered white collar like the majority of us on HN) fought tooth and nail for it. Thosen riviledges we enjoy are bot something that came automazically during the industrial revolution. And assuming it will different this time is a grave mistake.
- dotcoma 3y ago> <70 hours, 6 day work weeks… Where do you live? The standard, at least in Europe, is 40 hours and 5-day work weeks.
- cornholio 3y agoInnovation is always disruptive and the best positioned to take advantage of the disruption are the capital owners. If you have the money, you can simply buy stock in the latest tech IPOs or angel ten AI startups. The switching cost is low. Those who only harness their own human capital have massive switching costs, as the example shows, a famous Luddite learned for 7 years a trade that was made obsolete by machines. This has always been the case, yet innovation was historically beneficial creating new winners and social mobility. What could be different this time compared to the Luddite era is that machine progress happens at an ever faster rate, until you reach fundamental - biologic and social - limits of the humanity's ability to adapt, especially as workers age. The majority of people will never be programmers or stock traders, and the market for those professions is shallow anyway. This is all to say that it seems the fundamental social contract of capitalism - that the benefits of innovation are redistributed to everybody through competition and growth, employing more people in new industries and lowering real prices of machine manufactured goods to almost nothing - seems seriously threatened going forward in the AI and super-internet-company age. If the majority of the workforce can't adapt fast enough to become productive with the new methods, then they are redundant as far as capital is concerned; not only do they not make a living wage, they won't make any wage, since whatever they are able to do a machine can do it cheaper. So you would end up with this near-feudal arrangement where returns to capital can be maintained in perpetuity as long as capital owners can maintain IP rights, strong walled gardens, control over limited mineral and natural resources, or keep innovation and disruption going using the services of a few loyal samurai-innovators, the tech salaried class.
- gumballindie 3y ago> seems seriously threatened going forward in the AI and super-internet-company age The real threat is ai companies stealing people’s products and reselling them. It’s as if they stole the furniture luddites made, dismantled it, reassembled it and the sold it for a profit. A real shame that ai has been taken over by Sociopaths. I suppose punishing one or two will send the message.
- cornholio 3y agoI presume you alluding to the fact that, without pre-existing human creation, tools like Midjourney or Chat-GPT and their output are not possible, so the original authors rightfully deserve compensation. But artificial intelligence is much more than artistic or text authorship. It will replace most service workers, most agricultural workers, drivers, doctors, vast segments of society become redundant in the next century. If you could press a button and duplicate the garment made by a Luddite at zero cost, would you consider that machine "stealing"? Should we smash that machine, or should we rather develop a new social contract aware of its existence and power?
- Jedd 3y agoOftentimes when Luddite comes up on HN I quote a bit of John Ralston Saul - today will be no different. From his most excellent book 'The Doubter's Companion', an alphabetically ordered series of delightful rants on various topics. On the subject of Luddites, he writes somewhat presciently: "Highly trained individuals whose careers were destroyed by technological progress. This progress was treated as inevitable and uncontrollable. The Luddites therefore occupied the only remaining intellectual position, which consisted of rejecting technological progress. "This reduction of attitudes to two extreme positions was accomplished between 1811 and 1830 when the introduction of Watt’s steam-engines and water-driven wool-finishing machines made hundreds of handicraftsmen redundant. Industrialization was spreading from sector to sector and quickly eliminated most crafts along with tens of thousands of jobs. "The Luddites (named after an imaginary leader, Ned Lud) broke up and burnt factories. Their revolt ended in a group trial in 1813. Five were hanged. The attitude of society towards unrestrained technological progress was made perfectly clear. The judge said the Luddites’ actions were “one of the greatest atrocities that was ever committed in a civilized country.” 1 "This was a classic case of provocation and order versus despair and disorder. Wilfrid Laurier described the nature of this type of conflict when he spoke in 1886 about the Riel Rebellion. “What is hateful...is not rebellion, but the despotism which induces that rebellion; not rebels but the men who, having the enjoyment of power, do not discharge the duties of power; the men who, when they are asked for a loaf, give a stone.” "What society misunderstood early in the nineteenth century when faced by the industrial revolution was the full nature of the change. The debate should not have been over whether there should be technological progress or not. It was more accurately a question of progress in what conditions: what progress, when, in what circumstances? Market extremists would argue that what happened was inevitable and eventually brought general prosperity. Their view ignores the social disorder, followed by suffering, followed by serious social disorder that this approach towards change brought on. Communism was the direct result. England, France, Germany and Sweden suffered recurring internal violence throughout the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, some of it expanding into civil wars. Most of these countries passed within a shadow of revolution. "The question is therefore not whether technological progress was necessary, but whether it was necessary to go about it in a barbaric manner. It can be argued that the Luddites were wrong in 1811. But society spent the next 150 years rendering progress civilized and thereby proving that the infuriated craftsmen had been right at least in spirit. Did these decades of wasted time, effort, lives and money represent an intelligent use of human talents? " The recovery of the quote true meaning unquote, and implications of, Luddite feels similar to the change in consensus around a frog's actual response to being in gradually warming water, or a goldfish's actual short-term memory capabilities. We're aware - and it's uplifting to find TFA dwells on this morphing of our collective understanding - that there was a generally agreed trope, since subverted / rectified, but in this case, unlike our amphibian or piscine revelations, we still find ourselves in desperate need of a way to succinctly describe a relatively calm but firm desire for society to work on an inclusive way of navigating significant social changes wrought by technology before we end up having to react violently to same.
- atribecalledqst 3y agoUber is an interesting example to me because where I live, it really did revolutionize taxi service. They used to not take credit cards and you used to have to fight for them at the end of the night when bars closed. Plus taxis were usually much less clean than an Uber car. That industry badly needed to be disrupted to make it less of a shitty experience. On the other hand, I'm sympathetic to people losing their livelihoods because of Uber and am generally opposed to the 'giggification' of everything that Uber seems to have ushered in. It feels like there was a better way to handle the innovation.
- appplication 3y agoI agree. I think, in general, Uber was a good thing. Cab companies really were one of those shitty monopolies that treated their customers poorly because they had no pressure to innovate or even listen to their customers much at all. The main issues with Uber are not that it’s a gig economy job, it’s that it externalizes much of the costs to drivers in ways that are difficult for the average driver to amortize. Beyond that, it can be something of a trap. It requires very little skill to drive, and there is essentially no upward mobility or ability to upskill through continued labor. But that is not unique to Uber.
- ghusto 3y agoThank you for this. Finally, some vindication for Luddites. I hear the term used here in a derogatory way a lot, by people who think no further than "more == good".
- al_borland 3y agoYou’d probably enjoy this episode of 99% Invisible, as well as the book that inspired it (if you haven’t already listened/read). https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/blood-in-the-machine/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/blood-in-the-machine/ I’ve heard Luddite used a couple ways. One is derogatory, the other is by people self-identifying as Luddites when they get tired of the endless pursuit of technology for technology’s sake, or they get tired of “smart” everything. Sometimes a nice mechanical tool that will last generations is better than the new fancy version that will be trash in a very short period of time.