8 ms·
[stub for offtopicness]
by dang 3y ago
[stub for offtopicness]
- andsoitis 3y ago> It’s only recently that I’ve begun to properly internalize just how broad the implications of having a computational language really are—even though, ironically, I’ve spent much of my life engaged precisely in the consuming task of building the world’s only large-scale computational language. Exemplar of humility.
- danpalmer 3y agoIt sounds like once you get the zen of Mathematica, it’s a truly exceptional tool to work with. It’s a shame that the only person it seems has get the zen of Mathematica is Stephen Wolfram himself.
- qsort 3y agoI mean, it really is good software. It's by far the best CAS around and the "standard library" is extremely impressive. But like all software it involves tradeoffs. Fanatics of any technology or idea are never the easiest people to reason with.
- wolverine876 3y agoAgreed, but what are the tradeoffs for Mathematica?
- jampekka 3y agoMathematica has the best CAD capabilities for many/most tasks, but the language is rather horrible. E.g. code can not be commented, the program state is difficult to manage or even reset, it's very tied to the Mathematica "notebook". And it's quite idiosyncratic. I sometimes have to use it where Sympy fails, and every time it's almost constant WTF. And it's very proprietary and very expensive.
- baq 3y agoNote it's free on the raspberry pi! https://www.wolfram.com/raspberry-pi/ https://www.wolfram.com/raspberry-pi/ If you have one collecting dust in a drawer, I'd heartily recommend checking it out.
- lispm 3y agocheck the license, though. https://www.wolfram.com/legal/agreements/wolfram-mathematica-raspberry-pi/ https://www.wolfram.com/legal/agreements/wolfram-mathematica...
- sampo 3y ago> code can not be commented Mathematica has a C-like syntax for comments (* this is a comment *) but it doesn't have C++ style comments // This is a C++ comment
- Iwan-Zotow 3y ago> And it's very proprietary and very expensive get free kernel and wljs notebook
- qsort 3y agoComes as a big monolithical block that's much harder to work with if you have to develop bigger systems, language tooling is lacking even compared to something like Python that's already mediocre, in many aspects (data analysis/data engineering, machine learning, etc.) isn't as good as other options like Python or R. It's also not great as a general purpose language. It was never meant as such of course, but working in a real language where I can take stuff off a notebook and have it become a script has its advantages. Finally, I'm willing to use open-source software that's slightly worse if the difference isn't huge, and for many use cases the difference isn't huge. For some it is, and that's where Mathematica is great.
- hacketthfk 3y agoIt is a bit Zen, but if you don't use it for a few months you forget everything because the syntax is so different.
- contravariant 3y agoIn his case the zen of mathematica is that people will write a slick function for whatever he is interested in at the moment. Everyone else needs to deal with stuff like '#1 + #2 & @@@ # &/ @'.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- baq 3y agoWolfram should get a dedicated title tag (Wolfram) and hn rules should be amended with ‘this dude is a bit full of himself, everybody knows that, no need to bring it up’ Saying that as someone who’s consistently surprised by just how big his ego seems to be, getting bigger each year, didn’t think it’s possible.
- _kwef 3y agoWhen you've done as much as him any kind of ego that you may possess becomes justified.
- Tomte 3y agoThe admin has already decreed exactly that. People just love to whine.
- nxobject 3y agoOr, for that matter, just come together in community and crack jokes we can all agree on, at the expense of someone we all know. Call it A New Kind of Socializing.
- hacketthfk 3y ago[flagged]
- qsort 3y ago*μ-Wolframs
- cturner 3y agoThis could be covered if there was a principle to respect the man in the arena. That should also discourage you-reinvented-the-wheel pile-ons. The Ratatouille critic put this well - "We risk very little, yet enjoy a position over those who offer up their work and their selves to our judgement. We thrive on negative criticism, which is fun to write and to read."
- markusstrasser 3y agoWhy are people getting hung up on his hubris? If his megalomania gives us Mathematica who cares. It's a phenomenal accomplishment. It can, out of the box, do hundreds of things that'd take you weeks in python/julia/etc or would be entirely impossible for most in other systems.
- wolverine876 3y ago> Why are people getting hung up on his hubris? If his megalomania gives us Mathematica who cares. We've had some bad results taking that approach recently - which we really should have anticipated, with millenia-old stories warning us about it. For one thing, megalomaniacs tend to be frauds (perhaps because, to be a megalomaniac, it's necessary to lie to yourself); maybe Mathematica will turn out to be the FTX, or Tesla auto-pilot, or ..., of mathematical software/languages. No way - how could that happen? All those people at Mathematica would just go along with it, right? There's no evidence! It would be too brazen!
- andyjohnson0 3y ago> We've had some bad results taking that approach recently I'm struggling to believe that Wolfram's hubris is anything like that of Trump or Musk or SBF etc. Wolfram seems like a genuinely smart person who knows he's smart, but is probably too aware of it. But he's not done anything majorly bad - and arguably has done good in creating tools for scientists and engineers. I think we need to give him a break. I certainly think that the perennial discussion of his ego is tiresome and distracting.
- nextaccountic 3y ago> megalomaniacs tend to be frauds Eeeh. Scott Aaronson review [0] and Cosma Shali's review [1] of NKS kinds of points to this direction, so he may well be a fraud. The plagiarism case regarding rule 110 (and attempts to hide this through NDA and lawsuits [2]) doesn't do him any favors, either. Indeed maybe the biggest problem of Wolfram isn't the megalomany per se, but the total unwillingness to give credit to others and cite their damn papers. Wolfram simply isn't in the business of sharing his bibliography, which is problematic for a scientist. However, the newer Wolfram Physics [3] [4] looks so damn promising that I'm willing to entertain possible quackery. I mean it surely has many ideas regarding how a digital universe would look like; he may be all wrong in the details but his ideas look important contributions to me. I sometimes think what's like to be at the frontier of science; today we take relativity (for example) for granted but there was a time when it was up in the air. When I read Wolfram's stuff stuff I just think this could very well be true, and while there's absolutely no evidence for it the conjectures all make sense. [0] https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0206089 https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0206089 [1] http://bactra.org/reviews/wolfram/ http://bactra.org/reviews/wolfram/ [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13961947 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13961947 [3] https://www.wolframphysics.org/ https://www.wolframphysics.org/ [4] https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2020/04/finally-we-may-have-a-path-to-the-fundamental-theory-of-physics-and-its-beautiful/ https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2020/04/finally-we-may-h...
- noneoftheabove 3y ago[flagged]
- zvmaz 3y agoIt maybe be irrational, but the absolute arrogance of the author is off-putting and makes me reluctant to use any of his creations (which may be great I don't deny). I may have developed a heuristic that tells me to be very suspicious of people that are so sure and full of themselves as to become dangerous because they can be spectacularly wrong. It may have stemmed from the pandemic... So, sure, you are smart and clever, but no.
- notso411 3y ago[flagged]
- agumonkey 3y agoI never really got what made people so allergic to Wolfram. After the many outrages online I tried to dig and I never found anything shocking. There's not too many mention of "I" or too many self flattering hyperboles.. so I don't know.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Qem 3y ago> I never really got what made people so allergic to Wolfram. After the many outrages online I tried to dig and I never found anything shocking For me it was trying to pass his employees work as if it were his own, through NDAs and lawsuits, like happened in this case: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_110 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_110 https://www.complex-systems.com/abstracts/v15_i01_a01/ https://www.complex-systems.com/abstracts/v15_i01_a01/ We only know this case because the employee fought back. Makes one wonder how many similar cases happened but never surfaced.
- agumonkey 3y agoOh interesting.
- 3y ago
- kjellsbells 3y ago> In the arc of intellectual history it defines a broad, new, computational paradigm for formalizing the world. I am in awe of what Wolfram achieved with Mathematica. And also the size of their ego.
- castles 3y agoAre they wrong :) ?
- throwup238 3y agoI was honestly expecting Wolfram himself to have claimed the invention of LLMs or transformers, probably by saying it’s really a scaled up implementation of some other function in Mathematica.
- seanhunter 3y agoJoking aside, he sort of implies this in his essay explaining GPT models[1] At some level this reminds one of the idea of universal computation (and my Principle of Computational Equivalence), but, as I’ll discuss later... And his "Principle of Computational Equivalence" is [2] "There are various ways to state the Principle of Computational Equivalence, but probably the most general is just to say that almost all processes which are not obviously simple can be viewed as computations of equivalent sophistication." Which a cynic might say is mighty convenient, because this is non-specific enough that you can apply it to basically anything and say you invented it and/or it's equivalent to something you invented and if it doesn't quite fit, you can use the "various ways to state" clause to weasel-word your way into something which does. I find Stephen Wolfram frustrating for this reason. Benoit Mandelbrot is another guy who constantly seems to claim he invented everything, eg the Efficient Markets Hypothesis (which Mandelbrot basically claims he invented because he gave Eugene Fama some advice about the price process for stocks when Fama was a PhD student even though Fama/French was after that and Mandelbrot's idea of the price process for stocks is very obviously and demonstrably wrong if you know about market microstructure and/or look at trade marketdata[3]). [1] https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2023/02/what-is-chatgpt-doing-and-why-does-it-work/ https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2023/02/what-is-chatgpt-... [2] https://www.wolframscience.com/nks/p716--outline-of-the-principle/ https://www.wolframscience.com/nks/p716--outline-of-the-prin... [3] At a microstructure level price movements are made up of individual trades which jump around wildly with gaps in both the time and price dimension, and it has a base level beyond which you can't "zoom in" any more- it isn't some kind of fractal scaling in time and/or volatility which is what Mandelbrot wants it to be.