> It is, in fact, voluntary: private companies that do not want to share attack data with the government are not required to participate. A bill that provides

> It is, in fact, voluntary: private companies that do not want to share attack data with the government are not required to participate. A bill that provides incentives (for example, legal immunity without any restrictions) is just as bad as a mandate. So that's a terrible argument, irrespective to the rest of your statements.