6 ms·
What a weird comparison. Nobody is saying we should drill oil and gas instead of wind turbines.
by adastra22 3y ago
What a weird comparison. Nobody is saying we should drill oil and gas instead of wind turbines.
- yellow_lead 3y agoWell, there have been campaigns and articles for years attacking wind energy on the basis of protecting birds.
- janmalec 3y agoMay I introduce you to our lord and saviour nuclear energy.
- osigurdson 3y agoIt blows up though.
- saagarjha 3y agoGenerally it does not. Makes a lot of people upset if things don’t work out, sure.
- osigurdson 3y agoAgree. Usually it doesn't blow up but sometimes does. When it does, all of the squirrels in the area get 3 eyes and 5 legs.
- smileysteve 3y agoMore accurately they suffer defects and die. Then there is Chernobyl which now has healthier and more diverse wildlife than much of the world because humans have evacuated.
- osigurdson 3y agoChernobyl was good then?
- smileysteve 3y agoIn the micro, no, see the part about death. In the macro, it created a nature preserve that humans will barely visit, won't hunt in, won't deforest; and requires no active enforcement to keep that way.
- osigurdson 3y agoSo positive NPV in a sense?
- adastra22 3y agoYou have a strange, anti human morality.
- Alifatisk 3y agoHow often does such incident occur?
- osigurdson 3y agoNot often but sometimes.
- renaudg 3y agoYeah and planes crash and it's spectacular, but they're still the safest means of transportation by far.
- osigurdson 3y agoPlanes are fast though. Even if less safe that cars we would still use them.
- adastra22 3y agoAnd nuclear is cheap. It is literally free energy.
- osigurdson 3y agoIf someone gifts you the facility and the staff work for free then maybe.
- bittercynic 3y agoNuclear energy is a little scary to me because I suspect it makes it more economical to build nuclear weapons. -Many more people become atomic experts, and they may be hired by weapons programs in the future. -We will learn how to deal with nuclear materials more efficiently - good for energy, but maybe also good for building weapons. -With more nuclear material being manufactured for energy, will it be easier to hide weapons manufacturing in the mix? I'd like to acknowledge that I'm speaking from ignorance here. I don't know much about nuclear technology.
- ceejayoz 3y agoNuclear weapons aren't that tough on a nation-scale to produce. It's generally thought that places like Saudi Arabia, Japan, Australia, etc. could make a nuclear weapon in a few months if they really wanted. The barriers are more geopolitical than anything.
- adastra22 3y agoNuclear weapons have very little to do with nuclear energy.
- bittercynic 3y agoCan you elaborate on that? Are the processes for making fuel for energy so different from the processes for bomb material that one doesn't help the other at all?
- audunw 3y agoThat's a "yes, and" kind of thing. We can't build nuclear fast enough yet. So we need both. I'd argue that wind and solar is much more important at this point since the growth of those is now faster than nuclear has ever been. And fast growth of non-fossil energy sources is priority #1 right now. We can free up some land later with nuclear. Wind and solar isn't going to push any species to extinction, so any damage is reversible. Though I'm a bit wary of nuclear given there are studies indicating that the heat energy added by thermal power plants contributes surprisingly much to global warming. If we can replace all thermal power plants with renewables that's a nice contribution to reducing global warming. On the order of CO2 emissions from planes if I remember correctly. I'm sure we could "afford" the heat from thermal power plants if we didn't have so many greenhouse gases. But when we're already so close to the edge of the cliff, every little bit counts.
- kika 3y agoIf we produced a gigawatt of energy by cleanest way possible, where do you think this gigawatt ends up? Some "energy dumpyard" somewhere outside the solar system?
- pjc50 3y agoIn the long term .. yes? The temperature is a balance between energy incoming from the sun and energy being radiated off into space. Wind and solar don't change that balance directly, although the lower reflectivity of solar panels makes a small local difference. Ultimately it's the transmissibility spectrum of the atmosphere that matters. Which is why we care about CO2 in the first place.
- awiejrilawej 3y agoI'm genuinely curious, why are there so many extraordinarily pro-nuclear people on this forum? And how many of them have greater than zero experience with nuclear anything? I worked in the nuclear power industry for a decade and people in the industry are not as maniacally pro-nuclear as the people in this forum.
- evandale 3y agoThis forum has lots of highly intelligent individuals and nuclear power is the most intelligent energy source to switch to so we can stop relying on fossil fuels. Perhaps you were working with people who don't feel the need to talk about how great nuclear is all the time because you all work in the industry and understand that already.
- pjc50 3y agoIt's weird, isn't it? There's a lot of nuclear cheerleaders, and it makes me suspicious when they're also anti-renewables rather than "yes, and". Essentially everyone has forgotten the arguments of the nineties: nuclear weapons proliferation, waste dumping, and covering the entirety of western Europe in a thin layer of airborne radioactive particles. As well as the more practical cost overruns. Personally I think it would be worth someone giving SMR a go, but in a different country from me and at their own expense.
- gcheong 3y ago"nuclear weapons proliferation,..." Seems like we got that anyway thanks to the military industrial complex without getting much in the way of nuclear energy generation.
- pjc50 3y agoLots of places built dual-purpose reactors? The initial UK nuclear program (Windscale) was weapons-first. The famous French reactor programme and their independent nuclear deterrent are also linked. Also, this is why people are reluctant to let some of the world's larger carbon emitters, the oil states in the middle east, build nuclear reactors. Iran has a small, heavily monitored fleet.
- mrweasel 3y agoThe people who are concerned about wind turbines killing birds also tend to not want nuclear power plants.
- smileysteve 3y agoAnd by wanting nuclear, within the context of the build pace of nuclear is to support the status quo - ie oil and gas. It's the same conclusion as hydrogen car investment. It's easy to maintain ice technology, but the generation, storage, trabsport, use are riddled with issues.
- beaeglebeached 3y agoOf course, if your neighbor has a good turbine spot and you don't, you have to look at it while his property's utility rises over yours. That, cannot be tolerated. They're free to move to industrial zoned land if they want to be a power plant. (Neither the ag-backwoods voters controlling their zoning nor capitalists installing them are hyper concerned about sparrows getting chopped up. It's a ruse.)
- sunshinesnacks 3y ago> That, cannot be tolerated. Why, exactly?
- beaeglebeached 3y agoIf you search zoning meeting wind turbine Google images it will be revealed quickly. Scan the demographic. Old people who've already gotten theirs with mostly invented blame for ailments. It's all downside for them, to see their landscape change and plant a tree who's shade they'll never see.
- red1reaper 3y agobah, old people is the reason why we are climatically bad in the first place, its a downside they are going to have to accept.
- sunshinesnacks 3y agoI originally thought you were arguing that wind turbines should not be able to be installed on someone’s property if they can’t also go on the neighbors property, but now I’m not sure. Was your first comment sarcasm? Maybe I’m just misreading.
- beaeglebeached 3y agoIt was sarcasm.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoThe Canadian province of Alberta has more or less this exact policy.
- gnabgib 3y agoThe province with the most solar (1511mw to #2-Ontario's 944mw[0]), and most wind power (4431mw to #2-Ontario's 3822mw [1]) in the country? [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_photovoltaic_power_stations_in_Canada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_photovoltaic_power_sta... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wind_farms_in_Canada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wind_farms_in_Canada
- dghlsakjg 3y agoI didn’t say that they don’t have green energy. I said that they currently have a government policy that is designed to promote oil and hinder green energy projects. https://www.wsj.com/world/americas/canadas-oil-rich-alberta-province-halts-renewable-energy-projects-96c3e369 https://www.wsj.com/world/americas/canadas-oil-rich-alberta-...
- imafish 3y agoWhat would be a better comparison?
- adastra22 3y agoNuclear. Solar. Geothermal. Hydro.
- nfriedly 3y agoI think some people are saying exactly that.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThey absolutely are saying that. https://theintercept.com/2021/12/08/oil-industry-wind-farm-prevent/ https://theintercept.com/2021/12/08/oil-industry-wind-farm-p... > The plan, which was approved in 2017, sanctioned a Danish company to build a 120-megawatt capacity wind energy project — enough to power 40,000 homes by placing turbines 26 nautical miles offshore. The letter warned that the project would “irreparably damage beach tourism, home values and the economy,” “lower rents generally,” and produce “no environmental benefit.” “In fact,” the letter claimed, “regional air quality would become worse because of them.” > While the letter was signed by a local resident, it made little mention of its true author: the Caesar Rodney Institute, a libertarian think tank at the time funded by the oil industry. The subterfuge was intentional. In an interview with the State Policy Network, a group that coordinates best practices for oil-and-gas-backed and libertarian think tanks, the Caesar Rodney Institute said it produced the letter and had it signed by a local concerned beach homeowner to “establish rapport” with the target audience of local residents and merchants.
- genman 3y agoYet those opponents of the wind turbines want to have all the benefits of the modern society like medicine and transportation and that sweet electricity that enables the electromagnetic waves used for planet wide communication. It almost feels like they are shilling for oil and gas companies or for authoritarian regimes that receive their main income from oil and gas drilling.
- osigurdson 3y agoIt really doesn't matter what anyone wants. Hydrocarbons are a huge but decreasing part of the energy mix. Eventually we will not use them but it is going to take 50-100 years.
- tasty_freeze 3y agoI don't know where you are, but in the US there is a large percentage of the population who claim to believe that, who claim that "green coal" is a thing, and they vote like they believe it. Former President Trump has repeatedly stated that wind turbines are terrible for birds. I'm no mind reader, but it is also a fact that he owns a coastal golf course and sued to prevent development of a wind farm because he didn't want his golfers experience to be affected by seeing offshore wind turbines. 2016: https://www.factcheck.org/2016/06/trumps-hot-air-on-wind-energy/ https://www.factcheck.org/2016/06/trumps-hot-air-on-wind-ene... 2018: https://www.factcheck.org/2018/09/trump-again-overblows-risks-of-wind-power/ https://www.factcheck.org/2018/09/trump-again-overblows-risk... 2019: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/dec/23/trump-bizarre-tirade-windmills https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/dec/23/trump-bizarr... 2020: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/donald-trump-wind-energy-kills-birds-presidential-debate-joe-biden/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/donald-trump-wind-energy-kills-... 2023: https://www.newsweek.com/fact-check-are-thousands-bald-eagles-killed-wind-turbines-1778304 https://www.newsweek.com/fact-check-are-thousands-bald-eagle... I'm sure if I looked beyond the first page of search results, I could fill in the other years. Some information about the lawsuit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump_International_Golf_Club_Scotland_Ltd_v_The_Scottish_Ministers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump_International_Golf_Club_...
- dangus 3y agoMy Fox News Dad sure does.
- ajuc 3y agoThere's currently a big public debate in my country regarding relaxing building restrictions for wind turbines, and all the FUD about noise levels, killing birds etc is very much in use. Current law is so harsh that you can build a coal powerplant closer to peoples' houses than a wind turbine :) That's despite the fact we have the worst air pollution in EU and the wind turbines would replace coal powerplants... TL; DR: you're wrong.
- mrweasel 3y agoYou are sort of correct, nobody is saying that directly, but that is the result. The people who are concerned about wind turbines killing birds aren't offering any alternatives, that would be widely accepted, so the result is fossil fuel, because that's what we already have in place. The anti-nuclear protests in the 60s and 70s also didn't want fossil fuels, but they also didn't understand that an increase in fossil fuel usage was the alternative, because it was the only one that made financial sense.
- pjc50 3y agoA lot of the anti-nuclear protests during the Cold War were against nuclear reactors because of nuclear weapons, which offered a much more immediate threat against the habitability of the earth.