2 ms·
If one reads the complaint, really all the complainant is trying to do is to change his subscription from unpaid to paid. First he subscribes to Facebook and I
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago
If one reads the complaint, really all the complainant is trying to do is to change his subscription from unpaid to paid.
First he subscribes to Facebook and Instagram for free, an unpaid subscription where he agrees to receive targeted ads.
Next he tries to change his subscription to paid, presumably with terms where Meta agrees not to send targeted ads.^1
Signing up for the unpaid subscription can be done with a single click.
Signing up for the paid subscription cannot.
"When the complainant finally reached the correct page, he was confronted with two options. The first preselected and reflecting his current situation was to continue using Facebook with trackers (Kostenfrei mit Werbung verwenden). The second entailed the purchase of a 9,99 monthly subscription, in order to have access to the service without being tracked (Aboabschlieen und ohne Werbung verwenden) see screenshot below, left side."
There should really be a third option: unsubscribe.
1. But does data collection still continue. Meta would probably argue it needs to track everything the complainant does while logged in to the Facebook and Instagram servers for "security" but without any restrictions on how they can use the data collected. We have already seen Facebook and Twitter getting caught using collected telephone numbers for commercial purposes when they were collected under the guise of being needed for "security". Even more, is Meta still allowed to track the complainant on the open web, outside of Meta's websites. The claims of "security" arguably do not apply there.
Is Meta still collecting and processing the complainant's data regardless of which subscription he chooses. If yes, then arguably he is only revoking consent to have ads placed on the Meta webpages that he accesses. The consent may not relate to data processing.
How does the GDPR define "data processing".
For example,
"Data processing is the collection and manipulation of digital data to produce meaningful information." French, Carl (1996). Data Processing and Information Technology (10th ed.). Thomson. p. 2. ISBN 1844801004.
Meta could still "collect and manipulate data [from the complainant] to produce meaningful information" but refrain from placing ads in webpages viewed by the complainant.