4 ms·
3.5 has, or had, a particular style. No matter what the story, it had a cheerily up-beat ending. The invading aliens learned the errors of their ways and then e
by ben_w 3y ago
3.5 has, or had, a particular style. No matter what the story, it had a cheerily up-beat ending. The invading aliens learned the errors of their ways and then everyone celebrated. Dracula, Winnie-the-Pooh, and Sherlock teamed up to fight crime.
4 is somewhat more interesting, and I've seen worse from actual humans, but… roll a d6, and on a 1-5 it's terrible, roll a 6 and you get something that's 90% fantastic and 10% just a bit off. For example, this story: https://github.com/BenWheatley/Fiction/blob/main/The%20Silent%20Anthem/The%20Silent%20Anthem.md https://github.com/BenWheatley/Fiction/blob/main/The%20Silen...
I like it, but if I really examine the thing, the details don't quite line up right. The humans were supposedly primitive, yet "[t]heir cruisers absorbed salvos that would've shattered lesser vessels"?
And sure, there are a million oddities like this in "proper" fiction[0]; but this… still feels like Stable Diffusion in text form. It's cool, it's a technological marvel, it's still, ineffably, not quite right.
[0] Even ignoring that the top speed in the pilot episode should've gotten them home in 7 years rather than 70, Voyager had a bajillion ways to get home sooner — for example, putting the crew in stasis so they didn't age, going at a normal speed, and then using any of the time machines Starfleet keeps tripping over.
- FiddlerClamp 3y agoIt's got no dialog, no characters, no real scenes. It's a summary of a plot, not a story.
- ben_w 3y agoOK, so the things you don't like about it are effable rather than ineffable, but none of what you say changes that I do, in fact, like it[1]. To me, it's fine that it has no named characters, no dialog. One of the most grating things in plots with aliens is the names, no matter if they're American names like the spiders in A Deepness in the Sky, or the Star Trek pattern giving us random apostrophes and internal capitalisation, where "Q'ting'pAh" could easily be either Klingon or Vulcan. [1] Not all of the output of 4, like I said it's mostly bad, but that I like this particular result.
- duskwuff 3y ago> no matter if they're American names like the spiders in A Deepness in the Sky This is a bit of a tangent, but: you missed an important point in that book with some broad implications. Those weren't the spiders' names, those were the translators' deliberately humanized names for the spiders. (And, to bring the discussion back home: no language model would have ever come up with a clever narrative trick like this.)
- ben_w 3y agoI didn't miss it ;) Just because it had a good in-universe reason didn't stop it being grating.