9 ms·
None of the examples given showed liquidity being added, because the people involved would have traded with each other directly without an HFT being there....In
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
None of the examples given showed liquidity being added, because the people involved would have traded with each other directly without an HFT being there....In every example OP gives...
You clearly ignored one of my examples.
Consider the example of Fry and Zoidberg. Fry places his sell order at 12:01. Leela and Bender are absent, so Fry's order goes into the book. Zoidberg places his buy order at $9.50 at 12:05. The bid/ask spread is now $0.50 and Fry has not traded.
In this case Fry is better off with Leela in the market.
At any point that an HFT is willing to buy stock, it's because there's a high likelihood that someone will show up to pay more after a few seconds or minutes.
If you want to take that risk, place an ALO order at the bid or ask price. You won't cross the spread, though your order might go unfilled.
The fact that most people don't place ALO orders suggests they don't want to take the risk.
- bo1024 15y agoWill your proposal be along the lines of "only allow trades every x (milli) seconds, and randomize among the bids/asks submitted in the most recent time interval"? This seems like the most natural, simple solution one might suggest. How does it sound to you? (Edit: sorry, this doesn't really relate particularly to this sub-topic.)
- yummyfajitas 15y agoNo, my proposal is much simpler.
- wtvanhest 15y agoI don't think that SomeCallMeTim understands that 0.10/share is a lot of money ($100,000) when a mutual fund is trading 1 million shares over 10 days. Now mulitply that by 60 holdings which are turned over 100% per year and you can see why pensions would want those mutual funds to save $6,000,000/year in liquidity costs. (Obviously mutual funds don't just do program trades, they also negotiate directly with each other etc. but the example still stands).
- pdovy 15y agoExactly. Even more direct benefit to retail investors - low liquidity costs mean that we can invest in mutual funds and especially ETFs that have extremely low fees. Those funds have to shuffle around their holdings as investors come and go, and they'd have to charge a lot more if they were paying $0.10 to cross the spread.
- wtvanhest 15y agoThe ETF concept could be interesting to look at. I was reading Tryenor's book and I thought he mentioned how entering an ETF position still nets out below an index return because of the cost of liquidity. I wonder if ETFs would have ever grown as large as they had if HFT never existed (the time periods of the rise of ETF parallels to the rise of HFT.) Anybody have any insight here?
- JumpCrisscross 15y agoThe success of ETFs is probably significantly underwritten by the increased liquidity. As a rule of thumb liquidity makes markets less volatile and thus able to sustain more complex structures. ETFs control tracking error, how closely the ETF follows the index to which it is benchmarked, by letting authorised participants (APs) arbitrage the ETF against the underlying. For example, if you are a SPY AP, you can turn in a certain quantity, called the creation unit, of S&P 500 constituent stocks and "create" the correct number of ETF units. Alternatively, you could surrender a creation unit of SPYs and the ETF trust would "destroy" those ETF units and issue you the S&P 500 constituent stocks [1]. The risk for APs increases non-linearly vis-a-vis the liquidity of the underlying. This has been empirically witnessed as a "U-shaped relationship between fund premium and market liquidity, which suggests that more active trading does lead to lower mispricing but only after a certain level of liquidity is reached" [2]. [1] http://www.londonstockexchange.com/traders-and-brokers/security-types/etfs/education/how-etfs-work/how-etfs-work.htm http://www.londonstockexchange.com/traders-and-brokers/secur... [2] http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1468-0416.2008.00144.x/abstract;jsessionid=1E87344267C3527B187A656E565B88D9.d01t01?userIsAuthenticated=false&deniedAccessCustomisedMessage= http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1468-0416.2008....
- sakai 15y agoThat example, however, it not solely germane to ultra-HFT. More traditional market makers have provided that level of liquidity for a long time. Do you have an example of where sub-100 ms execution truly adds significant liquidity? I'm open to listening, but have never heard a convincing case for why HFT below such a time threshold adds net value (i.e., enough to make up for the volatility it can cause). Edit: Changed to "solely germane"
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThat example, however, it not solely germane to ultra-HFT. More traditional market makers have provided that level of liquidity for a long time. The studies I link to provide compelling evidence that traditional market makers provided much lower levels of liquidity. Do you have an example of where sub-100 ms execution truly adds significant liquidity? Please reread my post starting from the words "The Latency Arms Race".
- nhaehnle 15y agoActually, out of the three links the first one does not talk about HFT at all, but about algorithmic trading. I don't think anybody seriously thinks algorithmic trading is bad per se. The third link talks about reducing the bid/ask spread. Fair enough. However, what people seem to forget in these discussions is that if you are genuinely trading in the long run, then the bid/ask spread is mostly irrelevant anyway, because it is totally dominated by intraday fluctuations. Whether I buy at the offered price at 12am vs 1pm makes a much bigger difference than whether a HFT reduced the spread by some small amount. I have yet to see an argument that the sum of intraday fluctuations + bid/ask spread is helped at all by HFT. So one study remains (this one: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1624329 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1624329). This one might genuinely apply - I haven't had the time to go through it - but the abstract isn't exactly enthusiastic, and probably disregards the social costs that come from people being sucked into the field. So I am still skeptical. Confirmation bias applies as well, I guess ;)
- ChristianMarks 15y ago
- SomeCallMeTim 15y agoUmmm...so the only example where an HFT has helped someone out is the one where the HFT screwed up and lost money? In other words, the better an HFT gets, the less benefit they're providing. This isn't doing much to convince me. Yes, in that case, it would suck to be Fry. But the problem at that point is that the price dropped before Fry got his order in, and that's a price of doing business in the stock market. Considering that an HFT would do all in their power NOT to be helping Fry in that case, it doesn't really support your position. You're not in this to try to help people like Fry; you're in this to AVOID helping people like Fry as much as possible. >If you want to take that risk, place an ALO order at the bid or ask price. ALO? How does that differ from a limit order? I only ever use limit orders when buying or selling stock -- and pretty much every bit of investment advice I've read recommends that you only ever use limit orders, though advice on where to place your limit varies. If "most people" use market orders, well, most people also lose money in the stock market.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoUmmm...so the only example where an HFT has helped someone out is the one where the HFT screwed up and lost money? Yes. This isn't all that uncommon - see insurance companies, for example. Without Leela, the problem is not that the market moved before Fry got his order in. The problem is the market moved before his order was filled. ALO? How does that differ from a limit order? It's a limit order which Adds Liquidity Only. But it's not even necessary in this case - if Fry is willing to accept execution risk, he can place a sell order at $10.05 instead of $10.00: Sell(Fry, $10.05, 100) Sell(Leela, $10.05, 100) ---------------- Buy(Leela, $10.00, 100) Buy(Bender, $10.00, 100) If Zoidberg and Amy each buy 100 shares, Fry's order gets filled. If not, Fry loses money. Fry could also have placed his sell order at $10.04 and jumped the queue: Sell(Leela, $10.05, 100) Sell(Fry, $10.04, 100) ---------------- Buy(Leela, $10.00, 100) Buy(Bender, $10.00, 100) In this case Fry gets filled before Leela, so he doesn't need Amy to show up.
- SomeCallMeTim 15y agoInsurance companies don't have to screw up for people to benefit from having insurance. >the market moved before his order was filled. In what tangible way is this different from "the market moved before Fry got his order in"? The market for a particular stock depends on there being people who are willing to buy it. Saying "the market moved" blurs the fact that there simply weren't any buyers at that price any more by the time he got his order in. If we're talking about a stock with a lot of volume, and Fry "jumps the queue" by setting a limit order in the current spread (something I almost always do myself, FWIW, based on that same investing advice I mentioned), then he'll sell his stock with or without HFTs. What value does the HFT add in this case? The argument is that HFTs add liquidity. Don't HFTs only work with stocks that have high volume? How is adding liquidity when there's already high volume a value?