5 ms·
The largest US dam-removal effort to date has begun
- 11235813213455 3y agoDams age with damages
- engineer_22 3y agoIt's a dam shame
- k12sosse 3y agoWas hoping I'd see some Post.10 footage
- londons_explore 3y agoHow does removing a dam compare with simply opening the gates and releasing all the water? A dam not holding any water back has far more strength than necessary and will probably last thousands of years. It's obviously far cheaper. You get many of the same environmental benefits (lake area no longer flooded, fish can traverse the base of the dam).
- mistrial9 3y ago> imply opening the gates and releasing all the water would that be step 1 perhaps? without much thinking about it, I would expect that the shape of the waterway structure may not really match a natural water course at all. For example, quite a lot of the release mechanisms would be at the top third of the dam wall, etc. Probably very specific to each dam?
- markedathome 3y agoSwitzerland are building a dam next to another dam that can no longer be repaired, B1M have a video going over the method - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0vxzYvIHUk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0vxzYvIHUk
- dylan604 3y agoThe spill way being opened won't release all of the water from a dam. Spill ways are just a type of pressure relief valve to keep the water from destroying the damn. So while it might add more water down stream, it will do nothing for restoring the flooded area upstream of the dam.
- parl_match 3y agoFirst off, that's opening a spillway, and that will still leave a substantial portion of land flooded. > A dam not holding any water back has far more strength than necessary and will probably last thousands of years. And, actually isn't true, there's a lot of complicated factors when building a dam, and having a consistent, low lying waterflow (like a river). Depending on the type of damn, soil conditions, etc, it can actually cause disproportionate erosion that will cause the damn to collapse in on itself (occasionally in a surprisingly short time frame, sometimes under a decade even - or in the case of heavy waterflow, hours or days). So, engineers will sometimes do what you suggested when it's feasible. But, it's not always.
- pengaru 3y agoThere aren't gates at the base of any large dam. The only way to discharge the artificial lake behind a large dam is via destruction AIUI. It will deteriorate with age and eventually break in an uncontrolled/unplanned manner anyways. At least this way you tear it down gracefully with a gradual discharge of the water, and enable restoration of the environment/salmon breeding etc.
- phyzome 3y agoWouldn't there still be a diversion tunnel or channel from when the dam was originally constructed? I wonder if those could be used to empty a reservoir. Or maybe the water pressure and flow rate of a full reservoir would be too high...
- pengaru 3y agoI don't think those are sealed upon completion in a gracefully reversible manner. My guess is dynamite blasting and dumping stone to collapse/fill it in until the water stops flowing. This short video[0] describes the process used for the Hoover Dam... sSounds like the blasted diversion tunnels were above the river level, then ad-hoc "cofferdams" were filled in both upstream and downstream of the construction site. So even if you reopened the diversion tunnels, it still wouldn't be down to the original level. It certainly doesn't seem like it'd be a controlled release of the water if you could manage to unseal them. There's no gate... [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9Gy_1Ppw5U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9Gy_1Ppw5U
- Arrath 3y ago> My guess is dynamite blasting Exactly right! I was involved in a 'lake tap' project in Oregon where the concrete plug in the diversion tunnel was mechanically demolished down to the minimum safe thickness, then we came in and finished it off with explosives. A gate structure was first built farther down the tunnel, to allow the operators to again close off the tunnel or chose a given flow level and let me tell you, having to sidle sideways through that partially open gate to go place explosives into the remnants of the tunnel plug was an interesting experience. Here is a presentation put together on the project: https://ndiastorage.blob.core.usgovcloudapi.net/ndia/2005/triservice/track1/schlenker.pdf https://ndiastorage.blob.core.usgovcloudapi.net/ndia/2005/tr...
- patmorgan23 3y agoNo, most dams are not designed to be able to completely disengage and completely discharge their entire reservoir. Some dams don't even have gates and are entirely passive structures.
- gerdesj 3y agoSpillways. I'm not too sure you have any idea about what you are talking about. Anyway, water at scale is a scary thing. A cubic meter of water is a tonne - 1000 Kg. Look at any river or even a stream and try and mentally construct a cross-section. Say 30m wide and say 3m deep, and assume a 75% section - that's 30x3 = 90x0.75 = 67.5m^2. Let's call it 70m^2. If the flow in this river is 1 ms-1 then 70 tonnes of water flows per second. That's roughly one and a bit main battle tanks per second! 1 m/s = 2.2 mi/h Let's set walking speed at 3 mph and a river in spate at say 15mph (6.7m/s). Far worse has been seen. Now you have 70m^2 x 6.7ms-1 = 469 tonnes of water per second. Let's call it 500 tonnes per second.
- fckgw 3y agoDo you think a dam looks like the gates from Jurassic Park?
- psc 3y ago> You get many of the same environmental benefits (lake area no longer flooded, fish can traverse the base of the dam) Besides the fact that the lake area will still be partially flooded, as other replies have said, fish are complicated and there are a lot of dam related issues that affect fish passage. Just a few: - Downstream passage would have to be through spillways. Survival rates are pretty good (95%+) [1], much better than turbine passage, but not as good as not having a dam in the way. - Conventional spillways open from bottom, which fish have a hard time finding. [2] Granted, if the water levels are reduced this could be less of an issue. - Time spent in slow moving water increases predation on salmon. [3] If you visit a dam you'll see ospreys all around. Slow water can also favor some species over others. - There are a bunch of other water quality issues that dams cause, most notably water temperature. The 2002 Klamath fish kill [4] (the largest in history and a major impetus for un-damming the Klamath) was caused by high water temperatures. [5] - Even shadows can cause significant issues, from structures as small as docks or piers. [6] - Upstream passage is not solved by opening the spillway and would still be an issue, requiring fish ladders or transportation. All the existing problems with fish ladders apply. [7] - Besides salmon and trout, other important species get blocked by dams, including sturgeon and lampreys [8], and each are affected by dams in their own way. [1] https://www.salmonrecovery.gov/Hydro/Structuralimprovements/Surfacepassage.aspx https://www.salmonrecovery.gov/Hydro/Structuralimprovements/... [2] https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/west-coast/endangered-species-conservation/juvenile-downstream-passage-west-coast https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/west-coast/endangered-species... [3] https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/west-coast/endangered-species-conservation/how-dams-affect-water-and-habitat-west-coast https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/west-coast/endangered-species... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2002_Klamath_River_fish_kill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2002_Klamath_River_fish_kill [5] https://www.waterboards.ca.gov/waterrights/water_issues/programs/bay_delta/california_waterfix/exhibits/docs/PCFFA&IGFR/part2/pcffa_155.pdf https://www.waterboards.ca.gov/waterrights/water_issues/prog... [6] https://wdfw.medium.com/casting-shadows-on-the-sound-3a9a55563b9b https://wdfw.medium.com/casting-shadows-on-the-sound-3a9a555... [7] https://medium.com/re-form/whats-the-dam-problem-3b5cd839ae74 https://medium.com/re-form/whats-the-dam-problem-3b5cd839ae7... [8] https://e360.yale.edu/features/sea-lampreys-pacific-lampreys-american-rivers-dams https://e360.yale.edu/features/sea-lampreys-pacific-lampreys...
- 3y ago
- abtinf 3y agoThis is how you know that perhaps the climate change movement’s actual priorities are different from their stated priorities.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gopher_space 3y agoPerhaps you'd talk about the connection between dams and a climate change movement a little. I'm a little familiar with both and don't see a connection.
- nostromo 3y agoDams provide clean energy. Getting rid of them is bad for climate change.
- kemotep 3y agoMany of these dams are actually causing ecological damage and have also outlived their usefulness and are not sustainable to continue operating and may even cause significant environmental problems if left in place. Do you know of an example of one of these dams being replaced with coal or gas plants?
- gopher_space 3y agoAhh ok we aren't talking specifics but more of a "general feeling about dams" from the layperson perspective.
- daelon 3y agoCount me as extremely skeptical of the climate change "movement", but even I don't understand what kind of connection you're implying here.
- kemotep 3y agoCould you elaborate why this specific dam removal project reveals that?
- nostromo 3y agoThis is another case where some environmentalists can be more emotional than rational, similar to opposition to nuclear energy. Dams provided the cleanest, most consistent energy of any source. They also are very effective at energy storage via pumping. We can try to mitigate damage to salmon, but honestly, we're just going to have to let some salmon die to not cook the earth. I doubt the US will ever be able to build another dam due to NIMBYs and other red tape. So when we get rid of a dam it's gone forever.
- michaelt 3y agoAmerica isn't the kind of country that would remove dams for purely environmental reasons. The fact is, a lot of these dams have long passed their designed lifespan and they're crumbling, a disaster waiting to happen. And though somewhat productive, they're not so productive anyone is about to write a check to cover the maintenance.
- cbb330 3y agoAmerica is the type of country to do negative “human” perspective actions for purely environmental reasons: https://www.government-fleet.com/10193319/military-charging-forward-with-fleet-electrification https://www.government-fleet.com/10193319/military-charging-...
- Analemma_ 3y agoIn your rush to dunk on your political enemies, you neglected to read the part of the article where it says the vast majority of these dams being removed do not generate any power and were constructed for water diversion or erosion control.
- marssaxman 3y agoYou might want to look at the quantity of power involved before drawing such a conclusion. The article begins with a mention of the dam removal project on the Elwha River: these were the second- and third-smallest hydroelectric plants in the state, generating only 28 megawatts together. In the year that the larger of the two dams was demolished, Washington State installed ten times that capacity in wind power alone. Two thirds of the state's electricity still comes from hydro. The four dams being removed in the Klamath project offer similarly diminutive capacities: 18, 20, 27, and 98 megawatts respectively. By way of comparison, California is currently installing about 4000 megawatts of solar per year. The dams will not be missed.
- jonbraun 3y agoGreat occasion to bring up Patagonia’s (the brand) DamNation documentary: https://youtu.be/laTIbNVDQN8?feature=shared https://youtu.be/laTIbNVDQN8?feature=shared
- islandert 3y agoI'm finishing up reading Cadillac Desert, a book describing the history of dam building and irrigation project in the US. It goes deep into all aspects of irrigation projects from environmental to economic to political. Very cool to hear that this dam is getting torn down just 30 years after the book was published.
- CoffeeOnWrite 3y agoGreat book. If you like fiction, also check out The Monkey Wrench Gang.
- Arrath 3y agoSeconding that recommendation!
- water-data-dude 3y agoThat book’s a classic for a reason! It’s a fascinating read, whether you’re a water nerd like I am or not - very accessible. I tell people to check it out if they enjoyed Chinatown, since the historical episode it drew inspiration from is so much wilder
- mullingitover 3y agoIt's not even a big loss in clean energy. Oregon solar has been on a roll, their total solar capacity graph[1] shows a very hockey stick-shaped line for the past few years with no sign of letting up. I would wager the state will add more solar generation capacity than it lost from this dam in a matter of months if the trend (the graph ends in 2021) has held up. The eastern half the state is high desert and has plenty of sun. [1] https://www.oregon.gov/energy/energy-oregon/Pages/Oregon-Solar-Dashboard.aspx https://www.oregon.gov/energy/energy-oregon/Pages/Oregon-Sol...
- LargeTomato 3y agoJust for my own reference, is transferring power from Eastern Oregon to Western Oregon a reasonably efficient thing to do? How much power is lost when we move it across an area the size of Oregon?
- mjevans 3y agoLess of a loss than selling energy from Texas to California. Edit: Much more information generally: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_power_transmission#Losses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_power_transmission#Lo... "For example, a 100 mi (160 km) span at 765 kV carrying 1000 MW of power can have losses of 0.5% to 1.1%. A 345 kV line carrying the same load across the same distance has losses of 4.2%."
- margalabargala 3y agoWikipedia tells me that high voltage lines transmitting 1GW at normal grid voltages will have losses of about 1% over a distance of 100 miles, which is honestly quite a lot. That's 100kW per mile. Oregon is only a couple hundred miles across, so it's feasible, but with more losses than I thought when I looked it up to answer you.
- Arrath 3y agoThere's also a goodly quantity of wind generation capacity in/along the Columbia gorge.
- 3y ago
- Element_ 3y agoIsn't the Canadian government currently building and refurbishing some of the largest dams in the world just north of there in British Columbia? I wonder how the impacts compare to the dams being decommissioned in the article.
- philistine 3y agoThe dams being decommissioned are all really small compared to those great big BC dams.
- fumeux_fume 3y agoI only learned about the significance of dam removal when I started fly fishing in WA. This is great news. Very hard to get this kind of unnecessary damage to the ecosystem reversed. The rivers and streams are the vascular system of our environment!
- tbenst 3y agoThere’s an amazing effort by a nonprofit to sponsor the first Kayak descent of this river by children from indigenous peoples of the region. This is a seriously intense adventure with anticipated class VI rapids. https://www.riostorivers.org/ https://www.riostorivers.org/
- davidw 3y agoThe Klamath River flows through some amazing areas - starting in the high/dry area east of the Cascades, going through beautiful oak woodlands and then the temperate rainforests on the northern California coast. A really beautiful part of the world.
- oregano 3y agoOrca whales off the coast of Washington (j,k,l pods) are endangered IN NO SMALL PART due to the existence of the Snake River Dam. If the salmon cannot survive then neither can the whales.
- jorisboris 3y agoAs a white water kayaker i believe we’ve killed a lot of rivers with our construction in and around them, especially in the European Alps Obviously I’m biased to say this as these constructions also prevent me doing my favorite sport in many places