3 ms·
...every trade that executes because someone wanted to trade while the price was somewhere between the bid and the ask would cut the HFT folks out of the loop..
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
...every trade that executes because someone wanted to trade while the price was somewhere between the bid and the ask would cut the HFT folks out of the loop...
See the first post in the series. This is exactly how the markets work. The best price always wins.
If the bid/ask is $10.00/10.05, and I offer to buy at $10.05, I will trade immediately. If I offer to buy at $10.03, I jump the queue and will be the first to trade (provided someone is willing to sell at $10.03 or lower).
- btilly 15y agoYou either did not read my suggestion, or did not understand it, because it is very different from how the markets work today. Suppose that the bid/ask is $10.00/10.05. Suppose that I am willing to buy at $10.20. In today's market I will immediately make the trade at $10.05. In my suggested market there is another fact to consider, the price. Suppose that it is $10.03. Then I become an outstanding buy order, and for as long as I am outstanding, the price will drift up. If the price reaches $10.05 without finding a seller, then I will trade at $10.05 with the HFT folks. But if a seller who is willing to sell at $9.90 comes along before that happens, we will trade with each other at the current price and leave the HFT folks out of the loop. My suspicion is that, if this were implemented, a large fraction of trades would actually execute in the middle ground between what the HFT traders are willing to offer as a bid/ask. Therefore this would be even better for actual speculators than the current system. HFT players would still be in that market, but they would not be as important. In short the difference with my system is that trades may have a small delay before they execute, but should execute at the same or better price for me than the existing market mechanism.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoI definitely misunderstood what you proposed. Your idea is definitely interesting. It certainly slows down price discovery, though probably not enough to matter. I'd need to think more carefully about whether it's a good idea or not, but it's definitely the best suggested tweak to market mechanics I've heard in this thread (or the last one).
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- tazzy531 15y agoBe careful conflating Order and Price. The Order book is the current stack of buyers and sellers. Price is the last executed price. So when you say a price drifting upwards, that means that both buyers and sellers meet at that price. A corollary is that there were buyers and sellers at that price. In addition, this also means that the market could have also moved away from that price without a trade being executed (ie after major announcements -- last trade 10.50, next bid/ask 8.75/8.80) So given that, "If the price reaches $10.05 without finding a seller" this statement does not make much sense and/or is irrelevant. >then I will trade at $10.05 with the HFT folks. Secondly, there is nothing to differentiate, nor should there be, a HFT trader and an individual trader. A trade is a trade. From a buyer's point of view, it doesn't matter if you buy XYZ from MomPop Co vs UltraHFT Co. A trade is a trade. >But if a seller who is willing to sell at $9.90 comes along before that happens, we will trade with each other at the current price and leave the HFT folks out of the loop. This is currently true right now. If someone enters a sell order below the bid, the trade is executed at the bid price (or whatever is at the top of the order book). It will knock out all the orders up to the limit price that is set. Also as I mentioned above, "current price" (ie last executed) has no meaning. In the case of of the major announcement, last executed could be far off from the current order books. >My suspicion is that, if this were implemented, a large fraction of trades would actually execute in the middle ground between what the HFT traders are willing to offer as a bid/ask. Nothing you suggest is anything different from the current system.
- btilly 15y agoYou are trying to figure out a way in which I could be describing the current system, "correcting" me on all of the ways that I am not describing the current system, and then telling me that I am describing the current system. Take that blinder off. In the model that I suggest, the price is a number set by the exchange that trades are allowed to happen at, that moves in a predetermined fashion. Even if there are buyers and sellers who are willing to trade at a different price right now, the exchange won't allow that trade to complete until the price set by the exchange goes into a range where that trade can happen. Under this model, which IS NOT how the market currently works, the people who have an opinion on which direction the stock will go will experience trading delays, but they have an improved opportunity of making trades in the middle of the range that market makers would be willing to offer.