4 ms·
> They can happily regulate on and off ramps, and enforce traceability etc for anything that touches the 'real' economy though, should they wish. But what good
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> They can happily regulate on and off ramps, and enforce traceability etc for anything that touches the 'real' economy though, should they wish.
But what good is that? All you get is traceability for people with nothing to hide. You can't actually prevent on and off ramps because anybody could go to the black market digital currency dealer (whose operations are conveniently situated near the local drug dealer) and exchange digital currency for anything that can be easily pawned, or cash, and the people you'd actually be interested in tracing just do that.
Which makes the KYC/AML rules de facto optional for anyone already breaking the law, but you're still inconveniencing anyone abiding the law because you e.g. can't have an anonymous vending machine because the machine would be required by law to verify your identity before accepting your money. Which is ridiculous when the vending machine sells candy bars and perverse when it sells contraceptives.
- Nursie 3y agoThat Bitcoin becomes un-resellable as it has gone through un-sanctioned addresses.
- genge 3y agoHow exactly would it become un-ressellable. Agreed, you would have to remain in the black market, but you cannot censor a transaction.
- roenxi 3y agoNo argument there; but if you're interested the tech does exist to solve that problem. https://www.getmonero.org/ https://www.getmonero.org/ . It is obfuscated to the point where transactions and ownership can't be tracked.
- JustinGoldberg9 3y agoThere will always be other exchanges or micro exchanges or something like lightning stores which will accept the tainted Bitcoin.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- max51 3y agotrying to ban adresses like this would never work because you don't have to ask permission to the recipient when you send them crypto. Every single large entity (eg. exchanges, companies, etc.) would end up with tainted bitcoins. The only way would be to have all the mining pool onboard to ban them from the chain itself but good fucking luck convincing them, the entire point of bitcoin in the first place was to prevent this type of interventions. Laundering crypto is extremely easy and cheap. You trade it on a crypto-only exchange (no KYC there) and trade it back. You can go further by doing both trades on different platform and using Monero. Now your dirty BTC belong to the exchange and will get spread out to everyone.
- _heimdall 3y ago> All you get is traceability for people with nothing to hide Have we officially abandoned the original goal of privacy/anonymity with bitcoin? Privacy isn't only a good thing when you have something to hide. > You can't actually prevent on and off ramps because anybody could go to the black market On and off ramps are generally meant to only include the legal avenues for buying and selling bitcoin. The government can absolutely regulate those, the black market is a separate concept. If you are left only with black market trades, the available market for the currency is drastically reduced and the potential value would be a fraction if what it otherwise could be.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Have we officially abandoned the original goal of privacy/anonymity with bitcoin? Privacy isn't only a good thing when you have something to hide. But if you have something to hide and the official on ramps and off ramps don't allow you to hide it, you can just use the black market, so the only people using the official system in that context are the people who believe themselves to be uninteresting to the government. Which naturally excludes nearly all the people the government is legitimately interested in, making the KYC requirements a pointless burden on innocent people. > On and off ramps are generally meant to only include the legal avenues for buying and selling bitcoin. The government can absolutely regulate those, the black market is a separate concept. Generally speaking government regulations only work when at least one of the buyer or seller wants the regulations, e.g. you buy your medication from the pharmacy and not a drug dealer because you want the quality controls the government imposes, even if the seller would rather not. So the openly operated pharmacy outcompetes the black market for aspirin. When both the buyer and the seller have no interest in the rules, neither of them reports the other for violating them and then they're basically unenforceable. Which is hot garbage, because the costs of the rules still fall on the people they weren't meant to constrain, and the vig on the transactions funds other black market activities, and the inability of the parties to resolve disputes through the legal system begets violence etc.
- _heimdall 3y ago> making the KYC requirements a pointless burden on innocent people. Oh I'd be all for getting rid of KYC laws and similar, no complaints here. > you buy your medication from the pharmacy and not a drug dealer because you want the quality controls the government imposes Personally if I were buying prescription meds I'd go to a pharmacy simply because I don't went to be caught and charged with illegally buying a controlled substance. I don't have much faith in the pharmaceutical industry or its regulation. > When both the buyer and the seller have no interest in the rules, neither of them reports the other for violating them and then they're basically unenforceable. This is where you lose me a bit. The laws are enforceable if they catch you. Catching you will be harder on the black market, but you absolutely can be charged if they do. My original point was more about the limited market if you have to go black market. Fewer potential customers to transact with means demand goes down, in all likelihood the value of bitcoin would be much lower if there were no legal uses for it.