3 ms·
The popularity of these scammy exchanges despite the massive red flags shows that this is actually what customers want. They don't want the theoretical advantag
by pavlov 3y ago
The popularity of these scammy exchanges despite the massive red flags shows that this is actually what customers want. They don't want the theoretical advantages of permissionless blockchains and private keys, they just want penny stocks that trade 24/7 and are called "crypto" because it sounds cool.
So institutions will take advantage of that desire for convenience and work with regulators to turn "crypto" into just another product on their menu, with the vast majority of customers having no other way to access it.
- petesergeant 3y ago> They don't want the theoretical advantages Surely only a fool would want advantages that were theoretical only?
- pavlov 3y agoThe greater fool theory is the only mechanism for converting crypto to dollars, so this is a feature.
- fidelramos 3y agoBut they are not theoretical, users who have their own crypto wallets have been unaffected by all the failed exchanges (MtGox, FTX, etc.) There are other actual advantages that some people today benefit from, like avoiding confiscation and uncensorable transactions ( which would have been appreciated by the Canadian truckers when they were debanked), or protection against high inflation (like many Venezuelans and Argentinians do). This is not to say that the UX of cryptocurrencies is not good enough for the majority of people, but that is a separate criticism.
- akoboldfrying 3y agoYou're absolutely right, though I took the parent's main point to be that it's incredible how little people seem to care about these actually-very-practical advantages. (The advantages must seem purely theoretical to people so willing to throw them away.)
- fidelramos 3y agoI agree with that point, most people don't seem to care about the advantages until they themselves get bitten by the status quo.
- troupo 3y ago> They don't want the theoretical advantages of permissionless blockchains and private keys Because none of these theoretical advantages make any sense for the absolute vast majority of people, and don't make sense for about 99.99999999999% of things for which the advantage is claimed.
- akoboldfrying 3y agoThis is right on the money. It's incredible to think about really: the one technical feature that truly differentiates crypto from all other forms of currency -- namely, a cryptographically strong guarantee that no one else can touch your money -- gets thrown away routinely and no one minds at all.
- gonzan 3y agoWhy would I mind if other people hold their money themselves or use a custodian as long as I have the option to custody my own money? Let people choose
- akoboldfrying 3y agoPerhaps I wasn't clear: There's no reason at all for you to mind what other people choose to do with their money, and I'm fine with exchanges offering it (that is, holding customer balances on file privately instead of recording everything on the public blockchain) as an optional service. It's just shocking to me that so few people seem to regard the small cost and inconvenience of "doing it properly" as being worth it, when in some sense the entire blockchain machinery was designed and built to enable exactly that guarantee. It's like watching someone buy a padlock to secure something, but then immediately cut through it with a boltcutter "to make it easier to get my stuff out".
- iraqmtpizza 3y agoOr maybe it's just that they aren't illiterate and know that US taxes must be paid in USD by law. If you want to call not going to federal prison "convenience" then make that argument explicitly instead of dancing around it.