9 ms·
What needs and wants is it fulfilling for you?
by simonw 3y ago
What needs and wants is it fulfilling for you?
- MuffinFlavored 3y agoMe guessing (as somebody who is anti-crypto): they like how it returns ~50-100% year over year pretty much. I swear I saw some super highly upvoted comments that read as normal + level-headed in r/CryptoCurrnecy that was like "if it goes from $45k -> $100k this year it isn't even that much" Do you ever hear Warren Buffet saying "122% yearly returns are meh"?
- stringfood 3y ago[dead]
- Timber-6539 3y agoYep, crypto bros will get in bed with the same banks that screwed them over in 2008 if the end goal means that the price of their coin (ahem) bags.. go up. The whole Bitcoin 'manifesto' and sticking it to the man is just a ruse.
- obviouslynew 3y agoOr the technologists that push these open source projects forward were abandoned by the very communities that used to celebrate disruptive technologies.
- rafaelero 3y agoBitcoin is wealth in the cloud. There's immense utility in being able to digitalize your wealth, including higher mobility and, since it is a decentralized network, assurance that it won't be inflated, confiscated and that you will have the freedom to transact it with whoever you want.
- vasilipupkin 3y agoWhat does that mean ? Most wealth is in the cloud, you don’t need Bitcoin for this. I don’t have any paper stock certificates.
- rafaelero 3y agoNot really. Most wealth is based on physical stuff like houses, factories and offices.
- TimJRobinson 3y agoAnd yet if you were to visit Iran and attempt to access that wealth you'd quickly discover how little of that wealth is actually yours. It's not just that it's in the cloud, it's the only form of wealth you can keep digitally AND only you have access and control over it. Maybe that's fine because you're a good citizen who follows the rules, but some people are born into places where they don't get the privilege of a fair financial system, or the system changes on them.
- vasilipupkin 3y agoBut all this is circular logic. You can’t say something is valuable because it’s digital. Why is it wealth in the first place is the question. Wealth is something that represents concrete value.
- epolanski 3y agoCool. Going on GitHub and downloading core code and deploying a new coin based on Bitcoin or some other crypto. I'll call it HackerNewsCoin. Didn't know it was that simple to create "wealth". What a foolishness to think that something that has no intrinsic value can constitute wealth. Don't confuse price with value. It really is true crypto combines all that people don't understand about economy with all that people don't understand about technology.
- mistercheph 3y ago> combines all that people don't understand about economy with all that people don't understand about technology I agree 100% with this but it is describing you.
- epolanski 3y agoAnd you've done an amazing job educating me on where I'm wrong or debating any of my points, haven't you?
- rafaelero 3y ago> What a foolishness to think that something that has no intrinsic value can constitute wealth. Honestly, I am also amazed that humans make something like that happen. But we do. Otherwise gold wouldn't have so much value.
- epolanski 3y agoGold is crucial in electronics, jewellery, biochemistry. Also, can't be forked, cloned or replaced by some gold 2.0 with smart contracts or bigger block size. Seriously, imagine comparing a currency, let alone a cryptocurrency to gold. Foolishness never ends.
- rafaelero 3y agoGold was a currency and a store of wealth for a long time for multiple societies (even when most of those use cases you listed didn't exist). If only they had the knowledge and wisdom of epolanski from 2024 they wouldn't have made this mistake...
- gknapp 3y agoThese are some interesting points around its value, but it can absolutely be inflated, no? Given that most of our standards of value are tied to fiats, and that Bitcoin's exchange with said fiats is highly variable, the value of your crypto wealth can totally be out of your control. Fortunately for most bitcoiners who got in early, it's been variable in a positive direction... But not for everyone.
- rafaelero 3y agoValue fluctuation is not the same as asset inflation. The first relates to how much confidence people have on using BTC to represent their wealth in a given moment. The second is a decreasing of the asset's value keeping overall confidence constant.
- killerstorm 3y agoIt provides an alternative to banks. Once you realize that banks are very fragile and abusive, just having this alternative is important. Banks can deny you access to your money on a whim. Compliance, glitch, failure, whatever. You can't use your money. You can't buy food. You can't pay rent. You can't buy tickets. You can't hire a lawyer. It's nice to have something which is based on completely different principles.
- reaperman 3y agoI think you'll be amazed at the extent to which BTC will be able to be controlled by strong central governments. I'd be shocked if in ten years there's not granular control over which wallets contain "tainted" bitcoin and cannot be converted to fiat except through actual money laundering. There's been a lot of consolidation of the exchanges in USA, tons of KYC controls in place now, and old-school options like localbitcoins.com or craigslist have disappeared or been nerfed beyond recognizability. If people no longer "need" to convert BTC to fiat, this would no longer be a point of a control, but until then, governments can already and will continue to grow how much they can control BTC flow. Some of it is currently very ham-fisted, but there's a clear intent to devalue off-exchange wallets: https://www.coincenter.org/new-crypto-tax-reporting-obligations-took-effect-on-new-years-day/ https://www.coincenter.org/new-crypto-tax-reporting-obligati...
- AlexandrB 3y agoI remember seeing articles related to this from a few years ago. I wonder what's going on under the hood at places like Coinbase. https://news.bitcoin.com/industry-execs-freshly-minted-virgin-bitcoins/ https://news.bitcoin.com/industry-execs-freshly-minted-virgi...
- hackernudes 3y agoWhat about the lightning network? Or Liquid sidechain? There are lots of people working on scaling bitcoin so that it can be used like cash (low fees and anonymous). When a user receives a payment in Cash App or Strike over the lightning network there is no way to track where that bitcoin came from. I haven't really tested that out yet, but I find the idea that bitcoin can be the rails of transferring value pretty compelling. Most people can still transact in fiat but with trustless interoperability between banks and service providers. And of course if people are happy transacting in units of bitcoin it can all be done in a trust-minimized way (with tradeoffs available for convenience, etc...). But to your point, the government could crack down on the app stores and service providers to not support this kinda stuff.
- latchkey 3y agoI've favorited off this comment for a while now: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26238410 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26238410
- p4ul 3y agoThank you so much for sharing this! It's definitely an interesting and valuable perspective.
- ericd 3y agoMany governments attempt to force their populations to keep their savings in the nation's currency, while aggressively devaluing the currency. The richer people in those countries tend to try to get out of it via other currency holdings in offshore accounts or real estate, but the poorer set don't generally have that option. The ability to opt out of that in a way that's harder to confiscate than eg physical gold/USD is very helpful to those people.