3 ms·
Genes play a big role. Some people have a faster (I think the more appropriate word is inefficient) metabolism, and can lose weight or stay thin despite eating
by paulpauper 3y ago
Genes play a big role. Some people have a faster (I think the more appropriate word is inefficient) metabolism, and can lose weight or stay thin despite eating more calories compared to someone with a slower/efficient metabolism, controlling for body size, age, and other factors. There was a thread on Reddit a while back where formerly or current obese people shared their old diets, and many people were commenting that it did not seem like much food. Even though people are generally bad at self-reporting calorie intake, that's called having a crap metabolism.
Imagine two individuals who both both need 2,500 calories/day to feel satiated, but the second individual stores anything above 1,500/day as fat, and a second individual stores anything above 3,000 as fat. The first person will constantly be fighting his body to not overeat and will feel hungry constantly. The second individual can eat to fullness and not gain weight.
Some men , particularly the formerly obese, have such slow metabolisms that anything stored above 1,200-1,700/day is stored as fat despite weighing 170 pounds or so, from reading personal accounts here and on Reddit. This is also why bariatric surgery patients regain weight and become obese again despite only eating around 1,200-1,500 calories/day. These people basically got short-changed when it comes to metabolism genes. If there is a famine, they will outlive everyone. But in abundance they become fat very easily. This does not answer why there are more obese people today compared to in the past, but there is still probably a genetic component nonetheless.
And on the other extreme are people who can be very slim despite eating a normal amount of calories or only slightly less than 2,000. These people are much rarer, as it's disadvantageous from an evolutionary perspective to have an inefficient metabolism, but they exist in the same way very tall or short people exist by virtue of phenotypic variance.