6 ms·
>So it seems Wirecutter is using “true-HEPA” to mean “H13”. >Except—what’s the logic here? This difference is core to Wirecutter’s dismissal of the IKEA purifi
by croes 3y ago
>So it seems Wirecutter is using “true-HEPA” to mean “H13”.
>Except—what’s the logic here? This difference is core to Wirecutter’s dismissal of the IKEA purifier.
According to this
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HEPA#Specifications https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HEPA#Specifications
H13 is HEPA, everything below is EPA. Or simpler, if it starts with an H it's HEPA, if it starts with an E it's EPA.
- jerlam 3y agoThe idea that "only HEPA-rated filters are acceptable" is bonkers and also internally inconsistent. Two of their "also great" recommendations are Blueair purifiers, which do not have HEPA-rated filters.
- wtallis 3y agoDid you mean to imply that Blueair filters as a rule don't have HEPA-rated filters?
- stavros 3y agoI read the sentence as "their two specific Blueair recommendations don't have HEPA-rated filters".
- wtallis 3y agoThat's what seemed to be the most likely intended meaning, but the comma throws it off.
- j33zusjuice 3y agoNo it doesn’t. The comment’s syntax is correct. Commas before “which,” and not before “that.” https://www.dictionary.com/e/that-vs-which/# https://www.dictionary.com/e/that-vs-which/# The actual problem is the usage of “which.” If they’re Blueair purifiers that happen to not have HEPA filters, they should have made the clause essential/restrictive. If all Blueair filters lack a HEPA filter, then adding that they don’t have HEPA filters as clarification is non-essential. So I understand your confusion, it’s just not for the reason you said it was.
- quasse 3y agoI came here to say this. For a blog post accusing the Wirecutter of being "rife with factual errors, [and] misleading statements" the author could have, ya know, not gotten basic facts wrong about filtering standards? Just a few sentences later the author states "This passage implies that a (“true”?) HEPA filter is designed to capture particles that are 0.3 microns or larger. But an H13 filter must, by definition, capture 99.95% of particles of all sizes." This is explicitly wrong! According to the author's own source that they linked above! "HEPA filters, as defined by the United States Department of Energy (DOE) standard adopted by most American industries, remove at least 99.97% of aerosols 0.3 micrometers (μm) in diameter."
- schiffern 3y agoThat's the definition for "HEPA," but what IKEA/Wirecutter said is "true-HEPA" which is undefined. Usually "true-HEPA" is just a marketing term used when selling non-HEPA filters. I also feel these semantics are evading the real point of the "what's the logic" comment, which was > we are never given a reason why H13 is good enough, but E12 isn’t. Surely it’s not just that higher numbers are better?
- CharlesW 3y ago"True HEPA" is an unfortunate side-effect of companies like BlueAIR, which use names like "HEPASilent" to refer to filtration which doesn't meet HEPA requirements. (Note that I'm not saying that HEPASilent is better or worse than HEPA H13, just that the name is designed to obfuscate.) Companies need some way to help consumers differentiate filters which meet HEPA requirements from those which don't.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wolpoli 3y ago> Usually "true-HEPA" is just a marketing term used when selling non-HEPA filters. I don't understand how companies are allowed to add an intensifying or strengthening adjectives to a noun and ends up with a weaken definition of the noun. For example, Full Self Driving is less than Self Driving and now true-HEPA is less than HEPA. Could I advertise that a product as Perfect-HIPPA compliant then?
- delecti 3y agoSimilarly, "genuine leather" is the leather equivalent of American "cheese" (much of which isn't legally cheese).
- CharlesW 3y agoAnother personally-painful example is "podcasting", which Spotify appropriated while creating a closed equivalent of our open web medium. Now everyone's forced to say "standards-based podcasting" or "open podcasting" to use its original meaning.
- makomk 3y agoWhich is a distinction which basically doesn't matter for air purifiers like this one - it's only really relevant to stuff like whole-room positive or negative pressure systems which ensure all of the air goes through the filter. With a standalone air purifier, the main limiting factor is how quickly the room air gets exchanged through the filter. It's pretty much irrelevant whether the filter removes 99.95% of particles or merely 99.5% since that's outweighed by all the pollution in air that hasn't been through the filter at all yet. The claims about why true HEPA filters are better are nonsense.
- jerlam 3y agoAs the article says, CADR (Clean Air Delivery Rate) is what matters, not whether the filters are HEPA or not. CADR takes into account both the filter rating and the airflow through the purifier. The infamous Corsi–Rosenthal Box uses filters which are far below HEPA standards (MERV-13) but since it's moving so much air, it performs better overall with a higher CADR.
- wincy 3y agoHaha we bought 4 box fans and buy 4 filters at once at Home Depot, so we get them for half off with a bulk discount. They’ve helped my wife’s asthma substantially.
- genewitch 3y agoK&N and possibly others make dense washable filters - much better than the green or blue style you see at big box stores. You can spray simple green (or another safe cleanser like that) on the back, and then quickly hit it with hot tap water and let it soak. 20"x20" is ~$30 iirc. for people interested in this style of filter the fans don't last very long, maybe a year or two. They are ~$20+ each. I was buying the highest MERV without carbon for a long time, then i switched to carbon and fiber washable ones, then K&N. Not an endorsement of K&N in particular, i just know the brand and use them.
- santoshalper 3y ago