3 ms·
Frankly, this is an example of everything that's wrong with healthcare in the US and much of the developed world. The textbook OSA patient is a middle-aged man
by jdietrich 15y ago
Frankly, this is an example of everything that's wrong with healthcare in the US and much of the developed world.
The textbook OSA patient is a middle-aged man with a short, thick neck. OP is a middle-aged man with a short, thick neck. I'll bet dollars to doughnuts that OP is also hypertensive. In such a presentation, there is a very simple initial prescription - lose weight, drink less alcohol, quit smoking, get some exercise, see me in six months. In nearly all cases these simple lifestyle changes cure the OSA, yield a huge array of other health benefits and cost nothing. CPAP is only indicated if either the patient still has symptoms after reducing their neck circumference, or is somehow unable to lose weight.
The only thing that went wrong in OP's case is that his primary physician yielded to demand for a quick fix, rather than making the correct prescribing decision. OP would rather sleep on a respirator than improve his lifestyle. I'm not blaming him, it's a cultural problem, but it's one that will kill us all and lumber us with an impossible burden of healthcare costs.
Consider this: The leading cause of limb loss in the developed world is type 2 diabetes. Mull that thought over for a moment, let it percolate. Most cases of type 2 diabetes are preventable through simple lifestyle changes. Most cases of dysvascular amputation can be prevented by better management of blood glucose levels. People are having their feet cut off because they are unable to appropriately manage their most basic physical needs. That thought is what disturbs my sleep.
- naner 15y agoConsidering that he wasn't getting restful sleep, wouldn't it be best to give him the CPAP and tell him to change his lifestyle? If I was in his situation and the doc told me that he would not give me a CPAP and that I needed to eat better I'd tell him where he could shove it...
- mynegation 15y agoSometimes, like in this case, quick fix is sorely needed to even get started with long fix. If you are sleep deprived and have hypertension, there is just not enough energy to do exercise or seek or cook healthy food. As for the weight - I can only offer anecdotal evidence: OP's problems are likely aggravated by weight, but it may well be that there is a muscle problem as well. My BMI (weight in kg divided by height in meters squared) during different periods of my life hovers around 25 - just between healthy and overweight. According to my wife, once my BMI is below 25 I stop having episodes of snoring at night and the more my BMI goes over 25 the more snoring I do.
- latortuga 15y agoInteresting thoughts. My father (who is not overweight, normal range BMI) has had sleep apnea problems for years and the CPAP all but cured him of it. A coworker of my girlfriend (not overweight) also has sleep apnea and has had tremendous success with a CPAP. Forgive my knowledge gap here but, is it just OSA specifically that is usually found in middle-aged men with short, thick necks or is it all forms of sleep apnea? As far as your comments about better management of glucose levels, consider that the primary recommendation for type 2 diabetes is to eat a diet high in carbohydrates (fruits, grains, vegetables), making glucose management incredibly difficult if you follow the doctor's orders. Your blood sugar is killing you; make sure you eat things that make it kill you faster. There's obviously a problem here.
- neilk 15y agoI don't know what's up with the OP's situation, but you present a false dichotomy. My doctor advised weight loss (not like I needed another reason) and CPAP. Sleeping well is key to fixing other things in your life that may be contributing the weight gain. It's pretty hard to commit to an exercise program if you have no energy. And in my case, I was consuming caffeinated drinks nonstop just to get a few hours of focus at work. I agree there is a worrisome focus now on managing the downsides rather than fixing the orignal problem. But it's not for lack of trying. Doctors have been hectoring patients to change their lifestyles for decades with little success. Obesity is a complex issue. I will only note that over the last three decades, all the other vices are way down -- alcohol, tobacco, even the use of illegal drugs. But obesity is way up. To me that suggests it's not all about a desire for 'quick fixes' or some generalized failure in knowledge or willpower. Culprits may include pervasive advertising that makes gluttony acceptable, agricultural subsidies, and maybe even some hitherto unknown toxicities in refined sugar. (Victor Lustig of UCSF is making that case very strongly.)