5 ms·
Vogtle notoriously suffered from cost overruns and was complicated by Westinghouse going through bankruptcy during the construction. It's not obvious that this
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
Vogtle notoriously suffered from cost overruns and was complicated by Westinghouse going through bankruptcy during the construction. It's not obvious that this is a representative example and "1" is not a statistically valid sample size. It was also the first US plant brought online in 40 years, which required a lot of lessons to be learned for the first time in a generation, as would not be the case for future construction.
And you're comparing the ultimate cost of the completed reactor to the estimated cost of the wind project -- the estimated cost of Vogtle was $14B, and now SunZia is getting sued for whatever it is this time. The US makes it unreasonably expensive to build anything.
And even then, by the time you account for capacity factor, short-term storage and long-term storage, even with all the cost overruns, the cost of Vogtle was the same order of magnitude as the estimated cost of a wind project that would supply the same amount of power.
I honestly don't understand why people think these things are particularly in competition with each other. If we're going to stop burning carbon, we're going to electrify transportation, and that is where most of the storage batteries are going to go for the foreseeable future. And then we're going to have to increase the amount of generating capacity to charge all of those batteries. But that's great -- they're batteries so we can charge them with new renewables without having to worry about intermittency.
Except that means we just allocated the bulk of our production capacity for both storage and renewable generation to electrifying transportation, and we still need to stop burning carbon for the existing baseload power generation. Hence nuclear.
- ViewTrick1002 3y agoKeep in mind that about half the cost is the transmission line. [1] Vogtle closely matches nuclear costs in Europe so trying to frame it as a special snowflake we will never repeat does not add up. Until proven otherwise it is what nuclear construction is expected to cost in advanced economies. Bent Flyvbjerg has studied megaprojects. Looking at those the most likely to come in on time and budget are solar pv and wind projects. On the complete opposite end of the spectrum we have nuclear energy only beaten by the Olympics and nuclear waste storage in terms of cost over runs and delays. The HVDC line adds risk but we have gotten quite experienced at building those globally. The equivalency in risk you try to construct does not exist. https://patternenergy.com/pattern-energy-closes-11-billion-financing-of-largest-clean-energy-infrastructure-project-in-u-s-history/ https://patternenergy.com/pattern-energy-closes-11-billion-f...
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Keep in mind that about half the cost is the transmission line. The main cost of a transmission line is the land. This is a good synergy when it's available but you can't just subtract the cost of the transmission line if you want to know how much the generation costs to build anywhere there isn't a transmission line because you'd still need to pay for the land. > Vogtle closely matches nuclear costs in Europe so trying to frame it as a special snowflake we will never repeat does not add up. Western Europe has only brought one reactor online in the last 15 years, resulting in the same kind of issues as Vogtle. Problems caused by not building enough of something can be solved by building more of them, which makes that a poor justification for not building more of them. > Bent Flyvbjerg has studied megaprojects. "The Iron Law of Megaprojets: Over budget, over time, over and over again." -Bent Flyvbjerg Claiming that the estimates are more often wrong for nuclear reactors doesn't help you when you're already comparing the actual finished cost of the nuclear reactor to the estimate for the wind project.
- ViewTrick1002 3y agoLets just keep the blinders on and ignore the other projects in Europe: - Flamanville: Construction start 2007. Hopefully finished 2024. Five times over budget - Hinkley Point C: Political decision and construction start 2008. Investment decision 2013. Hopefully done by 2028, costs spiraling. n:th of a kind reactor. - Olkiluoto 3: Construction start 2005. Done 2023. - Hanhikivi: Never passed the phase when they tried to certify a Russian reactor for western safety requirements. The problem with nuclear is the Baumol Effect [1]. The construction industry has barely become more efficient while labor costs has increased. Thus magically investing another trillion dollars in subsidies for nuclear is not certain to meaningfully make it cheaper. We have already had one massive round of subsidies, those didn't pan out. France famously experience negative learning by doing in their nuclear program. [2] Given the outcome of previous wind projects it is almost certain that it will be on time and on budget. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol_effect [2]: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0301421510003526 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03014...