5 ms·
YouTube Bans True Crime Videos That Reanimate Dead Children with AI
- anigbrowl 3y agoGood thing too. Absolute gutter exploitation, like most of the 'true crime' genre.
- atticora 3y agoI disagree. AI is becoming an increasingly important tool for telling stories, and making it harder to tell stories about true crimes and dead children is not a good thing. We need our full range of tools to think about and communicate about these horrors, as much as for anything else.
- nickthegreek 3y agoSo true. I've never really been able to understand the visceral nature of a childs death in my 40+ years on this earth. Until now, the horrors could never be adequately told, let alone shown by complete amateurs. Luckily we now have notAnExploiter420 to reanimate your dead child to show their well researched hot take and for monetary gain!
- HenryBemis 3y ago> tool for telling stories Yes, i.e. I am thinking of a story that would make a nice children's book, with some keywords (forest, cave, fire, marshmallows, squirrel, etc.) It would be GREAT if I can get some AI machine (currently using Midjourney) to describe a scene, to find an image that would 'improve' the story. I understand that others above mention "the law", but until the makers of laws react (globally) to prevent from this sh*t happening, we have to use basic human decency. Also, we don't need to make movies for people who don't want movies to be made. And yes that is a thin line (i.e. we MUST make movies about the holocaust so we never forget - and not listen to people who want this avoided). But the tragedy of a family is a whole different game (and it requires a human with a soul to tell them apart - apparently).
- LiquidPolymer 3y ago"True Crime" as a genre is littered with unscrupulous hosts. But not all of it is in the gutter. In fact, some of it produces a public good. I admit I am attracted to these stories and try to choose carefully. If I may - two recommendations: "My Only Story" - an adult man notices with horror that the man who secretly raped him as a school boy in South Africa is still working as a teacher. He quits his job and starts a podcast about how grooming works and how the school system is letting pupils down. All the while he is trying to expose this man for who he is without being sued - so he has to dance around the man's name. It is riveting. The story unfolds live as he finds more and more fellow students who were victimized willing to go on the record. This leads to naming names. "The Root Of Evil" which features (in part) a retired Los Angeles homicide detective who believes his surgeon father was behind the famous Black Dahlia murder. He brings receipts. An astonishing amount of historical material is unearthed including cassette tape audio from the 70's. Story telling is such an integral part of the social experience. Like everything it can be corrupted by greed and bad incentives. Not every True Crime podcast falls into this trap.
- Analemma_ 3y ago> "True Crime" as a genre is littered with unscrupulous hosts. But not all of it is in the gutter. In fact, some of it produces a public good. True crime has a similar problem to, say, commerical fishing. Some of the early stuff was quite good, because the first shows to do it had their pick of complex and narratively satisfying events to be based on. But once the low-hanging fruit was plucked, subsequent shows had no choice but to begin trawling, in the same way that fishermen do when populations run thin. The demand for true crime has considerably outpaced the supply, and hence why newer shows essentially can't not be bad and dangerous: they have to either invent predators out of thin air or otherwise make mountains out of molehills. There needs to be like a 30-year moratorium on true crime, to let the "fish stocks" replenish.
- teeray 3y ago> The demand for true crime has considerably outpaced the supply Soon it will go meta: a serial killer hosts a true crime show to create interesting episodes, and then other true crime shows have an episode on that!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- maerF0x0 3y agoWhile obviously it can veer off into the morbid and obscene, anyone remember "dramatic reenactment" labels on true crime TV in the 90s? (maybe before too) But I do think there's a space for communicating with impactful re-enactment and tasteful "redaction" (censor blurs, keeping things off scene, or jumping forward allowing implication to tell the story). As with all laws, and rules, the enforcement story will tell what the policy actually means.
- bitshiftfaced 3y agoI think it's something about recreating a likeness of a victim. A paid actor may look similar to a victim, but not exactly. Their image will evoke a totally different emotion from the victim's friends and family.
- danbruc 3y agoThe generated girl was white, the actual victim black. Also - after skimming another article - it seems that the child was killed with a knife first and only then was the body put into the oven, maybe in the hope to get rid of the body. This is more like loosely based on a true story then an accurate retelling of events. Also age and name are slightly altered.
- bitshiftfaced 3y agoDoes that matter? What did you think YouTube has in mind when they say "realistically simulate"? Sometimes you can see a trend coming early on, and isn't YouTube responding to what people will probably do in the future?
- gspencley 3y ago> I think it's something about recreating a likeness of a victim. I'm pretty sure that's what the person you are replying to was commenting on. If you're just continuing the discussion and talking about whether or not the policy is a good move on YouTube's part, fair enough. But it kind of reads like you're shifting the goal post. My opinion is that I'm honestly not sure if it "matters" or not. YouTube has every right to make their content policies according to whatever drives them, be it business forces or their own values. As an adult consumer of YouTube I would personally prefer if there were a "as long as it is legal" policy, but I get why YouTube may have reasons to adopt different policies and it's not up to me. I recognize their right to do what they think is best with their business and product.
- 11thEarlOfMar 3y agoBlack Mirror covered re-animation of loved ones via AI & robotics: Be Right Back Black Mirror: Season 2, Episode 1
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nomel 3y agoThere are already services for this [1]. This is also how https://replika.ai https://replika.ai started [2]. 1. https://news.yahoo.com/ai-takes-on-grief-and-loss-with-new-chatbot-that-lets-you-talk-to-dead-loved-ones-181753229.html https://news.yahoo.com/ai-takes-on-grief-and-loss-with-new-c... 2. https://www.cbc.ca/documentaries/the-nature-of-things/after-her-best-friend-died-this-programmer-created-an-ai-chatbot-from-his-texts-to-talk-to-him-again-1.6252286 https://www.cbc.ca/documentaries/the-nature-of-things/after-...
- teekert 3y agoOne of the best ones of the series if you ask me, and a true insight into the role of human grief. It's also is an eerily accurate prediction of things now (about 10 years after release) very much possible.
- sudosteph 3y agoThere's also a great Adult Swim Infomercial satirizing this idea, "Live Forever As you Are Now with Alan Resnick"[1]. Apparently it came out the same year as that Black Mirror episode (2013) ! [I]https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xg29TuWo0Yo https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xg29TuWo0Yo
- jncfhnb 3y agoI like to boogie board
- aspenmayer 3y agoI think Inside No. 9 also had an episode on this theme. It’s a seriously underrated show and practically unknown. It sort of occupies a middle ground between Black Mirror’s dark satire and Resnick’s absurdist realism, now that I think of it.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- rplnt 3y agoIf you want to see a true crime, try that website on a phone without an ad blocker. Screen-sized ad after every sentence or two.
- qingcharles 3y agoAnd I would hate to see the total payload of the page too for those running with 5GB/month limits on their data.
- henriquez 3y agoTry Chrome’s new Happy Fun Interest Cohorts feature to make sure that all your ads are served through Google’s ad services networks and approved partners. It won’t reduce your bandwidth but it will make browsing the web so much more fun and satisfying!
- thriftwy 3y agoIn Russia they have passed a law some time ago that you can never post dead children faces in any mass media (so they pixelate or draw over). I was thinking that it is most stupid law, but now I don't. Oh boy how right these lawmakers were in light of this new development.
- chris-orgmenta 3y agoAgree. I think every camera manufacturer should implement auto blur on photos (legislate it). Then an opt-in system unblurs the faces of the people that approve. (Or just replace the faces with AI random faces instead of blur) Point being, society has fallen into an opt-out system naturally - But I don't think there is good reason for it to be a necessary thing for the common good. I want privacy, and the tech is there to do it. Manufacturers are meddling with raw images for proof of non-tampering, and if the horse has bolted there then I want my proposal above folded in at the same level.
- iraqmtpizza 3y agojust wear a mask instead of going house to house confiscating cameras with SWAT teams
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vsnf 3y agofwiw, some facial recognition systems, especially ones coming out of Asia where masks are far more common, are pretty good at identifying people with masks on.
- Vecr 3y agoAn elastomeric respirator worn with a hood (on the outside, don't break the seal) and dark sunglasses might work well enough in the US. Need to do something about gait though.
- iraqmtpizza 3y agoSo I can use AI to recreate Shirley Temple but only because she wasn't murdered?
- samsin 3y agoThe decision is out of sensitivity for the victim’s family, and the examples are videos recreating the events of their murder. I think you’ll be fine recreating Shirley Temple…
- mock-possum 3y agoThat’s uh - that’s just straight up censorship though. Like I get that it’s a gross practice that can be used exploitatively, but… using AI to create media that depicts a murdered child telling the story of their own death is a compelling work of art.
- pests 3y agoA content policy is censorship?