2 ms·
> Perhaps it costs more, but I'm more than happy to pay taxes to ensure public order and cleanliness are maintained. This event apparently cost "$11.3 million
by ben_w 3y ago
> Perhaps it costs more, but I'm more than happy to pay taxes to ensure public order and cleanliness are maintained.
This event apparently cost "$11.3 million in overtime", for an event one week long, so I'm going to just approximate that as $587m for a whole year, or $720/person/year (more per tax payer, but I don't know how many tax payers there are in SF).
This may be OK for you, especially as that's out of a total budget of $14.6bn[0], so your total taxes would only go up in this case by x1.04.
But that was funded by the expectation that the event itself would bring in about x5 as much extra economic activity as the increased costs. If you do this all year, perhaps it would also boost the economy, which would be good; or perhaps it will only displace the people with the issues, which would be bad, because where exactly the people are is a zero-sum game for your nation, while actually moving those people costs money… and your city government has to deal with the surrounding cities all deciding to respond in kind, which could make the cost of such displacement arbitrarily high, not bounded to just $720/person/year.
[0] https://missionlocal.org/2023/08/explore-san-francisco-budget-2023-2024-2025/ https://missionlocal.org/2023/08/explore-san-francisco-budge...
[1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/sf-apec-budget-overtime-police-security-breed-18552301.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/sf-apec-budget-overti...
- mc32 3y agoI don't think that's a good extrapolation. It cost a lot because of the momentum of the current status quo. If they changed the status quo and set different expectations of what will be permissible and not, it would not cost so much to maintain. It's like comparing refactoring vs rewriting. One is a semi continuous process the other is a periodic thing that takes a lot of work.
- scarmig 3y agoMuch of that displacement was internal to San Francisco, and the movement of a constant number of homeless people from one area to another can still be net positive, if the area displaced from is denser and more economically productive. External areas would respond in kind. However, they will balance two possible responses: "anti-displacement" and provision of homeless services, depending on what's most effective. The latter does more than shuffle people around. In fact, that dynamic in reverse is how we got to the status quo: other areas have essentially no homeless services but plenty of appetite for displacing to places that do have homeless services, like SF.