4 ms·
Of course the laws on the books can be enforced! The question is just, how well, how often, and what else would you rather do with the resources spent on that e
by ben_w 3y ago
Of course the laws on the books can be enforced! The question is just, how well, how often, and what else would you rather do with the resources spent on that enforcement.
For example, if you tried to fully enforce all the traffic laws, you may find that very quickly everyone's banned from driving (including the police). Perfect enforcement of copyright law would probably destroy all of the Hollywood studios and newspapers, for all of the newsworthy examples of the MPAA and newspapers suing individual pirates for copyright infringement.
But in each case, while you're doing that, you get some combination of all the other crimes go unresolved and/or the costs go up massively, e.g. if the UK were to fully enforce the UK prohibition on heroin[0], it would need to triple the nationwide number of prison cells even if literally every other crime was ignored.
[0] which I choose as an example of things nobody even wants to defend, not even if they otherwise think drugs are cool
- em500 3y agoI recall reading that having a lot of strict laws on the books that are very selectively enforced is the standard playbook of authoritarian regimes.
- ben_w 3y agoIt's everyone's playbook. One of the reasons I use heroin as a go-to example of "you can't fully enforce laws even if you want to" is that it's so widely understood to be bad, and yet the UK is economically incapable of fully enforcing just that one rule even at the expense of all the others.
- mc32 3y agoLaws are there but prosecutors are sometimes loath to enforce them. To wit, Ross Mirkarimi had to draw up a new sit-lie law to address the nuisance of intoxicated kids blocking access to businesses and housing. But we had plenty of laws already! It wasn't a problem in the 60s and 70s, or even 80s. But come the 90s, oh noes, we can't enforce them... so we have to draw up new ones...