6 ms·
Welcome to the end of college football as we know it
- taylodl 3y ago"But in the long term, when you pattern yourself after the NFL in order to get some of their television juice, when you jettison the traditions and orthodoxies that made people fall in love with the sport in the first place, you stop being college football: You simply become Minor League NFL. And no one cares about minor league anything." This pretty much sums-up college football today: it has no future. When you throw out all of the traditions you're left with a bunch of kids playing football. I can watch that on Friday night for a lot less money - and support my local community.
- Balgair 3y agoI see that there are a lot of 'factors' that are not used to giving ground that are being set up against each other, and I don't think it's going to end well or be very predictable. 1) Money: The sports of football and basketball are wildly popular in the US. Our appetite for football is effectively bottomless. Putting that much of it on the air is going to test how bottomless it is. Additionally, the 'lesser' sports that aren't in the TV money making arena are still going to have access to NIL money. This is especially true with Olympic sports, where every four years or so, these elite athletes are going to get a bust of cash from sponsors. For the 'lesser' sports, they will finally have longer term spokespersons that can keep the hype going through the off Olympic years, and the athletes will want this as well. Turning these athletes into money making machines is not going to be something that sponsors want to get rid of. 2) Laws: There are massive Title-9 violations all over the place. Lets look at Stanford students in particular. Their admissions policy is a bit unique in that sports are 'not considered' in admits (who know how true that is for football). The 'lesser' sports' athletes really are there for the education, mostly. Now, with the very long travel distances to the east coast or to SMU, that is putting a de facto undue burden on the women's teams, especially if they aren't flying the same airlines as the men's football team. Combine this with the NIL money that these 'lesser' sports are gong to get, and they can finally hire a real law firm that can go toe-to-toe with the army of lawyers from the university. 3) Banks: There are many schools that have decided to recently re-vamp their fields and facilities. Those are on long term mortgages and other contracts with the various banks of the nation. If these teams start sucking, or are in bad conferences, then there is a huge incentive to change that by the school. Still, there are going to be a lot of teams that just aren't going to do well. And their mortgages are going to start looking like really really bad ideas from the bank's perspective. 4) Governing boards: Some schools are governed by a board of regents. Some are governed by just a president. Some are governed by the state legislature. Some are governed by the Catholic church. All of these petite tyrannies and oligarchies are used to getting their way. Now, they are all going to be competing with each other for giant piles of money. Governing entities that have more legal powers than others are going to be incentivized to use those legal powers to try to grab more of that money. And once one does something galling, all the others are going to be forced to follow suit and try to outbid that gall. 5) Mothers: Mommas don't want their boys playing football anymore. The game is largely seen as too violent and damaging. Yeah, not all the mothers see that, by any means. But the statistics point to a marked and continuing decrease in the number of boys playing. This is a big threat to the pipeline going into football. Other sports aren't really seeing this issue however, outside of women's soccer. But as most of the issues with the conferences are centered around football, mothers end up being a factor. 6) Attention: This is the main issue, I think. The dynamics are pushing schools to have billion dollar programs to survive. These things kinda end up as power law distributions. And as programs get more money, they tend to win more. The system will settle on programs that are very successful and very expensive. To say yet another way, winners will keep winning. Without some sort of balancing factors (player draft, players' unions, salary caps, etc) the winning teams will largely be known before the season starts, just based on expenditures. That's where the attention issue comes in. Who is going to want to watch a game, let alone a season, where you already know the outcomes? Yes, football is uniquely random and therefore exciting. But putting a billion dollars out there on 18-22 year olds is not what 'smart money' wants to do. That kinda gets back to 1) Money, but I hope you see where this goes. Carefully built teams will minimize the risk to the money and therefore the game will be boring. No one wants to watch one of 10 teams play in the playoffs yet again, year after year, with the same heavy favorites again and again. Without some sort of balancing, the same teams are just going to keep on winning as their power law distributed expenditures dictate. Any one of these factors could easily become the dominate factor in the new college sports landscape, and many will change with time, especially as things wind their way through legislatures and courts. Who knows how things are going to go. All I know is that the action off the field is going to be just as exciting as the action on it.
- karensteiner499 3y ago[dead]
- brodouevencode 3y agoConferences needed to die when nearly all schools became financially able to charter planes and buses, and the sport became the priority and not academics, and not for the reasons listed here. > The sport has reached its end-stage-capitalism period All credibility left was just lost
- readthenotes1 3y agoRight? It has just achieved end-stage serfdom.
- babelthuap 3y ago[dead]
- k310 3y agoNow that Stanford and Cal are in the ACC, there will be vastly more air travel, having environmental impact and lost time for academic study, which these two universities actually care about, and consequent fatigue for the players. Zoom classes on the long flights, or sleep? Same for other left (over) coast teams, but less impact.
- Balgair 3y agoAs far as I knew, the plan for Cal/Stanford was to have all their non money making sports games (outside of their rivalry) at Southern Methodist in Texas. So the football and basketball games were to be played 'normally', but lacrosse and soccer, for example, were to be at SMU. I'd also heard that a lot of the 'lesser' sports were just going to be keeping on with the PAC12 league anyways, things like water polo which the ACC pretty much doesn't play. That said, with FSU really trying to get out of the ACC, who knows. But you do bring up a good point on the travel times. Most of the 'lesser' sports' players are at the universities for the academics. Especially Stanford due to their admissions model. Take a player in a sport that is an Olympic sport, who now has access to some funds from the NIL. Say swimming or something. They get a lot of cash from Speedo for the NIL as they are likely to win some medals. Now they can hire a real law firm to argue for them against the army of lawyers from the school and they now have a real shot at winning. The title-9 violations from these long distance travel arrangements may not be de jure but a good lawyer can argue that they are de facto violations. And now those schools are paying big money out. And now they can't just cancel all sports other than the money makers because these athletes now have access to real money and real lawyers. What a mess!
- csa 3y agoI’m guessing that you grossly underestimate the academic support for athletes. 1. Most athletes take fewer and easier classes during their season, or the main part of their season. Missing credit hours can be made up for during the summer, which sometimes have easier classes. 2. Many athletes take easier majors in general. 3. Athletes have access to free tutors. Sometimes these tutors help, sometimes they help a lot, sometimes they just do the work for the athlete. I imagine that the ethics line is adhered to a bit more frequently at places like Cal and Stanford, but sometimes it’s a blurry line. 4. Athletic departments and athletes know which majors and which professors are easy to deal with for things like travel and workload. Word gets around. Of all the things to worry about, the academic side for the athlete would be the least of my worries.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wolverine876 3y agoThis conference realignment is obviously a bad outcome. The leaders of the universities and American academia are delivering very poor results: education is too expensive, academic freedom is limited by outsiders, and now this. What good do the conference realignments do for anyone? Who is happy or better off? The Big 10, in particular, used to be both an athletic association and an academic one, sharing resources between their members, (almost) all AAU members (leading research universities). This year they had the chance to add Stanford and Cal to the academic association, and share their resources. And they turned them down, because the Bay Area college football market isn't big enough. The story I read said Fox Sports, the Big 10's main broadcast partner, made the decision. They had the chance to add Stanford and Cal to their academic association, and said no - if you restrict yourself to universities which compete in major college sports, you will never get a better opportunity. For generations, college football avoided this absurdity. Long ago, maybe eight years ago, there was a crazy notion of people working together, cooperating for a greater good. Why do that? Because it was good, and because they could accomplish more by working together than by acting in anarchy. People now embrace law-of-the-jungle anarchy like it's a rebellious trend, instead of just well-established idiocy. The NCAA members could work together to make it better; they could arrange conferences so that they work for everyone, without students flying across the country; but what was the norm for generations is now so obviously absurd that people roll their eyes at me.
- shermantanktop 3y agoWhat was the norm for generations was and has always been laughable. College football has been a cancer for academia, at first fed by the deep pockets of alumni who were the real audience. The business side grew up and realized that tv rights were an even bigger prize, but along the way somehow failed to recognize that they were greasing the wheels of their money machine with the distant hopes of a pro career held by academically underqualified students with athletic gifts, most of whom either fail to get a diploma, succeed in getting long term injuries, or both. The university priorities get turned upside down and season-winning coaches win the compensation lottery too. It’s disgusting and always has been. Gooooo fighting whatevers!
- 3y ago
- jez 3y agohttps://lite.cnn.com/2024/01/06/opinions/college-football-playoff-championship-leitch/index.html https://lite.cnn.com/2024/01/06/opinions/college-football-pl...
- kube-system 3y agoAd dollars ruin everything. It ruined the internet, and now it is ruining amateur athletics and academics. I'm not sure how to fix it, but I suspect we'll need some regulatory answers. Just like some places have laws to prevent a billboard being built in a place that harms others, we shouldn't enable advertisers to harm others in other realms.
- bondarchuk 3y agoIt would be easy and straightforward to ban third-party advertising across all business domains. But you will see when this is proposed that some people really really really like ads, curiously enough.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- GeoKangas 3y agoTFA mentioned Kansas (where I sit typing this comment) as potentially losing its importance (such as it is) in college football. If it turns out that way, it won't just be disappointing for the KU football program; recent action by the program will make it disastrous. What action? Huge scale reconstruction, of the football portion of the KU campus. As I type, the current football stadium is being demolished, to make way for a bigger and better (and more expensive) stadium, within a fabulous and exciting "Gateway District". This was already IMO a bad bet, on continuing KU football's recent relative success; if things go the way TFA projects, catastrophic failure could occur regardless of win-loss success.
- janalsncm 3y agoThese “students” should be allowed to delay their academic studies until they’re done playing. Most of them won’t make the NFL, so they’re stuck with whatever education they can get while they’re not busy getting CTE.
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoWhile not quite the same thing, most schools will allow football players to finish their degrees after their football eligibility has expired. Given the amount of money live sports generates due to being one of the few places advertisers can be guaranteed an audience, schools that used to be stingy with limiting scholarship money to what was required by the NCAA, can now be very generous. But yes, this isn't quite the same as letting players focus on football first and then work through their degrees once their playing career is over.
- olliej 3y agoOh cnn you garbage site: “ We apologize, but your web browser is configured in such a way that it is preventing this site from implementing required components that protect your privacy and allow you to view and change your privacy settings. This functionality is required for privacy legislation in your region.”
- kashunstva 3y agoAs an outsider with close to zero knowledge of American football, the spectacle of college athletics seems bizarre. I mean, I understand the old principle of _mens sana in corpore sano_ but it’s a stretch to imagine college athletics serving that goal for all but a very few students. I don’t doubt that the system has produced some academic success stories but it must be the exceptional case. Instead, the whole system bears the taint of over involvement of parties with financial incentives that have nothing to do with the mission of the academy.
- nonameiguess 3y agoMost college sports are just students who happen to also compete in a sport that is most likely earning negative revenue and they get scholarships in return. The NCAA and other associations, along with the school's athletic department itself, all get non-profit status and are eligible for tax-free donations and government funding because promoting amateurism in sport is a specifically designated carveout in the tax code. Men's football and basketball are entirely different stories. Of the North American big four, hockey and baseball have always had robust minor leagues and kids are drafted into them straight out of high school. Football and basketball, on the other hand, have pro leagues that have historically relied upon university competition to develop athletes ready for the big leagues. The NBA (American pro basketball) started up a developmental league something like maybe a decade back or so it now calls the G League, but historical inertia being what it is, there is a much larger following for universities and the best players will still tend to do at least a year there, which I think is still the minimum required. The NFL (American pro football) won't draft you until you're at least three years past high school graduation, so the players there have no choice and need to go to college. There's a lot driving it. Alumni pride, even regional and civic pride in places without pro teams in the same sport. Often the best school in each state is the flagship land grant public school and maybe a large private school, and these are usually not located in major metro areas that also have pro teams. There are a few exceptions like University of Washington, which played in the national championship game two days ago, is in Seattle. USC has one of the historically dominant teams and is in Los Angeles. But looking at the other top schools from this year, you're looking at Athens, GA, Ann Arbor, MI, Tuscaloosa, AL, Austin, TX, all places that do not have pro teams. Something people miss is the university athletic department is often, even usually, its own separate non-profit corporation from the school. So, contrary to a lot of takes, it actually has its own revenue stream and its own expenses separate from the larger university. Having a very good football and/or basketball team can draw in enough revenue that the athletic department at the very best schools is typically self-funding. They may as well just be pro franchises, except they don't pay taxes and the athletes nominally have to attend enough classes to not flunk out, though they also don't need to graduate. It's a farce of a system at the very top, but most athletes at most schools are actually amateurs just looking to do something healthy and competitive while they learn and get some of their school paid for, and the US law requires an equal number of scholarships awarded to men and women, so thanks to there often being men's sports that generate a lot of revenue, and there not being such a thing right now as women's football, the presence of a very successful football program can fund a ton of scholarship for obscure women's sports that give girls a chance to get a free education if they're willing to learn and practice them. Everything from fencing to bowling.
- throwaway81523 3y ago"All that drives decision-making in college football now is television ratings, to the point that conferences are hiring former television executives as their commissioners." The sooner it dies, the better.
- trilbyglens 3y agoamen
- mattikl 3y agoI was just wondering the other day, are any of the top college athletes majoring in something demanding (in a way that it requires one to spend countless of hours learning new mental models) like CS or physics? As a European, my exposure to college sports is pretty limited, but I've never seen a major like that listed.
- cafard 3y agoThere have been men who earned PhDs in mathematics during or after NFL careers--quite recently HN had links to an obituary of Frank Ryan, who led the Cleveland Browns to their last NFL championship, and who taught at Case. More recently, John Urschel, a lineman for the Baltimore Ravens earned a Ph.D. and according to Wikipedia teaches at MIT. I have the impression that college football was much less of a full time job in Ryan's day, but Urschel graduated from Penn State in 2012.
- saintduck285 3y ago[dead]
- karp773 3y agoIn Division 1, it's rare but happens. Rather an exception. In Division 3, check out MIT, Caltech, or CMU teams. For these athletics is not a priority.
- defrost 3y agoIf you're interested you could look to the lists of Rhodes Scholar's worldwide- the entry qualification (before selection for award) is to be triple top tier - reputable sporting positon and good academic marks and reputable public facing involvement. Typically, in Australia say, an annual Rhodes Scholar might be a captain in a state cricket team and a viola player in the state orchestra and studying one of the STEM lines. I could point to a Physics Prof who occassionally lectures at the Royal Institute with good sports and band camp cred from their youth .. or another teaching music in the US at a prestiguous school - but that starts to pinpoint my origins :) https://www.rhodeshouse.ox.ac.uk/scholarships/the-rhodes-scholarship/ https://www.rhodeshouse.ox.ac.uk/scholarships/the-rhodes-sch...