4 ms·
Some people will make the claim that alcohol is treated "just like fat" in the body, and that this is why people have beer bellies. While at the same time studi
by peterwwillis 15y ago
Some people will make the claim that alcohol is treated "just like fat" in the body, and that this is why people have beer bellies. While at the same time studies show that people with high-alcohol diets and low carb intake actually weigh less than their non-drinking counterparts. The metabolism of alcohol is quite complex, so it becomes silly to make over-generalizations like "alcohol metabolizes to fat" (ex. http://www.elmhurst.edu/~chm/vchembook/images/642alcoholmetab.gif http://www.elmhurst.edu/~chm/vchembook/images/642alcoholmeta...). I think a lot of people end up taking this as gospel, such as the people who parrot that "alcohol kills braincells." Well yes it does, but not much more than will die naturally or due to other causes, more studies have shown. The real danger lies in permanently damaging or killing your liver from which there is no coming back.
When I see television pieces done telling me there is a single simple culprit for a huge problem like obesity, my brain tells me that this is probably not the case. In fact, most of the people I know who are obese don't seem to be eating handfulls of cupcakes or sodas. They're eating chicken wings and burgers and fries and nachos and big macs. Not to say fat is another single cause of obesity, but it's clear that an overabundance of fat, or perhaps simply just over-eating, is another simple cause for obesity which needs to be weighed with all the rest.
Technically just drinking alcohol could lead to diabetes as it lowers the blood sugar and insulin swoops in to fill the gap. Sure, sugar can be very detrimental to your health, but let's not make it out to be the devil. Promoting nutritional balance and moving away from non-fresh foods would probably go a lot farther towards preventing diabetes than never eating sugar.
- Sapient 15y ago> chicken wings and burgers and fries and nachos and big macs Thats loads of carbs. And they are probably also eating a lot of crisps, along with all the sodas and sweetened drinks they are drinking. What I am trying to say, is that its not the fat in those meals which is making them fat, its the carbs. I am on a diet which has cut out all carbs entirely, and increased the amount of fat I eat drastically. I lost a large amount of weight fairly quickly on this diet, and the loss continues. Edit: Americanized chips to crisps.
- bad_user 15y agoI am on a diet which has cut out all carbs entirely, and increased the amount of fat I eat drastically Be careful about it, because your body needs those fruits and vegetables. Like, I know it is trendy to hate the potato, but it still has an unique nutritional value that can hardly be replaced. Unfortunately you can't precisely measure the effect carbs can have on your body. Things like the quantity of carbs, or the glycemic index, or the insulinemic index ... are clues, but not proofs of what you should eat. To make matters worse, we don't actually know what nutrients our body needs, we just know that this shit is really complex. What you have to really watch out for are the refined carbohydrates (sugar, white flour, white rice) and keep in mind that not all carbs are created equally ;-) Personally I think the best diets are those dissociated. You may lose weight slower than on more drastic diets, but that's also good for preventing loose skin and other health related issues.
- Sapient 15y agoI should have been more specific - I have completely cut out all refined carbs like bread and sugar, and massively cut down on the rest (I do still eat some fruits, vegetables and even a little starch in the form of sweet-potatoes etc, but very little while I am losing weight). Once I have lost enough weight, I will increase the amount of carbs in my diet (NOT refined carbs) until I find the point at which I start putting on weight again.
- peterwwillis 15y agoSee, if I was going to take on an extreme fad diet that cut out entirely one of the three basic building blocks of nutrition, I would have gone with the junk food diet: http://www.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.professor/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.professor/...
- Sapient 15y agoI have only cut them out completely until I have reached a healthy weight. Once I am there, I will not introduce any refined carbs (sugar, flour etc) into my diet, but will increase certain carbs (Sweet potato, other fruits etc) until I find the point at which I put on weight again.