5 ms·
The title's "no moving control surfaces" (both on HN and the DARPA site) contradicts the article itself: > The X-65 will be built with two sets of control actu
by bell-cot 3y ago
The title's "no moving control surfaces" (both on HN and the DARPA site) contradicts the article itself:
> The X-65 will be built with two sets of control actuators – traditional flaps and rudders as well as AFC effectors embedded across all the lifting surfaces. This will both minimize risk and maximize the program’s insight into control effectiveness. The plane’s performance with traditional control surfaces will serve as a baseline; successive tests will selectively lock down moving surfaces, using AFC effectors instead.
> “The X-65 conventional surfaces are like training wheels to help us understand how AFC can be used in place of traditional flaps and rudders,” said Wlezien. “We’ll have sensors in place to monitor how the AFC effectors’ performance compares with traditional control mechanisms, and these data will help us better understand how AFC could revolutionize both military and commercial craft in the future.”
Was anyone else's first reaction to DARPA's "Artist's Rendering" to wonder "what new kiddie cartoon show is that from?"
- prox 3y agoI guess the goal is no moving control surfaces, but this prototype has both to understand and compare, that is how I read the article at least. The rendering could be straight from Thunderbirds if you give it a green lick of paint!
- ceejayoz 3y agoReminds me of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Tacit_Blue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Tacit_Blue a bit.
- ceejayoz 3y agoWhat contradiction? The prototype has both types of control surface. It’s for testing the new tech; you don’t want it uncontrollable if something goes wrong with the new stuff.
- bell-cot 3y ago[facepalm/] It was a reasonable design decision to put both types of controls on the prototype. But if I put chocolate chips in a cookie, claim that the cookie is chocolate-free, and then (when called on it) explain that the chocolate chips were only needed to make it taste good, while working on my cookie recipes - I still have lied.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThis is more like whining that a prototype wireless internet device had an Ethernet cord for debug access. “It’s not truly wireless!”
- bell-cot 3y agoFaulty analogy - "wireless internet" is a specific ~1/4-century-old computer set of technologies, and ~everyone knows that "wireless internet" devices still have plenty of cords. His Majesty's English contains quite a few words - "mixed" and "hybrid" come to mind - which could very easily be used to describe the airplane. Without resorting to a cool-but-counter-factual headline. BTW - how do you feel about Tesla's "Full Self Driving"?
- ceejayoz 3y ago> Faulty analogy You're gonna try that approach after the chocolate chip cookie one? > BTW - how do you feel about Tesla's "Full Self Driving"? That's a good analogy, actually. If it actually worked, it'd be fine to call it a "full self-driving car" even if it had a manual steering wheel option. Just like this prototype aircraft! The problem with FSD isn't the fact that it also has a steering wheel, it's that it can't actually meaningfully function without the steering wheel.
- datadrivenangel 3y agoThis is making a double batch of cookies that are half chocolate and half chocolate-free. You don't want to lose the whole batch of cookies and eat nothing, but still want to test the chocolate-free cookies.