11 ms·
Yes. Anything with finite memory is not Turing-complete, and transformers are finite-state machines. So what? Anything with infinite memory is un-buildable. Ye
by Animats 3y ago
Yes. Anything with finite memory is not Turing-complete, and transformers are finite-state machines. So what? Anything with infinite memory is un-buildable.
Yes, there's a school of philosophy that claims that AI cannot be built with digital hardware because it needs infinite state. Penrose is the leading exponent of this argument.[1] This isn't taken too seriously any more, now that finite machines are doing so well at AI.
This is close to theology. Man must be special, right? Only humans can play chess, right? Play Go? Pass the Turing test? Create art and music? We're running out of boxes to check. Common sense (as in getting through the next 30 seconds without a major screwup) and manipulation in unstructured settings are still in bad shape, but we only need squirrel-level AI for that.
On that subject, there was a "what does the cerebellum do" article on HN a few days ago. That's a big issue. The lower mammal brains are mostly cerebellum. The weak areas in AI at present are mostly cerebellum functions. That area has never gotten enough attention in AI research. Today, though, the amount of hardware to do a low-end mammal cerebellum equivalent doesn't seem at all unreasonable.
[1] https://sortingsearching.com/2021/07/18/roger-penrose-ai-skepticism.html https://sortingsearching.com/2021/07/18/roger-penrose-ai-ske...
- colechristensen 3y agoPenrose claims that human intelligence relies on quantum effects and demonstrates certain structures in neurons that makes it at least a plausible argument. It would follow that comparable intelligence would not be possible with current digital computer architectures. I also think a lot of people are a little too fooled by the “intelligence” of current models which are mimics with enormous libraries of “knowledge”. It is not too hard to be frustrated by the enormous limitations of current models. Impressive, yes, smart, no. Though to refute claims of their intelligence is really pushing to refine the philosophical definition of intelligence which has been rather vague so far. We can’t just say “i know it when i see it” because computers pretending is getting very good.
- jiggawatts 3y agoThere is no way to effectively pretend to be smart without actually being smart. This comes up a lot in things like science fiction, movies, etc... E.g.: an author can state that a character has "superhuman intelligence", but the author themselves would need to actually posses this superhuman intelligence to write the actions or dialogue of that character.[1] Because authors are "just human", they obviously can't be superhuman, so they generally avoid directly demonstrating the actions of superhumanly intelligent characters. I.e.: the "tell, not show" instead of the usual "show, don't tell." The current crop of AIs are 100% "show". They demonstrate intelligence directly, by answering questions instead of just talking about how they would answer questions, which is what fake intelligence would do. PS: Next time you see a politician promise to deliver a solution, but not actually state what that solution is... well... now you know what's going on with that particular situation! [1] There's a degree of cheating available to authors, because they have information that the in-world fictional characters don't. Similarly, they can set up the question to lead to an answer they already have. The chat-based AIs can't cheat like this, they have to answer the questions given to them.
- colechristensen 3y agoSure there is. Know the answers to questions already. Being trained on a noninsignificant proportion of all questions ever asked on the Internet means you have to wonder how smart LLMs really are. Seeing the ways they fail, confirms not so much. They are able to abstract a bit of knowledge an statically match it to questions and answers already seen. Confident hallucinations help you see this. The best hallucinations I saw was asking chatgpt for a list of references for a topic I was researching. They all looked entirely believable, titles, authors, institutions, summaries… IIRC there were about twenty of them. Only one actually existed.
- Aeolos 3y agoAsk a human the same question and force them to answer (instead of saying I don't know), and they will hallucinate a list of references for you just the same. Does that mean humans are not intelligent? I don't think your argument proves what you claim.
- ithkuil 3y agoThis! One could argue that humans will say "I don't know" when they don't know, but that ultimately depends on training. We currently don't have LLMs trained to answer "I don't know" (I suspect that in part that's due to incentives of focusing on something that looks impressive; one could argue that if an AI system too often says "I don't know" it's less impressive albeit it may be more useful since you can rely upon it more when it says it knows) There are plenty of cases where humans are trained to hope they sound convincing even if they make up answers. I've seen a fair share of this done by students.
- endofreach 3y agoThis was my goto argument when people without technical background were laughing about ChatGPTs bullshit generation (before it was called hallucinating). Put a gun to Einsteins head and force him to answer any question you ask him without hesitating or denying an answer. This is not an argument for stating LLMs like ChatGPT are intelligent (it is not, but not for any of the reasons i have read about so far anywhere). But the hallucinations definitely don't show anything about intelligence. Actually, if they did, they would actually indicate intelligence rather than not. So, quite the opposite which should be very obvious.
- patrakov 3y agoAnd so what? Your existence, as well as existence of Earth and anything else made of nuclei and electrons, relies on quantum effects.
- colechristensen 3y agoThe point being you would need a kind of quantum computer for real intelligence. It is at least a plausible requirement.
- sroussey 3y agoYet the digital computer is based on quantum effects in transistors. We engineer the weirdness away to give the illusion of a digital computer. Eventually we will go back and see what can be done without that. Boolean algebra is nice a clean but there are other ways.
- teaearlgraycold 3y agoEven then, it sounds like a speed issue. Quantum computers can be simulated on traditional computers. And quantum is coming, so those that repeat this theory to comfort themselves are at best buying time.
- drdeca 3y agoWhile quantum computers can be simulated classically, you can’t have the simulated state of a simulated quantum computer, be entangled with something outside of the classical computer doing the simulating, while a quantum computer could have qubits entangled with something outside of the quantum computer. So, if that was somehow important, then the “you can simulate the quantum computer classically (at the cost of exponential slowdown)” point wouldn’t handle that kind of thing. But, it seems rather unlikely to me that we’ll find any significant evidence of that kind of thing being important for intelligence.
- pelorat 3y agoWhy? Just introduce a separate loop of thoughts driven by a true quantum based RNG, something like a subconscious loop that subtly interacts with the rest of the system. With "loop of thoughts" I am talking about using an a true RNG to create a never ending stream of the system "talking" to itself, and the subconscious part being that it would run separately from all other processing. The current content of this loop, would be weakly injected into the prompt that drives the main loop of thoughts (or possibly multiple loops of thoughts, why limit to one after all). We won't reach AGI and true intelligence by adding more parameters, but via AutoGPT like systems that are self-driven without needing any external prompting. A simple addition of a true RNG will make the system nondeterministic.
- madhadron 3y ago> Penrose claims that human intelligence relies on quantum effects and demonstrates certain structures in neurons that makes it at least a plausible argument. Except that Penrose's argument is biologically nonsense, which probably means that he has an incorrect definition of intelligence, since I'm pretty confident in his ability to reason from axioms.
- jona-f 3y agoThe man did great things, but this quantum effect consciousness nonsense is a case of nobelitis. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_disease
- ithkuil 3y agoIirc his nobelitis around consciousness started before he even got awarded the prise. He clearly invented the time machine but didn't tell us yet
- kaba0 3y agoI don’t think we are running out of boxes. We just try to determine the minimum requirement that we could constitute as general AI, and that bound is hard to find. It’s quite trivial to find less than minimal bounds, say, writing a novel research paper, making a discovery/invention, etc.
- 3abiton 3y agoThis is such a philosophical rabbit hole that I will get into when time allows it.
- Animats 3y agoGood approach.
- drowsspa 3y ago> This is close to theology Yeah, even the arguments reek of basically "God of the gaps" and "moving the goalposts" stuff
- Tainnor 3y ago> Yes. Anything with finite memory is not Turing-complete, and transformers are finite-state machines. So what? Anything with infinite memory is un-buildable. I think that's missing the point. A Turing Machine description is independent of the memory provided to it by the hardware and it doesn't need to be rewritten every time the hardware improves. That's very different from a FSM which is restricted in memory a priori. I don't really know enough about transformers to understand where they fit in here, though some reviewers do seem to suggest that allowing transformers access to infinite memory does make them also Turing Complete.
- baq 3y agoEngineering POV makes sense, but Turing-completeness is well-defined in CS i.e. maths, and maths deals with unbuildable stuff all the time. You can't engineer a result into CS unless you prove your engineering in a mathematical fashion, e.g. the famous four colour theorem proof.
- sacado2 3y agoThe issue is that intelligence itself is an ill-defined concept, and an unofficial but broadly-shared rough definition is "what separates humans (and some animals) from unanimated things". So, as soon as a machine can do something (whether it's having good memory, proving things, playing chess, translating texts, drawing a picture, driving a car, anything) it no longer belongs to "intelligence". Using that very definition, AI is an oxymoron.
- Animats 3y agoAmusingly, there's part of the commercial AI community that wants to define intelligence as what companies will pay humans sitting at desks to do.
- b4ke 3y agoIsn’t genetic material an infinite state machine as long as the host system has the requisite support continuity? “Ai” is just the current moniker for a persistent assault on the original general intelligence (belief not required). Pretty sure religion is an accurate representation of a generative intelligence, but I digress to knowing little. “James