That was very similar to my reaction. All the fair use rhetoric is carefully caveated to public information. NYT is not publicly accessible, it's paid access. I

That was very similar to my reaction. All the fair use rhetoric is carefully caveated to public information. NYT is not publicly accessible, it's paid access. If this argument is true then zlib does nothing illegal the Internet Archive is allowed to scan books. We can't have this it's true and false dichotomy going.