4 ms·
Consider what happened after the Space Shuttle accidents. The vehicle was grounded for a long time (32 months for the Challenger accident). During that time t
by pfdietz 3y ago
Consider what happened after the Space Shuttle accidents. The vehicle was grounded for a long time (32 months for the Challenger accident). During that time the putative benefits of the launches were not being accrued. The stand down implies the value of these benefits couldn't be very large, given the expected number of additional astronaut lives saved during that time.
In general, it's economically irrational to spend large amounts of money making space travel safer for a small number of astronauts. It would be better to just say "this is dangerous as hell; we'll pay you $10M/mission (say) to justify the risk."
- gmac 3y agoI'd say this kind of highlights the limits of economic rationality as a decision-making rule. Yes, that's rational. But being careless with other people's lives is something many people (including me, an economist) are morally not OK with.
- pfdietz 3y agoI'd say it illustrates that the Space Shuttle program wasn't actually worthwhile. When push came to shove, the supposed benefits were less than a rather piddling amount of astronaut life value. We have no trouble continuing to risk lives in other activities (the military, for example).
- gmac 3y agoQuite possibly. But I suspect the full benefits are pretty hard to assess from our armchairs. I imagine there's a fair amount of useful technology that got developed along the way, and a bunch of global cultural value (and US soft power) over several decades derived from having putting a person on the moon.
- pfdietz 3y agoThose benefiting from the spending have incentive to exaggerate the benefits up to the limit of plausibility. So, as a rule of thumb, expect the actual benefits to be less than the claimed benefits. It's certainly the case that many of the supposed benefits of the Space Shuttle (and the Space Station) didn't materialize. The Space Shuttle has the additional "negative benefit" of having retarded development of US expendable boosters. Something like an expendable Falcon 9 could have been created decades earlier, had policy been rational.
- GuB-42 3y ago- Even with no one on board, losing a Space Shuttle is a big deal - Astronauts received expensive training, you don't want to lose the investment - Astronauts are not just random people, they have a hard to find set of qualities - Having people die in public is bad publicity It is not politically correct to say it like that, but it is undeniable that some lives are more valuable than others. $10M is kind of an average. When you build a road for instance, astronauts and violent criminals can both take it. The astronaut is more valuable than the criminal, but it makes no sense to make the road safer for astronauts without making it safer for everyone else, so we take an average. But put in their respective environments (Space Shuttle vs prison), it becomes very obvious whose life is the most valuable.
- grotorea 3y agoYou'd need to factor in the prestige and national morale costs , plus the political consequences.
- pfdietz 3y agoBy "political consequences" you mean "this might interrupt our gravy train". Of course that was the real reason.
- grotorea 3y agoI was thinking "it would look bad on the polls" but yeah that too.
- supertrope 3y agoHaving a schoolteacher become an astronaut and broadcasting a disaster on live TV kids back the US Space Program tremendously. Also the Cold War ended so the motivation behind funding dual use aerospace technologies weakened. (The same technology that can propel astronaut capsules and satellites into space and recover them can also launch nukes).