3 ms·
Serious question: why do you expect VR to take off with the general public? A decade into VR experiments, and nobody has come up with good non-gaming applicatio
by adastra22 3y ago
Serious question: why do you expect VR to take off with the general public? A decade into VR experiments, and nobody has come up with good non-gaming applications better than cartoony chat apps. It’s got a worse track record than blockchain.
- freeone3000 3y agoSpace is limited, screens are expensive and hard to transport, and people are more mobile than ever. Having your multi-monitor setup at a coffeeshop just as it is at home is a huge gain. I’m not expecting this to replace monitors for most people now. But next monitor upgrade, if you already work on a Macbook, it might be a better option than an external display for some people.
- jprete 3y agoIt would be easier and simpler to use a portable LCD monitor. They do exist and are simpler, smaller, and cheaper than a VR headset. Tablets could have been used for the same use case. But...they aren't. People don't want it. What they want is a computer so light that it's always available. Most people seem to carry phones for consumption and sometimes lightweight laptops for work.
- vel0city 3y agoI've seen a few people bust out portable secondary displays or use a tablet in screen mirroring mode. Personally, I find the experience still pretty clumsy. The monitors are still not at an ideal height, they're usually smaller than I'd like, they take up a lot of table space. I'm not sure VR headsets are going to take off from this use case, but if the VR headset is good enough, I'd imagine the experience of the floating screens would be far better than having a portable monitor. Busting out a portable wireless keyboard and putting on an HMD would be pretty neat IMO, if the HMD was good enough.
- adastra22 3y agoOr just multiple virtual displays on your laptop? There are plenty of laptops with 4K of better resolution, which is what the Vision has. VR lets you swivel your head to get more real estate, but it doesn’t let you look at more pixels at once. Not unless you zoom out, which is what exposé already does. But sure, you can strap a couple kilos of hardware to your face and take on that neck strain, disconnect yourself from the environment around you, and introduce motion sickness just to avoid pressing F3.
- shafyy 3y ago> It’s got a worse track record than blockchain This is not true. VR gaming is something some people genuinely enjoy doing and paying money for. There are more than handful of VR gaming studios that can run healthy businesses based on this market. I'm not saying that the Vision Pro will make VR replace laptops, someday it might, who knows. But suggesting that there is zero value from VR is also not true.
- adastra22 3y agoI said "non-gaming applications." Apple is marketing this for general consumer adoption. What are those applications?
- shafyy 3y agoI'm sorry, I must have missed that. I'm not sure what non-gaming applications could take off, to be honest. Some ideas: - VR meetings in my opinion feel better than 2D Zoom calls - but I don't see companies buying VR headsets for this purpose for their employees - Education: There's definitely some cool stuff here, but hard to monetize I think (did something in this space a few years ago) - Non-gaming entertainment, such as watching movies on big screens. This could be the next big area for VR after gaming. - Fitness. You could count this as gaming, but specific fitness apps are really popular and I would define fitness as a separate category.
- adastra22 3y agoThanks for the serious response and example app ideas.
- cljacoby 3y agoI'd consider buying a headset that could do the following: - Virtual desktop experience at least as good as a single 27inch monitor - Doesn't make me nauseous or hurt my neck - Isn't egregiously expensive (3,500 is pretty steep)
- bilalq 3y agoI don't think it's a worse track record than blockchain. Things are clunky now, but there are some genuinely fun and cool experiences to be had: - Playing table tennis in VR is more fun than in real life since you don't have to go chasing around the room to pick up balls. - I've used VR headsets to show my parents and other elderly folks photosphere shots I've taken from mountain summits that they would never be able to access or see in person. - There are some VR games that are quite well received (e.g., Half-Life Alyx). - Beat Saber is a blast. I totally agree that where the technology is today, it's not ready for broad adoption. But as displays, materials, and capabilities expand, so too do the possibilities. We're probably not going to hit sci-fi levels of VR anytime in the next decade, but we can almost certainly create compelling experiences that go far beyond what exists today.
- adastra22 3y agoI said "non-gaming applications." I can see the immediate and obvious application to gaming, even though I'm not a gamer myself. But the hardcore gamers that would use such a device are still a niche market. If Apple's making it, they're expect mass consumer applications though. I just don't see that. Being able to "summit" a mountain without actually being there is an interesting use case though. Thanks for that.
- bilalq 3y agoSorry, I missed that in your earlier post. In terms of experiences that work today outside gaming, I guess we mostly just have 360 videos and virtual workspaces/screens. The former is a novelty and the latter has been held back by display capabilities. The Vision Pro might actually be good enough for that latter use-case though.