3 ms·
> An Irish employee of Israeli tech company Wix... Reaction: Not that I'm any sort of expert - but "Israel routinely treats the Palestinians horribly" has bee
by bell-cot 3y ago
> An Irish employee of Israeli tech company Wix...
Reaction: Not that I'm any sort of expert - but "Israel routinely treats the Palestinians horribly" has been a widely-asserted and widely-believed meme for the past 3/4 century. If the employee in question wasn't okay-ish with that...why was she working at Wix?
- Freak_NL 3y agoIn what sense is that a meme?
- padjo 3y agoThey probably felt there’s a difference between treating them poorly and killing them
- bell-cot 3y agoNot an expert...but hasn't "Palestinian kid throws rock at Israeli soldier, soldier responds by shooting the kid dead" been a fairly-regular thing since the 1950's?
- SauciestGNU 3y agoI dont know what to say besides what's happening right now has a different feeling than shooting a kid for throwing stones. As wrong as that is (I believe), the Israelis can point to the concrete action of the stone throwing as a proximate cause for execution. The current conflict is killing tens of thousands of noncombatants who had nothing to do with the October incursion. They may have supported it politically, or celebrated the violence against their oppressors, but that doesn't make them combatants deserving of death. I think the difference now is the clarity of the mass disproportionate response. It's impossible to stretch the definition of "self-defense" to include the actions Israel is currently taking. I think that's why people are motivated to respond differently and with a different degree.
- bell-cot 3y agoSadly, 5-digit civilian casualties (when the Israeli military sweeps through an area) is probably nothing new - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1982_Lebanon_War#Casualties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1982_Lebanon_War#Casualties
- MrJohz 3y agoWix is not a state-run company, is it? It seems reasonable to me to be able to distinguish between "Israel, the government/state" and Israelis.
- bell-cot 3y agoTo some degree, during periods of relative peace, yes. But could you point out any large Israeli companies which are any sort of "neutral" in the current Israel/Hamas war? Or any large Ukrainian company which is okay with employees voicing pro-Russian sentiments? Or any large American company ... in the year or so after the 9/11 attacks? Or any large Indian ... during the Indo-Pakistani war of 1965? Or any large British ... during WWI? This really is not a new thing.
- pastage 3y agoThis is a bit different than the cancel movement and nation states at war, but sure there are parallels. Having a bunch of rich dudes having secret meeting on who they should fire/mess up next really sucks.
- jbstack 3y agoWhy does the fact that an employee isn't ok with Israel (in this context, a government) mean that she shouldn't work at Wix (a company)? I don't agree with all the policies of my country's government (UK). Does that mean I shouldn't work for any British company?
- bell-cot 3y agoDepends on context. If (say) Argentina invaded the Falkland Islands again, then the UK declared war against Argentina and launched a major military campaign against them - would you expect your employer to be cool with your vocal support for the Argentine side?
- jbstack 3y agoYou seem to have pivoted away from the original point you were making, which was why the employee was working at an Israeli company if she disagrees with actions of the Israeli state. But to address your new point: Being "cool" with it is a different thing from firing me for it. I'd expect my employer to form its own opinion which might differ from mine, and I'd reasonably expect my employer to dictate what I can express while I'm representing them (e.g. while speaking to customers, or posting to the company website). I'd also expect them not to get involved in my private life and to respect my rights under the Equality Act 2010; specifically Section 4 (belief is a protected characteristic), Section 13 (discrimination = treating someone less favorably than others based on a protected characteristic), and Section 39(2) (discriminating against someone by dismissing them is unlawful discrimination).