6 ms·
Obama Administration Threatens To Veto CISPA
- HistoryInAction 15y agoFour main points in the veto threat: 1. Protect user privacy, separate intra-government sharing from government/private sharing (troubling because data shared with DHS could possible be shared with NSA or FBI then, even if the company doesn't intend for that data to go to those agencies) 2. More oversight/liability for inappropriate use of these proposed powers; data sharing should not be used to help incumbents crush startups 3. Liability waivers to encourage information sharing go way too far, protects bad behavior 4. Internet is civilian, but bill treats it as military re: intelligence, which is bad
- tptacek 15y agoYou're kidding yourself if you think privacy is a top-of-mind issue for the Administration. They're pushing back on CISPA --- as they have been since last year, and even longer if you understand the idea CISPA is trying to express --- because their agenda is to enact government controls on the security of "critical information systems". CISPA is the GOP's "let the industry regulate itself" response to the Obama Administration's concern about Chinese state sponsored hacking. The privacy issue here is a fig leaf; CISPA is entirely voluntary (unlike previous "cybersecurity" bills supported by the administration), and private industry already has the legal tools to feed private information to the government under the ECPA.
- HistoryInAction 15y agoWhen it comes to government, I try not to put my personal views in for just the reasons you cite. That's just my analysis of the language in the veto threat, nothing more. ECPA, though, that's another thing to research, thanks. I just want to focus on getting founders the visas they need to build great companies; I don't know anything about this open internet stuff, but I keep getting dragged into it.
- francoisdevlin 15y agoHe WANTS the DHS involved? I'm not sure that's a trade off I'm willing to make. Let's hope the thing just dies.
- jellicle 15y agoObama has vetoed two (2) bills to date. CISPA is certainly not going to be #3. Grade sitting Presidents participating in a reelection campaign on their actions, not their words.
- krschultz 15y agoThat's because once the president says he is going to veto a bill, it almost never makes it to his desk. Much like the threat of a filibuster is basically as powerful as a filibuster, the threat of a veto is almost as powerful as a veto.
- maratd 15y ago> That's because once the president says he is going to veto a bill, it almost never makes it to his desk. You're being vague. The truth is, once the president says he's going to veto a bill, it never makes it to his desk in its present state. In fact, all of the veto threats outline the parts he has a problem with and those parts usually go away. But some laws can't be fixed. They can't be fixed because they're based on a false premise. Enough with these threats of fix this or fix that! Garbage shall not pass. As simple as that.
- yahelc 15y agoIssuing a veto threat and then not following up on that veto is pretty much the biggest tactical mistake a President can make. The whole point of a veto threat is to make a credible threat to coerce Congress to change course. If he didn't follow through, all his future veto threats would ring hollow and he'd have lost an important executive tool. Even if he didn't want to veto CISPA on principle, at this point he has too.
- baddox 15y agoWhy not just veto bills when you want to veto them, and signing them when you want to sign them?
- 15y ago
- MBlume 15y agoI still get a bad feeling from the fact that this e-mail talks about "cybersecurity" like it's not a made up word with no referent
- mncolinlee 15y agoThe president threatened to veto the National Defense Authorization Act as well, yet he still signed it into law with the objectionable clauses. The administration simply added a signing statement that the President wouldn't use the more dangerous powers to indefinitely detain U.S. citizens, which were granted by that legislation. I'm glad to hear this veto threat, but I hope our President has the sense this time to realize that signed laws can be used or abused by any future President. We cannot predict how laws will be used. Software patents are a classic example.
- ewillbefull 15y ago> The president threatened to veto the National Defense Authorization Act as well, yet he still signed it into law with the objectionable clauses. These are disjunctive. The President threatened a veto of the NDAA over very specific provisions that he disagreed with, which _were_ removed eventually. In addition, the NDAA did not authorize anything habeas corpus related that the Supreme Court hadn't already ruled AUMF did. (See Hamdi v. Rumsfeld) I would rather see a more pointed example of blatant disregard of a veto threat before I cast judgement on the credibility of this one.
- mncolinlee 15y agoThis doesn't invalidate anything I said. The sections which were removed were designed to compel the executive branch to take certain actions. The Obama administration believed Congress should not have the power to compel the President to take action. Instead, the administration is only allowed to indefinitely detain citizens without trial in the final bill's section 1021. Unlike section 1021, Hamdi v. Rumsfeld only applies to citizens arrested overseas like Hamdi (in a literal battlefield) so long as they may contest their designation as an "enemy combatant". A veto threat is not a veto promise. Just because most Americans oppose a certain provision doesn't mean the veto threat is conditioned on removing that same provision. The proof is in the handling of the NDAA bill text.
- azernik 15y agoIn that case, the sections the Administration objected to (and got removed) were about compelling the executive branch to act; in this case, the ones cited in the veto threat (http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/opinion-la/la-ol-obama-administrations-threatens-to-veto-cispa-20120425,0,1194826.story http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/opinion-la/la-ol-obama-a...) are about the precisely the privacy concerns you're worried about. Though I'm not familiar enough with the bill to know if everything objectionable in CISPA is in fact objected to in the memo, it's definitely a substantial and positive step.
- picklefish 15y agoIf CISPA were to pass, what would stop someone from hacking into your local ISP and dumping a database on the web so all your friends can check out your surfing habits? If ISPs are required to start logging data like that there is no way it's going to be safe. Granted I'm sure a lot of them already log data like that already.
- snowwrestler 15y agoCISPA would not require ISPs to start logging data, or in fact to do anything whatsoever. Participation in data sharing under CISPA would be completely voluntary, which is why businesses like the bill.
- parfe 15y agoAsk Qwest how the government encourages "voluntary" participation. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2007/10/qwest-ceo-nsa-punished-qwest-refusing-participate-illegal-surveillance-pre-9-11 https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2007/10/qwest-ceo-nsa-punished...
- unreal37 15y agoI love that the statement says "his senior advisers will recommend a veto" and not actually that he plans to veto it. There are weasel words in there for him to pass the legislation as-is.
- lallysingh 15y agoElection year.
- vinayan3 15y ago:(. As others have noted advisors recommend he should veto it. I hope the President directly says that he will veto it. If this gets passed and goes through I'll be really disappointed.
- dmfdmf 15y agoIts fascinating and frightening watching the advancement of the legal powers and psychology necessary for a dictatorship in the USA. Its an open question whether Americans will see it in time to stop it before said powers are used to suspend the constitution, in the "public interest" (via the Democrats) or "national security" (via the Republicans). In the end, the specific rationalization won't matter. Don't forget, the Nazis did not "take over" Germany but were legally voted into office where they proceeded to legally suspend the rights of German citizens. It is no accident that the US government is trying to control and throttle the internet. As dictatorships around the world have discovered, its the internet and freedom OR dictatorship. Our homegrown power lusters, such as Obama, are paying lip service to our rights while doing everything in their power to abrogate them. The internet has destroyed the traditional means (primarily via the NYT and the MSM) of controlling the political discourse and agenda . Like it or not, we are in the middle of the greatest social revolution since the invention of the printing press destroyed the power of the Catholic Church. See Clay Shirky's article on this topic; http://www.shirky.com/weblog/2009/03/newspapers-and-thinking-the-unthinkable/ http://www.shirky.com/weblog/2009/03/newspapers-and-thinking... Nobody really knows how this will turn out.
- coffeemug 15y agoThere is no evidence that any individual, oligarchy, or organization is driving the country towards a dictatorship. The truth is actually quite a bit scarier - it's the massive, complex, screeching, unstoppable human system that happened to have evolved a set of incentives that have nothing to do with dictatorship but drive the country towards one anyway. The congressmen are concerned by the next election, and the primary concern that currently drives american voters is the economy. So they're working to protect the intellectual property since it's pretty much the only thing we produce. That's a tiny assault on the constitution. The president is terrified of another terrorist attack because it will probably mean the end of his administration. So he has massive incentives to expand the rights of security organizations. That's a tiny assault on the constitution. The mayors are concerned with looking tough on crime, so they incentivize the police officers to stretch the concept of probably cause to clean up the streets. That's a tiny assault on the constitution from the other side, the municipalities. This goes on, and on. If we had a person or an organization to take a stand against, things would have been much easier. But how do you take a stand against a massive system that includes every commercial organization, individual, municipality, and state and federal agency in the country? Ultimately, a small group citizens concerned about individual freedoms cannot fight a massive system head on. There isn't enough energy or resources for dealing with millions of little issues one by one. The only way to make a difference is change the minds of the electorate in a scalable way. We haven't figured out a way to do that yet, because the right idea, the right meme that resonates with the majority of the populace hasn't been feed. This is why things may seem hopeless. But as we've grown to appreciate, this can change in a matter of days. TL;DR: freedom needs a viral YouTube video.
- tptacek 15y agoThis thread is mostly an uninformed fever swamp. The Obama Administration is not being a friend to the Internet here; the opposite is in fact largely true. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3891094 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3891094
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoInformation on the bill from govtrack: http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/112/hr3523 http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/112/hr3523 Note that there are already 112 co-sponsors of the bill with folks from both parties. If there isn't some huge groundswell of public opinion (and a few nerd-oriented trade articles don't qualify) this could get a fairly big vote in the House. Perhaps veto-proof, more probably loaded up with lots more stuff anybody in their right mind would support (Orphan-Feeding Act of 2012?). It has certainly been set up to succeed. (Political wonk note: big difference between a bill with 100+ supporters from both parties coming to a committee vote and something like Chuck Schumer's yesterday one-of threats for better immigration law. They both might be reported in the same way, but there's a huge difference in the underlying reality.)
- droithomme 15y agoSeveral times Obama has deflected criticism of some dangerous bill by saying he would not sign it, and then when everyone wanders off because they assume the veto is a sure thing and protest is no longer needed, he signs it. Example: NDAA.
- tomelders 15y agoIt's great that he said that, but no one should take it for granted. The public efforts to oppose CISPA should be maintained, even if it's just to be doubly sure that it doesn't pass.