4 ms·
If (deliberately) picking losers is easy, you should buy an index fund and do some careful shorting on the side. Instead of saying 'most stocks suck', you shou
by eru 3y ago
If (deliberately) picking losers is easy, you should buy an index fund and do some careful shorting on the side.
Instead of saying 'most stocks suck', you should probably say that probability distribution of future prices of stocks is highly skewed, but current prices reflect the expected future price. Logically, the median stock (and thus most stocks) will trade above its future potential.
Suppose you had a lottery where 90% of tickets pay one hundred dollar next week. You wouldn't say those tickets suck. You'd be happy to own lots of them.
Now suppose I tell you that the other 10% of tickets pay one million dollars next week. That makes the tickets even more desirable.
But in an efficient market, all tickets will trade at approximately 100,000 dollars today. That will make it look like 90% of tickets suck. But both in lottery tickets and in stocks, suck-age is relative to prices paid.
If 60% of tickets paid X, and 40% paid 0, then tickets would trade for about 0.6 * X, and most tickets will look like they don't suck: most tickets almost double in value.
- ac29 3y ago> If (deliberately) picking losers is easy, you should buy an index fund and do some careful shorting on the side. This doesnt make sense. The "losers" in this case don't necessarily go down in price, they just go up in price less than the overall market. Shorting these losers would still lose you money. Its easy to pick a stock that goes up less than the market, its hard to pick a stock that goes down (at least one that goes down by more than the cost to borrow and short it).
- eru 3y agoBuy the index fund to get the market return, then pick out and short the 'losers' that either don't grow or grow slower than the index. Either way, you will have increased your returns.
- throw0101d 3y ago> If (deliberately) picking losers is easy, you should buy an index fund and do some careful shorting on the side. "Lose" also includes stalling such that as the rest of the market goes up, your portfolio does not do anything. It can even mean when the market goes up 5% your portfolio only goes up 3%. Now compound this lack of performance over a few decades, both pre-retirement when accumulating, and post-retirement during decumulation.
- eru 3y agoBoth of your alternative definitions of 'lose' are fine. Buy the index fund to get the market return, then pick out and short the 'losers' that either don't grow or grow slower than the index. Either way, you will have increased your returns.