3 ms·
This report is repeating a line of BS I've seen before from MIT. They say renewables + batteries for the entire grid becomes very expensive without a "firming
by pfdietz 3y ago
This report is repeating a line of BS I've seen before from MIT.
They say renewables + batteries for the entire grid becomes very expensive without a "firming source". They then say nuclear is a firming source. They then at least imply, if not outright say, that nuclear is needed to supplement a renewable grid. (See page 10 of the full report.)
But this is bullshit. There are other firming sources that would work better than nuclear. In particular, green hydrogen, produced by electrolysis, would be a great firming source. It would be much better than nuclear for this, since a simple cycle combustion turbine power plant has just 1/20th the capital cost of today's nuclear power plants (combined cycle, just 1/10th the cost.) For a low capacity factor firming source, minimizing capital cost is all important.
- acidburnNSA 3y agoGreen hydrogen is not a "source" at all. It's an energy storage mechanism that would have to be powered by additional green capacity. There is a legitimate concern that expanding wind/solar will run into increasing costs, NIMBY, and transmission issues at extremely large scale. Nuclear may help there by virtue of it being highly concentrated and 24/7.
- pfdietz 3y agoYour quibble there does absolutely nothing to refute my argument, so why did you make it? Of course green hydrogen is storage. So what? It acts as a way to produce the firming that is needed to deal with long wavelength intermittency. Your concern mongering there seems entirely vacuous. If anything, wind/solar have seen aggressive experience effects that reduce costs at larger scale, not increase them.
- acidburnNSA 3y agoThe point is that if you just look at cost of hydrogen equipment, you're missing the cost of the equipment that has to charge it as well. Have you read Komanoff's hypothesis that any given energy technology's cost scales to first order with sector size? It's quite an argument. He used it to explain unrelated cost escalations in nuclear and coal. It says that the bigger a sector is, the more people are impacted, and the more regulations and other externalities come in. For wind and solar, you can imagine land use leading to more NIMBY and transmission costs, and increasing costs of dealing with high intermittency (e.g. 2-week long wind droughts across 4 huge states that regularly occur in January).
- pfdietz 3y agoAh, but the equipment to charge it is the renewable sources you're already building. These are installed with some overcapacity, so they can more often provide what they're required to provide directly to the grid. But this means they also produce excess output, which can then be diverted to hydrogen production. One gets two bites at the apple here; the two approaches are synergistic with overall cost less than the sum of the costs of each separately. As I have repeatedly pointed out, simulations based on actual weather data show green hydrogen can be highly effective at reducing the overall cost of a RE grid, vs. just using batteries alone.
- Yoric 3y agoGreen hydrogen, produced by electrolysis, requires a source of energy (also, if my memory serves, platinum). Do you mean that one can use hydrogen as storage to bridge the gap between daylight/wind/tides/... periods?
- jillesvangurp 3y agoThe issue with statements like this is that the question of how much capacity exactly is needed for this is never really specified in these reports. It's all a bit hand wavy and unscientific. As soon as you specify a number in gw of capacity needed, the challenge becomes a lot more simple to address. And of course there are a wide range of mostly existing technologies that you could use for this. We have pumped hydro, geothermal, off shore wind, and a few other things. Just to name a few things that we are already doing at large scale. And especially offshore wind sure is coming online a lot faster and at a much larger scale than nuclear in recent years. And a lot cheaper. Add to that storage systems, of which there are a wide variety being field tested right now, and the picture gets even better. It's not at all clear that renewables plus that would not be enough. The premise that nuclear is the only option doesn't really add up. It's wishful thinking by people that have a hammer and are looking for nails to wack with it. At the current cost level nuclear is not an option at all. The report acknowledges as much. We could do it technically but it's a bit of a hassle and would consume a lot of tax payer money (forget about doing this profitably without that). It's a lot cheaper and easier to get the necessary capacity with cheaper technology. The notion that it is impossible to do this without nuclear and that we don't know how to do this, etc. is simply not based in reality. We have plenty of promising things. Specify how much you need and then it just becomes an engineering challenge. You can start planning and budgeting for it and get it done. Maybe nuclear will be part of this. But probably not at the current cost level. It will have to come down a lot. But the new type of nuclear that will have that cost level is as of yet unproven technology. There are some companies working on this of course. But they have a lot to prove still.