Personally, those criteria seem irrelevant. If people were immortal and infinitely replicable, what they're allowed to read/learn/speak shouldn't change! Ditto

Personally, those criteria seem irrelevant. If people were immortal and infinitely replicable, what they're allowed to read/learn/speak shouldn't change! Ditto for the machine counterfactual (limited AI reproduction + mortality). Maybe I'm just being unhelpfully sci-fi/abstract here. If humans are contextually special here, a "passing the torch" argument seems unconvincing, to me.