4 ms·
> well what about Figma and Photoshop I, for one, don't want them rendered in my browser. I have an OS that can run apps, and I want my browser to be an app th
by palata 3y ago
> well what about Figma and Photoshop
I, for one, don't want them rendered in my browser. I have an OS that can run apps, and I want my browser to be an app that renders simple HTML pages. If you want an app, make a damn Desktop app that can run on my OS.
- dstroot 3y agoWell… if you have ever supported a desktop app you know how difficult “version dispersion”, users that never update their OS, users that always update their OS, different hardware, other hostile software, etc. can be. If you know, you know.
- palata 3y agoSure, I'm not saying it's easier. It would be completely stupid to go down the webapps road if the desktop apps one was both better and easier. I kind of find it ironic, though: why not write one desktop app that only supports the latest version of Windows, and tell your users to use that? If you're big enough, surely you can force them to use the OS you want, right? I am convinced that most people who love webapps kind of hate the idea of being forced to use the latest version of Windows. But somehow they find it okay to force everyone to use Chromium? What's the difference?
- skydhash 3y agoWhat I remember was mostly minimum and standard requirements listed on the product pages.
- throwitaway1123 3y agoI couldn't disagree more. Desktop apps are often so invasive that they almost feel like malware. Every time I install a desktop app I have to ensure that it isn't reading random files from my filesystem, snooping on my clipboard, or making itself persistent so that it restarts automatically every time I reboot my computer. Adobe apps like Photoshop are some of the worst offenders. Sometimes I'll kill an Adobe process running in the background, only to realize that there's an additional background process ready to restart the first one. It's like playing whack a mole trying to stop all of the creative cloud junk processes. I would much rather sandbox software like that in the browser where I can close a tab and be done with it (and where I'll be prompted before an app tries to read passwords from my clipboard or access files from my filesystem).
- palata 3y agoYou can sandbox desktop apps, you don't need to run them in a browser that is so complex that nobody can even imagine writing a new one. For instance Android does that sandboxing by default.
- throwitaway1123 3y ago> You can sandbox desktop apps You can do a lot of things in theory, but in practice browsers are much better sandboxes than desktop operating systems. > a browser that is so complex that nobody can even imagine writing a new one. I'm not sure how this is relevant? As a user I don't care how complex a browser is. I care that it sandboxes applications better than my desktop operating system. Unless you mean to say that the complexity implies a greater surface area for security related bugs, in which case surely the underlying os is even more complex (which is what native apps run on). I would imagine writing a new desktop os would be even more complex than writing a browser app that runs on top of it. > For instance Android does that sandboxing by default. Ok, so now we're talking about mobile operating systems rather than desktop operating systems, which to me feels like an implicit concession that desktop operating systems are indeed bad at sandboxing applications. But even if we do shift the goalposts — even mobile operating systems pale in comparison to a web browser when it comes to sandboxing. Android and iOS will notify you if an app reads from the clipboard (which they've only recently started doing), but your browser won't just notify you, it'll ask you to confirm before a website reads from the clipboard. A website can't even make a request to a third party domain unless the website has cors enabled. And new vulnerabilities pop up all the time. There was an article that generated a lot of traction on HN just a few weeks ago about how certain iOS applications can pinpoint your location by scanning for known hot spots your device has access to [1]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38720656 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38720656
- palata 3y ago> but in practice browsers are much better sandboxes than desktop operating systems. Do you know anything about sandboxing, or are you throwing that there for the sake of the argument? > I would imagine writing a new desktop os would be even more complex than writing a browser app that runs on top of it. Oh right, I guess you don't really know about sandboxing then. So it won't be a super constructive debate given that your position is apparently fundamentally based on your intuition about sandboxing. > As a user I [...] I don't know who invented that "As a user" thing, but I find it completely stupid. In my view it is just used as a justification for anything one wants when they don't have a better argument. In this case users are perfectly fine running standalone apps on their smartphone, let's not pretend they would really not want the same model on their desktop. > which to me feels like an implicit concession that desktop operating systems are indeed bad at sandboxing applications. Not at all, I was just giving a real-world example of sandboxing of apps at scale. > even mobile operating systems pale in comparison to a web browser when it comes to sandboxing If your baseline is sending a full web browser with every app you make, on desktop you could run each app in a VM and it would obviously be better. > A website can't even make a request to a third party domain unless the website has cors enabled. An app can't make a request unless it has the internet permission, what's your point? My point is that webapps move everything into the browser, going towards a world where something like ChromeOS is the only valid way to use a computer. I want to choose my OS, I don't want to rent an OS provided by BigTech, whether it is ChromeOS, Windows or anything else. The model where users pay for a product but don't own it is good for companies, not for users. "As a user", I want to own the product I pay for. And I want to pay for the product I want to own.