3 ms·
I really hope Mastodon is just a stepping stone and evolutionary dead end. The "federation mods are all powerful" is another step in the wrong direction. Reddi
by echelon 3y ago
I really hope Mastodon is just a stepping stone and evolutionary dead end.
The "federation mods are all powerful" is another step in the wrong direction. Reddit mods revel in the control they wield, and we've already seen this happening in the Mastodon ecosystem all over again.
BlueSky's protocol will allow end users to subscribe to the moderator(s) they want without having to worry about choices being made for them carte blanche by online dictators lording over their fiefdoms.
The internet bred the worst kind of power structures. We're sliding backwards with these platforms that enable and empower useless middle managers.
- izzydata 3y agoSo far Mastodon has been reasonable, but I've personally seen another federated Reddit clone Lemmy fell down this Rabbit hole. The two "biggest" instances admins are all power hungry and like to bully users to exert their authority. The people who always end up as admins and power moderators on these sites are absolutely the ones who should not have it.
- mariusor 3y agoI know this is probably not what you want to hear, but you just need to search for the right instance. You must treat the fediverse the same way as your neighbourhood not a club. You should not go to the most glamourous instance, but find one that has people that share the same values you do.
- brnt 3y agoWhat I'll say to that advice is that it boils down to self-bubbling, which isn't what some want, and not what most need.
- izzydata 3y agoAll instances combined of Lemmy is already small. If 99% of the traffic of the all instances combined come from 2-3 instances and all of it is run by terrible people then I don't really see how going somewhere that has a handful of active people is a solution. Honestly that particular federated experiment has failed which is fine. More will pop up.
- mariusor 3y ago> Honestly that particular federated experiment has failed which is fine. Everybody is complaining about failures in the fediverse but nobody applies the elbow grease to grow better communities. It's a bit of a self fulfilling prophecy there. :)
- izzydata 3y agoI was busy doing just that and grew a community to 10,000 subscribers. Things were going great and then the administrators abused their powers and took over the community and banned me. They don't follow their own rules so I don't see the point. I was in it for the long haul, but such a thing really destroys your motivation. It's a neat trick though. Let other people put in the work and then ban them and give their communities to their friends.
- mariusor 3y agoIdeally you do this in a community where you trust the sysop, or you are the sysop. See my previous comment.
- davidy123 3y agoRight on. Not only that, but from what I've read, the protocol is a mess. It lurches in a number of directions but doesn't successfully reach any of them. So it's really hard to develop for, you pretty much have to be an insider to make any progress. Which adds up to a terrible standard. But above all, as you pointed out, why are people trying so hard to replicate an obviously easily exploitable and now more prone to individual failure/abuse model? Is unprotected identities and scraps of paper, oh and tags like 2007 twitter, really the best, most user honouring application of current tech? https://cosocial.ca/@hrefna@hachyderm.io/111692934209903603 https://cosocial.ca/@hrefna@hachyderm.io/111692934209903603
- mariusor 3y agoI'm curious what you're reading into what Hrefna said to make you believe that the protocol is a mess. If there is such a thing, it's mostly due to many fediverse developers trying to maintain interop with Mastodon, which leads to innumerable quirks that one needs to be mindful of. Why do you think another protocol which has barely any implementations at the moment would be better when confronted with the same problem: many developers, interpreting some things in many ways?
- davidy123 3y agohmm did you read the entire thread? comments like «The problem is that _AP itself_ is hard to implement correctly and nontrivially in a way that scales», «I was surprised at how difficult I found the spec(s) to read compared to theoretically more complex ones I've read in the past,» «something went direly wrong in the standards realm sometime around the OAuth2 RFC, which says verbatim that following the spec as it stands will produce implementations that don't interoperate. ActivityPub has the same nature and when we complained about it last year we got a bunch of dweebs telling us that the activitypub spec is fine because it has optional protocol annexes that "all the real implementations" follow»… and basically all the comments. including yours. I wasn't specifically endorsing Bluesky, but it would not be surprising if a professional, clean slate protocol based on the "learnings" of the past would be simpler to implement and just all round better. I think the use of DIDs opens up to many interesting options, none of which need to use a blockchain. It's a shame about ActivityPub, I think Linked Data is a really important tech that hasn't been picked up enough, but from what I hear it's a really half hearted implementation at best.
- fifteen1506 3y agoCan you link to a page about that Bluesky's moderator part? Thanks!
- echelon 3y agoComposable Moderation: https://blueskyweb.xyz/blog/4-13-2023-moderation https://blueskyweb.xyz/blog/4-13-2023-moderation Anyone can label content. It can be human or automated. Different teams can expose their own sets of labels. The end user chooses which labels they want hidden or displayed. - - - - - - Edit: The downvotes I'm getting triggered the HN commenting rate limit, and I can no longer post comments. (Another form of censorship. Though I do appreciate everything HN does to be "high signal", there are some rough edges. I really want for systems that just get out of the way and let people communicate.) Here's my response to a child comment: > Which is entirely possible to do under ActivityPub. Several Mastodon instances block people who federate or engage elsewhere. That's the kind of fucked up middle management that a first-principles distributed moderation system would solve. For instance, I'm LGBT and I'd like to engage with the community. But I don't want the mods running the instance choosing what I can or cannot see because they don't like eg. Harry Potter. That's my individual decision to make. Frankly, I have a thick skin and I like to be exposed to lots of different people and ideas. And I even enjoy talking with those that disagree with me. I respect people who have the opposite opinion about this, but I don't want to be caught up in their censorship blast radius. Nobody should get to choose who talks to me except for me. - - - - - - Edit 2: Look at how stupid this gets on Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/unpopularopinion/comments/al3r4q/comment/efba0l8/ https://www.reddit.com/r/unpopularopinion/comments/al3r4q/co... https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/comments/10kgo0y/a_subreddit_is_banning_are_users_automatically_as/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/comments/10kgo0y/a_subre... https://www.reddit.com/r/infp/comments/18ynfaq/comment/kgc8x31/ https://www.reddit.com/r/infp/comments/18ynfaq/comment/kgc8x... Platformization of the distributed web of the 90's and 00's was bad enough. Now we're empowering people to silence broad group participation over pettiness. I hate this. And I don't hate very many things. - - - - - - Edit 3: > find one that has people that share the same values you do. That's a mismatch. In any group of people, there will never be 100% consensus. Yogurt lovers won't all like FroYo, and some will die on the hill of Kefir. The correct thing to do is compose your interests and group memberships yourself. It's flexible. You'll overlap with other people, topics, and ideas naturally. Not every individual of every community you join will see eye to eye with the sum of the people in your circle. And that's okay. Another analogy: perhaps your extended family don't all get along. But you don't typically ostracize an entire branch of the family because you can't put them all in the same room together. The Reddit/Mastodon way is about labeling the individual. You have to be a card-carrying member. If you do things the management doesn't like, you're out. The distributed approach is about an individual navigating their preferences themselves. It's fuzzy, organic, and matches the real world. It's not a dictatorship of ideology or ass-kissing.
- mariusor 3y agoI feel like you're showing way too much trust into what AT Proto will be able to do in some nebulous future when the reality is that there are barely any servers running outside of Bluesky (if any). Until AT Proto is proven as a federated protocol the same way ActivityPub is I would take comparisons - even for mostly unrelated capabilities, which moderation is - with a pinch of salt.
- gardenhedge 3y agoWow that's a great idea by BlueSky. I hadn't heard of or thought of that approach!