5 ms·
Apple starts sending 'batterygate' settlement payments
- lnxg33k1 3y ago[flagged]
- endisneigh 3y agoCould you elaborate on the scam billions bit?
- lnxg33k1 3y ago[flagged]
- endisneigh 3y agoThat’s not what was happening though?
- lnxg33k1 3y agoI think it had the effect to make people buy new phones, you don’t?
- endisneigh 3y agoThat was not what it was about. The throttling existed to prevent the phones from shutting down needlesssly
- lnxg33k1 3y agoDue to broken batteries, becoming broken after a short period of time, so to avoid recalling phones
- blackoil 3y agoLack of communication means people didn't had choice (information) to replace battery and choose new phone by default. What percentage of users would have selected new battery instead of phone is debatable but it must be greater than 0.
- endisneigh 3y agoI agree. Apple was wrong to do that, hence the settlement.
- FredPret 3y agoSlight overreaction there
- batch12 3y agoYou aren't worthless.
- lnxg33k1 3y agoSpeak for yourself :D I find comfort in being a blade of grass, my frustration is not from being worthless, comes from corps trying to exploit that for their interests
- batch12 3y agoEven a blade of grass has worth to a grazing animal, but I respect your comfort. I do identify with your frustration of being exploited and manipulated by the powerful.
- Gyrantula 3y agoWhich is it? Are we worth billions or are we worthless?
- donor20 3y agoI’m curious why apple didn’t just let folks turn this off if they were so upset. Their phones would have died and apple would get another sale. Make the turn off permanent- once opted out no going back. Off all the “gates” this one seemed a bit underwhelming
- Podgajski 3y agoBecause by throttling the phone, they could blame all the new “powerful apps” instead of their defective batteries.
- foldr 3y agoThe batteries weren’t defective. They were just aging normally.
- ysleepy 3y agoOne is however solved more easily, replacing the battery for 80 bucks. The other necessitates a new device for 800 bucks. Apple benefits from hiding the cheaper fix in order to make $$$. The mechanism might be technically reasonable, but intentionally misleading customers is not.
- pi-e-sigma 3y agoIf that was the case Apple wouldn't have deployed the stealthy 'fix' and instead just said 'your battery is old and hence sometimes turns your phone off unexpectedly. But it's normal'. It clearly shows that the battery aging wasn't considered normal
- foldr 3y agoSorry, I don’t see the logic here. Any battery will be able to supply less peak current as it ages. Throttling the SoC is clearly a better solution than just having the device randomly brown out. Fundamentally, that’s why it’s the solution that Apple adopted. We can speculate about Apple’s motives. My point was just that the batteries were not defective.
- Podgajski 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Podgajski 3y ago[flagged]
- leetrout 3y agoThis is good news. The keyboard lawsuit should start seeing payments in 2024 hopefully! https://www.keyboardsettlement.com/ https://www.keyboardsettlement.com/
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- blindriver 3y agoThis the highest settlement of actual cash I’ve seen in my life. Normally the settlements end up being less than $10 with the lawyers taking the lions share and not worth replying to to avoid disclosing my SSN to a possible fraudster. I guess I should have sent in my claim for this!
- Astronaut3315 3y agoI got $148.25 in two payments for the Vergara v. Uber TCPA settlement. They sent me an unsolicited SMS.
- ceejayoz 3y agoClass action notices are incredibly difficult to distinguish from scams. Unsolicited emails/texts with a random domain name promising money if you just fill in a form with some personal information! I really wish the courts would set up a `classactions.gov` site; if a court approves a settlement, you get `foo.classactions.gov` for it.
- gcanyon 3y agoDoes anyone have a cite that Apple knowingly created the issue they were dealing with here? 1. iPhones have the ability to burst-use a lot of energy 2. Older batteries aren't able to produce the same voltage as fresh batteries 3. Apple throttles performance on older iPhones to prevent them shutting down completely by demanding more power than the battery is able to deliver. 4. Apple doesn't explain to anyone what they're doing. 2 is just physics/chemistry 3 and 4 are a mild misstep. So my question is: did Apple know ahead of time that they were designing phones that would age out of functionality and require this workaround? Or did they design phones that operated at peak functionality when new, and then a few years later realize the consequences of that design decision as the phones got older, and then take a perfectly reasonable course to handle the situation as well as possible, and only screw up in not telling people what they were doing?
- judge2020 3y agoIMO it was all perfectly reasonable, but yes, the settlement was mostly because the performance dropped without informing the user whatsoever, which lead to a non-zero amount of sales of new iPhones, even if Apple's motivation wasn't to push users to buy a new phone. But I think it's fair to say that laypeople shouldn't need to read every article about a potential Apple "gate" to know if/when their phone is performing normally, just old, or is defective and thus they need a new one.
- fauigerzigerk 3y agoIf they had told users (which they should have done) it might have lead to even more sales of new iPhones. Yes, some users would have replaced just the battery. But many others would have replaced the phone entirely, among them people who would never have noticed any slowdown from throttling.
- thebruce87m 3y agoMy wife didn’t upgrade despite knowing her phone was throttled. She definitely would have if it was rebooting due to brownouts. So there was a sale “saved” by apple. No idea if the numbers cancelled out. Coincidentally, we found out today her iPhone 8 has a degraded battery. Once again she has no plans to change the battery.
- kneel 3y agoI remember several iphones suddenly start performing poorly after updating coincidentally when Apple released new iphone models. It happened so much that people refused to update iOS because "that's how they get you." Apple knew about the complaints, it was very loud. They did this for several update cycles and hit pay-dirt on their sales.
- filoleg 3y agoMeanwhile, Google didn’t utilize a similar workaround with their Nexus 6P models (which was their flagship around the similar timeframe as the iOS “batterygate” scandal), as their phones were hitting the same issue. You know what happened? While my friends who had iPhones were sometimes complaining about slowdowns, pretty much everyone I knew who owned a Nexus 6P (including myself) ended up having to deal with the RMA process. Why? Because the phone would just shutdown instantly while at double-digit percentage charge. For me personally, it started with shutting down instantly at 8%. Then it creeped into the 12-15% territory. By the time I felt like I had it enough to deal with it, the phone would just shutdown entirely at 27-29%. The problem initially started around a year after the purchase, and progressed to this awful state in less than half a year. For a lot of people, it would straight up just start hitting a bootloop too, so your phone was entirely toast no matter what. Nexus 6P was an extremely popular “clean android flagship from google” phone at the time (Samsung was not the clear “apple of android” player at yet, but was visibly getting there at a breakneck pace, as they were gearing up for the release of their Galaxy S8 series). Every single person I knew who owned that phone hit that problem within the first 18 months at latest. To Google’s defense, their remediation was (at one specific narrow point in time) to just give people their newer Pixel 1 in exchange for RMA. The problem was that Google butched even that, as they didn’t expect such volume of requests, and they started denying RMA for people who didn’t have their “protection plan.” Oh, and that option was only available in certain locales in the first place, and you had to get a bit lucky even then. The situation was so disastrous for the owners, I have no idea how Google managed to not get dragged through the mud in press for this even remotely as much as Apple continues getting dragged for their approach to almost the exact same problem that occurred around the exact same time period. My only bet is that, overall, Nexus phone market share wasn’t nearly as massive as that of iPhones. Every single person I knew who owned a Nexus 6P hit this issue, and that included myself too. For context, look at the number of comments on the “official RMA thread” in r/Nexus6P related to this[0]. Just reading the replies on it today almost gave me a headache, with how vividly I remember having to deal with this at the time. 0. https://www.reddit.com/r/Nexus6P/s/XPfDqktozm https://www.reddit.com/r/Nexus6P/s/XPfDqktozm
- GeekyBear 3y agoInterestingly, the 2015 Nexus 6P had the exact same issue (among others). > If you're among those affected, your phone will randomly shut down and completely die, even though your battery indicator might have said you had plenty of juice left. It's not a simple system crash, because your phone will stay dead until you connect it to a charger. https://android.gadgethacks.com/news/nexus-6p-battery-randomly-dying-its-not-just-you-0175625/ https://android.gadgethacks.com/news/nexus-6p-battery-random... Google refused to do anything to remedy the situation and lost a lawsuit over that. > Nexus 6P owners eligible for up to $400 from Huawei and Google in class action settlement https://www.androidcentral.com/nexus-6p-owners-eligible-400-huawei-and-google-class-action-settlement https://www.androidcentral.com/nexus-6p-owners-eligible-400-... Doing nothing seems to have ended up costing more per device, with Apple paying out about $100 and Google paying out up to $400.
- tiffanyh 3y agoDumb question: has the word “gate” just become synonymous any scandal because it’s a play on the word “Watergate” (which references the office building of the Nixon scandal)?
- krapp 3y agoYes. That's been the case since Watergate.