3 ms·
Predicting the financial crisis is probably orders of magnitude more complex that climate change. Climate science is based on well known (although complex) syst
by Anon84 15y ago
Predicting the financial crisis is probably orders of magnitude more complex that climate change. Climate science is based on well known (although complex) systems of equations and laws that have been studied independently from each other for hundreds of year (heat diffusion, fluid flow, etc...). The tricky part is combining all the pieces is a system the size of the planet where a lot of quantities are still relatively unknown.
Compare that with the financial crisis where there are no hard laws and the behavior of the system depends directly and inextrinsibly from how a large group of people scattered around the world will reach to certain hypothetical scenario in an unknown point in history. Will investor A be rational? Panic? How about B? What happens if B sees A panicking? Or vice versa?
I'm not an economist, by can give you an example on epidemiology I worked on recently. Starting with one of the simplest epidemic models (SIR), as soon as you add a simple behavioral assumption (people can become afraid of the disease and behave more carefully) the behavior of the systems changes completely.
- eli_gottlieb 15y agoPredicting the financial crisis is probably orders of magnitude more complex that climate change. Orders of magnitude simpler, I'd think. "If real wages and household incomes keep dropping while household indebtedness keeps rising, you will eventually have a financial crisis." Marx never needed any math to work this out, just the good sense to realize that money never appears out of thin air.
- Anon84 15y agoDon't mistake a bubble with a financial crisis.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- neutronicus 15y agoThere's as much content to that prediction as there is to the prediction "if you release carbon dioxide into the environment at an accelerated rate, the average temperature of the Earth will increase". What people are meaning by "prediction" here is something much more specific than what you mean and you know it.