4 ms·
Tesla lowers Model Y, S, X range estimations following exaggeration complaints
- kccqzy 3y agoThe headline is slightly misleading. The range estimations are lowered for these two reasons instead (buried in the article): > First, are “comfort and functionality improvements” made by Tesla that require more energy, and second is the implementation of revised EPA testing requirements that result in a “higher consumption and a slight decrease in overall range.” Personally I think the second reason is the main one. EPA gave automakers way too much leeway to tune the tests and report an inflated figure. It's good that they are tightening the procedures. However, it's quite possible that without the exaggeration attempts there wouldn't be any changes to EPA testing requiments.
- devmor 3y agoThose reasons are not officially from Tesla, in case it wasn’t clear. They’re supposedly leaked from internal documents- Tesla has given no official word publicly on the adjustments.
- belltaco 3y agoDupe https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38880668 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38880668
- dumpsterlid 3y ago[dead]
- judge2020 3y agoThe fact that the EPA allows two different suites of tests to be ran then marketed under the same name, without any disclaimers, is insane. Either do something like "X miles EPA 1 (est)"/EPA 2, or deprecate the EPA test cycle that only Tesla seems to still be using (probably for backwards compatibility/comparisons to older Tesla cars).
- idontwantthis 3y agoBetter yet, Require the only test that matters in an EV: Range at 70mph on a real highway.
- hypothesis 3y agoAnd some states even have 75 mph legal speed limit on freeways.
- idontwantthis 3y agoSure 70/75 whatever. The point is that range means “how far can I go on a highway”. The city range is more than that and also doesn’t matter for noncommercial vehicles.
- GolfPopper 3y agoStreet miles (or minutes) under standard traffic conditions would also seem important for many drivers.
- idontwantthis 3y agoBut why would you need a separate number and test for that? It’s guaranteed to be more than the highway range and for the small percentage of the time that range matters at all 99% of the time that will be on a highway. Do people seriously consider driving >200 miles inside of a city in a single day?
- marsokod 3y agoIt would be useful for people who do not have a home charger, so that they understand if they can do a whole week with it. It is also useful for taxi drivers (though I would hope they do more than just reading a single number). It is difficult to find a good solution for this, even providing 3 ranges (city, suburban, highway) has its limits and will confuse people.