5 ms·
> I turned out to be everything the company wished they never hired. I had extensive knowledge of economics, currencies, financial markets, and investment strat
by smacktoward 15y ago
> I turned out to be everything the company wished they never hired. I had extensive knowledge of economics, currencies, financial markets, and investment strategies. I had interned at a former hedge fund manager’s website and learned to write about financial markets. I had my own financial website, and I tweeted with financial TV personalities on a regular basis. Worst of all, I had a YouTube channel chock full of rap videos I made about my favorite stocks...
Then what the hell are you doing working at a call center?
Call center workers have one job: to read from the script. That's it. People who want to be creative do badly in those jobs, because they are not creative jobs.
If you take a job on the grill line at McDonald's, they will not care if you can make the most juicy, succulent cheeseburgers on your backyard grill. They will not be interested in hearing how you do it. If you start trying to do it at work, they will fire you, no matter how good your cheeseburger tastes. Because the goal at McDonald's is consistency. They hire you to make a burger to the McDonald's standard. Not to make the best burger you can.
And that's perfectly reasonable! There's no way to build a business on the scale of McDonald's while depending on the genius of artisanal burger chefs. It only works if you standardize.
The only way to turn out burgers on an industrial scale, in other words, is with an industrial process. And the same is true of turning out information via telephone. You could never find enough people to do it if each one needed to be a financial expert. The only way to do it is to use less expert people and give them a script to read from.
If that's not an environment where you thrive, I can understand. But the problem isn't with the environment; it works for what it needs to do (answer huge volumes of mostly basic and/or stupid questions). The problem is with you for putting yourself there. If you want to be an artisanal burger chef, McDonald's is not where you should be looking for work.
- EvilTerran 15y agoMcDonald's wouldn't fire you for giving your friends burgers from your backyard grill, even if they all got food poisoning afterwards; while this business would fire you for doing anything resembling financial advice in your own time, even if nothing bad came of it to anyone. It's the controlling attitude towards off-duty behaviour that strikes me as particularly insidious.
- timwiseman 15y agoA company needs to protect itself from things that could potentially be tied back to it, even indirectly. This is especially true for employees that are presented as representing the company even some of the time. I work as a SQL Server DBA and occassionally publish articles about technical aspects of SQL. But anything that rises above the level of a comment like this one gets vetted by the company before I publish it. I am quite comfortable with this because I agreed to it ahead of time and I understand why the company wants the right to review.
- fennecfoxen 15y ago"A company needs to protect itself from things that could potentially be tied back to it, even indirectly." I don't think that this sort of lockdown is a good answer. The answer should be something more like going "what the heck is wrong with our system of lawsuits and liability that the company needs to be this paranoid about its risks?"
- talmand 15y agoWhile true, a company cannot change the laws it operates under by itself and must take steps to protect its interests. In the US most of these laws are created to protect the consumer to the detriment of the company. It is what it is.
- Zak 15y agoIt seems to me that a company shouldn't be liable for anything an employee does outside of work unless there's evidence that the company specifically sanctioned such conduct. In other words, the default should be "the opinions in this post are mine and mine alone..." for anything not explicitly done in the company's name.
- timwiseman 15y agoI am not a lawyer, but I am inclined to agree with you. However, the analysis for whether an employee's actions trigger respondeat superior is more complicated than that, especially for employees where the work/life balance may not be entirely clear (this is frequently true of executives and may be true of anyone that ever does post/publish/or even speak on behalf of the company). But even if it were clear that the employee's actions did not fall into the category, a company is rightly concerned about anything that would create even a colorable cause of action (in otherwords, anything someone could sue for without it being immediately thrown out). Also, the company might be worried about the appearance in the public's eyes even when lawsuits are entirely off the table.
- timwiseman 15y agoYou make an excellent point, in many jobs consistency is valued far above outstanding results and should be. If that is not for you, do not work there. But, having worked in a couple of call centers, I feel obliged to point out not all of them are that way. I have been in call centers for major products where there were no scripts, the representatives (or "agents") were expected to think and help solve problems for the customers as well as provide feedback to other departments making the products. But I will agree those are a minority and in some call centers they are separated out into "level 2" or something equivalent.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- wisty 15y agoMcDonald's wouldn't fire you if a client asked you "why is the quarter pounder tastier", and you said "it's because it has a different sauce". Especially if the client was a professional chef, and you were fired because you may have given them potentially misleading advice. The rant isn't about why he was fired. He got a "final warning" for giving useful information to a savvy client. He got fired because he restarted his blogging, taunting them to fire him. His rant isn't about why he was unjustly fired - he obviously didn't give a shit at that stage. The rant is about how restrictive the compliance is, and how it hurts everybody. The compliance rules are there for a reason, but the author clearly doesn't think it's worth the cost. I like eating at McDonalds, but I'd also like the option of going somewhere that's a bit sloppier, and a bit more creative. Yes, I might get food poisoning, but as they say - Caveat Emptor.
- wizzard 15y ago> McDonald's wouldn't fire you if a client asked you "why is the quarter pounder tastier", and you said "it's because it has a different sauce". Well, they would if the customer could turn around and sue them because they didn't get the right sauce.
- wtvanhest 15y agoThis guy doesn't even know that it has nothing to do with being at a big company. It has to do with investment advice rules from the SEC designed to protect investors from situations like boiler room. He should get an MBA from a top school then get a job as a sell side analyst and get paid for what he wants to do.