11 ms·
This excuse always struck me as implausible. Nuclear power plants cost many times the cost of their materials. More likely is they were always lowballing the
by pfdietz 3y ago
This excuse always struck me as implausible. Nuclear power plants cost many times the cost of their materials.
More likely is they were always lowballing the cost, hoping for a miracle. We'll see what comes up in the shareholder lawsuit.
- lostlogin 3y agoAlso: The power they would make would be worth more, making the project infeasible? They could always sell the power for less.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoWho would fund new nuclear when it has to sell power at a loss?
- lostlogin 3y agoThe point I was making was that citing a high selling price as a downside seems implausible. Edit: pretty sure I’ve misunderstood your initial point. They were going to have to sell the power for a lot. It wasn’t that the market price rose.
- danans 3y ago> The point I was making was that citing a high selling price as a downside seems implausible The OP doesn't cite a high selling price for the generated electricity, they are citing the high cost of materials to build the plant.
- elsonrodriguez 3y agoWho would fund solar power when it was so expensive and so inefficient? Someone funded it, and subsidized it, and now solar panels are cheap and plentiful. And that someone now owns the global market for solar panels.
- roenxi 3y agoThat is likely pointless in US Nuclear. If you look down to the "Nuclear Power Learning and Deployment Rates" figure [0] you can see that the US has managed to invert the learning curve; by regulation since I've never seen any other technology do something like that V shape. That strategy might work in other Asia. It probably won't catch in the US. [0] https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/ThvvCE2HsLohJYd7b/why-has-nuclear-power-been-a-flop https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/ThvvCE2HsLohJYd7b/why-has-nu...
- epistasis 3y agoAll these regulatory stories seem to fail to connect the full picture back to a suitable regulatory regime that actually saves costs. With our latest round of nuclear failures, there was a new combined licensing approach taken at the behest of industry. It did not seem to work. The article cites "hundreds of millions for licensing" which is a tiny percentage of reactor cost, and frankly insignificant. For costs to be lower, there has to be a huge, 50%+ drop in construction costs. The latest nuclear failures in the US used a new design, the AP1000, which used something like an order of magnitude less concrete and steel, and that was not enough to pull down costs. Where is the money going? Labor. The French regulatory regime is presumably OK, as it oversaw a large buildout in the 1970s, and I've never heard anybody complain about it, but it has still resulted in economic failures at Flamanville and Olkiluoto. Eliminate ALARA, and what construction or design cost savings are there? I'm not sure and it's not really clear. What construction site savings are there? Ignore the containment? People all agreed that after Chernobyl is was a bad idea, what engineer is going to sign off on that? Maybe they are OK with it, but I haven't heard any engineer brave enough to cite a lessening of safety that would drive down construction costs. Also, all large construction projects, the heart of nuclear, have gotten expensive in the US, even without the NRC. It's just a hard problem to build big things with complicated logistics. Look at construction productivity trends over the past 50 years, and they have been stagnant compared to manufacturing and other types of productivity. And as productivity increases in an economy, overall wages increase, even for the less productive construction sector, because workers have the choice to work in more productive fields, and must be paid to compensate for the low productivity of working in construction. The places closest to having low costs on nuclear are economies with cheap labor: Russia and China. It's going to be hard for us to outsource construction labor to cheap countries when the reactors need to be sites in high labor cost countries. Even if regulation is a major factor, this labor cost of construction is also a major factor. And it's unclear to me why nuclear should ever be cheap. It's a huge huge construction project, and in advanced economies, those are still very expensive.
- pydry 3y agoThe US government. They have a vested interest in maintaining a nuclear supply chain and skills base to share with the military. It's the reason why there has been such a huge pro nuclear PR offensive in the last 10 years. Consent needs to be manufactured for lavishing nuclear power with subsidies. E.g. in order to justify giving Bill Gates's startup a dumptruck full of taxpayer money people have to be positively predisposed to nuclear power. The most ironic and fucked up part of the nuclear-military industrial complex's PR offensive was when they tried to shame environmentalists for being anti nuclear power and tried to shame Germany for trailblazing a highly effective green energy policy. The environment is of no concern to them.