5 ms·
NuScale Lays off 40% of its Staff
- toomuchtodo 3y ago> Last January UAMPS issued a report that inflation had rapidly raised the prices of key materials like concrete and steel forcing a steep rise in the overall cost of the project. In turn, the expected cost of electricity from the completed project soared into the stratosphere making it uneconomic in terms of selling it to customers. The target price for power from the plant jumped $53 to $89 per megawatt hour. https://neutronbytes.com/2023/01/24/nuscales-smr-costs-hit-hard-by-inflation/ https://neutronbytes.com/2023/01/24/nuscales-smr-costs-hit-h...
- jdewerd 3y agoFrom googling around it looks like prices doubled and then halved. It looks like they were back to 2019 levels by the beginning of 2023. https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/steel https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/steel
- pfdietz 3y agoThis excuse always struck me as implausible. Nuclear power plants cost many times the cost of their materials. More likely is they were always lowballing the cost, hoping for a miracle. We'll see what comes up in the shareholder lawsuit.
- lostlogin 3y agoAlso: The power they would make would be worth more, making the project infeasible? They could always sell the power for less.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoWho would fund new nuclear when it has to sell power at a loss?
- lostlogin 3y agoThe point I was making was that citing a high selling price as a downside seems implausible. Edit: pretty sure I’ve misunderstood your initial point. They were going to have to sell the power for a lot. It wasn’t that the market price rose.
- danans 3y ago> The point I was making was that citing a high selling price as a downside seems implausible The OP doesn't cite a high selling price for the generated electricity, they are citing the high cost of materials to build the plant.
- elsonrodriguez 3y agoWho would fund solar power when it was so expensive and so inefficient? Someone funded it, and subsidized it, and now solar panels are cheap and plentiful. And that someone now owns the global market for solar panels.
- roenxi 3y agoThat is likely pointless in US Nuclear. If you look down to the "Nuclear Power Learning and Deployment Rates" figure [0] you can see that the US has managed to invert the learning curve; by regulation since I've never seen any other technology do something like that V shape. That strategy might work in other Asia. It probably won't catch in the US. [0] https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/ThvvCE2HsLohJYd7b/why-has-nuclear-power-been-a-flop https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/ThvvCE2HsLohJYd7b/why-has-nu...
- epistasis 3y agoAll these regulatory stories seem to fail to connect the full picture back to a suitable regulatory regime that actually saves costs. With our latest round of nuclear failures, there was a new combined licensing approach taken at the behest of industry. It did not seem to work. The article cites "hundreds of millions for licensing" which is a tiny percentage of reactor cost, and frankly insignificant. For costs to be lower, there has to be a huge, 50%+ drop in construction costs. The latest nuclear failures in the US used a new design, the AP1000, which used something like an order of magnitude less concrete and steel, and that was not enough to pull down costs. Where is the money going? Labor. The French regulatory regime is presumably OK, as it oversaw a large buildout in the 1970s, and I've never heard anybody complain about it, but it has still resulted in economic failures at Flamanville and Olkiluoto. Eliminate ALARA, and what construction or design cost savings are there? I'm not sure and it's not really clear. What construction site savings are there? Ignore the containment? People all agreed that after Chernobyl is was a bad idea, what engineer is going to sign off on that? Maybe they are OK with it, but I haven't heard any engineer brave enough to cite a lessening of safety that would drive down construction costs. Also, all large construction projects, the heart of nuclear, have gotten expensive in the US, even without the NRC. It's just a hard problem to build big things with complicated logistics. Look at construction productivity trends over the past 50 years, and they have been stagnant compared to manufacturing and other types of productivity. And as productivity increases in an economy, overall wages increase, even for the less productive construction sector, because workers have the choice to work in more productive fields, and must be paid to compensate for the low productivity of working in construction. The places closest to having low costs on nuclear are economies with cheap labor: Russia and China. It's going to be hard for us to outsource construction labor to cheap countries when the reactors need to be sites in high labor cost countries. Even if regulation is a major factor, this labor cost of construction is also a major factor. And it's unclear to me why nuclear should ever be cheap. It's a huge huge construction project, and in advanced economies, those are still very expensive.
- 0xbadc0de5 3y ago[flagged]
- dsgnr 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- carbocation 3y agoIt wasn't really obvious to me since I don't follow this closely, but NuScale is a company building nuclear powerplants. Edit now that the link has changed, the new article makes this much more clear.
- pi-e-sigma 3y agoNot really, because they haven't built any :)
- throwaw33333434 3y agoThis is such a shame, they were planning to built SMRs in my country (Poland). I hope GE Hitachi won't abandon the project now. Currently, I'm very enthusiastic about fervoenergy.com. It presents an outstanding alternative to gas and coal for district heating, and it may even have potential for electricity generation.
- danans 3y ago> It presents an outstanding alternative to gas and coal for district heating, and it may even have potential for electricity generation. Fervo's first demonstration project is for electricity generation, not district heating [1]. Electricity is much more valuable (in terms of money) than heat. 1. https://www.google.com/amp/s/blog.google/outreach-initiatives/sustainability/google-fervo-geothermal-energy-partnership/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/blog.google/outreach-initiative...
- epistasis 3y agoThe Canadian projects with GE Hitachi's BWRX-300 definitely seem the closest to reality. But when I look at the promises: > In 2019, GEH expected construction to start in 2024/2025 in the US or Canada, entering commercial operation in 2027/2028, and for the first unit to cost less than $1 billion to build. -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BWRX-300 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BWRX-300 I can only think that they are completely over promising and committing themselves to under delivering. Three years to build at $3300/kW seems like exactly the same fantasy land that the nuclear industry has been failing to deliver for far too long. Just once they should try a realistic estimate and deliver what they promise. That would have an amazing positive effect for whoever did that. Agreed on Fervo. For the 5% of countries with the worst sun and wind resources, something like that will be essential. And it will undoubtedly help the countries in the top 95% of wind and solar resources too.
- pfdietz 3y agoGeothermal becomes a bit more efficient in cold weather, which is when that 5% of countries really need it. 5% is also the fraction of human population living poleward of 50 degrees N/S.
- dang 3y agoUrl changed from https://neutronbytes.com/2024/01/05/nuscale-lays-off-40-of-its-staff/ https://neutronbytes.com/2024/01/05/nuscale-lays-off-40-of-i..., which points to this.
- dang 3y agoUrl chnanged from https://neutronbytes.com/2024/01/05/nuscale-lays-off-40-of-its-staff/ https://neutronbytes.com/2024/01/05/nuscale-lays-off-40-of-i..., which points to this. Submitters: "Please submit the original source. If a post reports on something found on another site, submit the latter." - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- epistasis 3y ago> NuScale laid off 40% of its over 500 employees on Friday January 5th > NuScale’s CEO said last November it had about $200 million in cash reserves but some of the funds are allocated to specific work for customers and can’t be used generally to revitalize the firm. 300 employees, plus unknown amounts of pre-allocated work, no chance of revenue before the runway runs out, and a terrible environment for high-risk capital, make this look extremely grim.
- credit_guy 3y agoGrim for whom? The 300 employees currently on the job market, it's not that grim for them. It's better to have some clarity, rather than live a half life. They can now focus on getting another job. My guess is that most of them won't have problems landing a new, and potentially better paying job. They participated in a project that resulted in the first NRC reactor certification in a very, very long time. Literally nobody else can put this on their resume. There are lots of nuclear startups out there, and they probably have troubles finding qualified people. They'll jump at the opportunity to get some ex-NuScale engineers. As for NuScale itself, they'll be fine. Their most important asset is their reactor certification. They don't have experience actually delivering even a single operating reactor. But that certification is gold. For many other companies that want to get into the SMR game, it would probably be much easier to license the NuScale design than to go through the decade long process of getting their own design certified.
- pfdietz 3y agoThey have a certification for the 50 MW version. They were trying to build the 77 MW version, which they don't yet have a certification for. Why would some other company want to build it, if there aren't enough customers?
- hyperdimension 3y ago> live a half life Not sure if that was intentional, but nice. I didn't even know there could be such a thing as a nuclear startup. How do you think they will succeed if NuScale didn't/couldn't? Or was NuScale mismanaged?
- renewiltord 3y agoInteresting. I wonder if they want to be a Reactor IP company rather than a Reactor Manufacturing company. Probably a better path to profitability there. The approved design is probably quite coveted by others.
- pfdietz 3y agoThey weren't going to make the reactors themselves. I believe Fluor was going to do that. Fluor spun them off in a SPAC a couple of years ago. SPACs are kind of a red flag, aren't they?
- renewiltord 3y agoOh man, thanks for that context. I have to say I kind of agree.
- throwaway5959 3y ago[flagged]
- unethical_ban 3y agoWell, you don't write in complete sentences, and you write off all nuclear power as a bad faith con in one unexplained sentence. When you take an unpopular stance, prepare to put in effort to defend them. Either there exists some people who think your "argument" is weak, or Big Nuclear is monitoring the thread.
- throwaway5959 3y agoI never said all nuclear was a con, nuclear isn’t particularly popular and you’re the only one mentioning “Big Nuclear”. Also being dismissive due to sentence structure (or lack thereof) isn’t constructive.
- pstuart 3y agoI'm as pro-renewables as most, but this is disappointing. As far as energy goes, the more the merrier. Non-carbon baseload energy that is "guaranteed" would be nice to have in our back pocket.
- pydry 3y agoThere are other cheaper, more effective ways to mitigate solar and wind variability. The most promising being pumped storage - it's cheap and it can store gargantuan amounts of power. The geography to support it is, according to the scientific literature, very common (citation: https://www.pv-magazine.com/2021/01/05/sustainable-pumped-hydro-across-616818-sites/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2021/01/05/sustainable-pumped-hy... ). We'd need about ~7 hours of storage to get a 95-97% carbon free grid, according to current models (citation : https://reneweconomy.com.au/a-near-100-per-cent-renewables-grid-is-well-within-reach-and-with-little-storage/ https://reneweconomy.com.au/a-near-100-per-cent-renewables-g... ). Australia could reach roughly that level by building a 2nd snowy 2. It doesnt indirectly support the nuclear-military industrial complex though, so the government will never be as keen on using taxpayer cash to subsidize it.
- snewman 3y agoMy understanding, and I've read a fair amount on the subject, is that geography for pumped storage is actually pretty limited compared to the eventual need. Do you have a source for it being plentiful? Promising alternatives to mitigate solar and wind variability, aside from pumped storage and nuclear, include advanced geothermal, load management, thermal storage, long-distance transmission, storing clean hydrogen or clean methane (made from electrolysis and captured CO2), and possibly long-term battery technologies (not lithium, that'll mostly be for overnight or shorter). In no particular order.
- pydry 3y agoThe source is a paper from the Australian National University who identified 616,818 suitable locations for 23.1 million GWh of pumped-hydro storage capacity. Link added above. I've seen quite a lot of contradictory messaging about the availability of locations but it never seems to come linked to any evidence I've seen. It wouldn't be the first time the carbon/nuclear industry successfully spread FUD about science that threatened their bottom line. For a long time the carbon industry's position was that the only thing capable of accommodating renewable intermittency was ~3 weeks' worth of lithium ion batteries. This is obviously nonsense, but I still see it repeated a lot. Clean hydrogen / methane would suffice as storage if the goal was to supply green electricity cheaper than nuclear power (not because it's cheap, but because nuclear power is that expensive), but we should be able do better than that - they're both quite inefficient.
- namuol 3y agoI get the sense VC funding is not patient enough for this kind of tech innovation. There are countless state-owned oil companies; why not for other parts of the energy sector, especially in countries with a lot of human/intellectual capital?
- rado 3y agoOliver Stone’s “Nuclear Now” film was very optimistic about small reactors. Not sure if it interviewed this company or another?
- pfdietz 3y agoIt would be a useful exercise to go back to that film and, with the benefit of hindsight, see where its argument went off the rails. And if one found that film convincing, it would also be useful to see where ones acceptance of the argument went astray.