8 ms·
Copyright Liability on LLMs Should Mostly Fall on the Prompter, Not the Service
- artninja1988 3y agoProbably agree. If liabilities on the service it would be impossible to operate using the best data leading to a worse service. And I want the better service.
- cyanydeez 3y agocounterpoint: the first law broken is by providing copyright derivatives without license. imagine if a public broadcast included random copyrighted images of movies, and you want people with antennas to be charged for watching.
- smoldesu 3y ago> imagine if a public broadcast included random copyrighted images of movies, and you want people with antennas to be charged for watching. What about it? That could still be protected by Fair Use considering the nature of the copyright law. If you're charging money for people to watch your movie review podcast or upcoming film news program, you'd probably be fine as long as you didn't attempt to show any films in full. A few years ago Corellium literally sold researchers a copy of Apple's iOS for penetration testing purposes. Apple was outraged and sued, but lost their copyright appeal because Corellium's use of copyrighted material was Fair Use. Even though they were making money off something that wasn't theirs. Same went for Google vs Author's Guild, a bunch of authors sued Google for deriving their books for a digital system. Since the original copies were lawfully attained and the full work was never output by Google, they also got away with Fair Use. And that's to say nothing of the copyright clusterfuck called YouTube...
- salawat 3y agoBulllllllshit. The copyright violation falls squarely on the people who scraped the everloving bajeezus out of everything, then trained on it. Trying to put the liability on the prompter is just fishing for a pass to not have to develop a well defined process whereby training data is acquired without bothering with compensating the source. Get back to me when all the sc-rapey types ask permission first. Then we can talk in good faith about loosening things up. No demonstration of such good faith has been hitherto done however.