2 ms·
Of course, it's absolutely DVC. The problem is that I've never seen a DVC solution that solves the problem by making the hosting decentralized. So all of the
by chaxor 3y ago
Of course, it's absolutely DVC. The problem is that I've never seen a DVC solution that solves the problem by making the hosting decentralized. So all of the huge problems I listed still exist even with these DVC packages. What's more is, even in addition to the cost of the hosting, some of the DVC packages cost money on top of that.
So, when a researcher deletes a file to make room for others on their storage provider and/or moves institutions and their account gets deleted, the data is gone. The only way around this is to use torrent or ipfs.
Also, I'm not sure what your issue with ipfs is; If it's 'I saw something something crypto one time' - it's a really poor argument. IPFS works completely independently of any crypto - it has nothing really to do with it.
The solution can also be torrent - I don't care too much - it's just possible that IPFS can run with far less resource usage on lower power, etc because it's more modern (likely uses better algorithms in the protocol, deals with modern filesystems better, with better performance, hopefully have better security, etc) and it's likely easier to implement. But it doesn't matter if it's torrent because it would work essentially the same way.
- dijksterhuis 3y ago> making the hosting decentralized > I'm not sure what your issue [is] with ipfs IPFS is cool. I played around with it a few years ago. I even had a similar idea during my masters (and then discovered IPFS). Decentralization is my issue here -- it's not necessary and it would be more of a blocker than a solution.
- chaxor 3y agoI'm not sure I understand? If you want to host the data on Dropbox, Dropbox becomes a part of the network and is hosted by the community and Dropbox or whatever service you like. The problem is that it is very prohibitive to use services like AWS. For instance, downloading all of Arxiv.org from AWS is around $600 last time I checked. Not every student trying to run an experiment is going to have $600 laying around to run the experiment. But with torrent/ipfs it would be free to download. It only adds. I don't understand how it subtracts.