3 ms·
If psychology is "under attack", or for that matter any scientific field is under attack, the solution is to do the hard work to prove that your work is meaning
by jerf 15y ago
If psychology is "under attack", or for that matter any scientific field is under attack, the solution is to do the hard work to prove that your work is meaningful and accurate, and if you discover it isn't, to fix those problems.
"People" are gullible and easy to fool in the short term, but I think it is commonly underestimated how smart "people" can be in the long term. Yes, you could throw up a smokescreen and dodge out of the spotlight cast on your bad science today, but that will only be a momentary reprieve of the pain. In the long term you'll still be under attack, and given that you will have been witnessed using smokescreens and obfuscations, you'll probably be on the losing side of that attack. In the short term, the pain of revealing just how much flimflam there is might hurt, but the result will be a discipline that in 5 or 10 years is no longer under serious attack, because "people" will notice that honesty and react to it.
If science is under attack, it is only because "people" are noticing that a lot of it is bunk... and the problem is people are right. We've seen that in a number of studies in a number of fields lately. The only answer that's going to truly restore confidence and respect is to eliminate the bunk. Politics won't work. Pay the piper now, or pay the piper more later. How often those are the choices....
and of all the people who should understand the psychological appeal of paying the piper later and taking the easy road today, you'd think it would be the psychologists...
- roc 15y agoI take a deep exception to the idea that a group of scientists attempting to reproduce the published work of their peers is, in any way, "an attack". Casting things that way immediately exposes a speaker as either not understanding science, and/or not having good science as their primary goal. Reproducing results is science. Perhaps the most important kind.
- jerf 15y agoThat is a reaction to the statement from the original article: "Nosek told Science that a senior colleague warned him not to take this on “because psychology is under threat and this could make us look bad.” In a Google discussion group, one of the researchers involved in the project wrote that it was important to stay “on message” and portray the effort to the news media as “protecting our science, not tearing it down.”" I see they say threat in that text, not attack, which appears elsewhere. Might I point out that if you carefully read my post it is vehemently agreeing that replication is necessary, and from there it should seem logical that I would not consider something necessary an "attack".
- roc 15y agoI'm sorry I wasn't more clear. I was agreeing with you. I was just trying to draw focus to just that particular point and its implications.
- mangodrunk 15y ago"Reproducing results is science. Perhaps the most important kind." Right, which is the problem because it's supposedly not being done and/or there are incentives against it for three journals of a particular field. This could be a larger problem in other fields as well. Saying what you said is right, but if the system is setup to be against it, then there is a problem.