3 ms·
> The idea that everything in the world has meaning is, by the way, the exact analogue of the principle that everything has a cause on which the whole of scienc
by layer8 3y ago
> The idea that everything in the world has meaning is, by the way, the exact analogue of the principle that everything has a cause on which the whole of science is based.’ Gödel – just like Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, whom he idolised – believed that everything in the world has a reason for its being so and not otherwise.
This is the core mistake, I believe, to assume that causation implies meaning, instead of causation just being a logical correlation, and meaning being a construction of the human mind.
It’s interesting, though, that Gödel took his incompleteness theorems as an indication that materialism (or naturalism) can’t be the truth, while still thinking that the world is rational.
- hirvi74 3y ago> This is the core mistake, I believe, to assume that causation implies meaning, instead of causation just being a logical correlation, and meaning being a construction of the human mind. I agree with you. If anything, saying everything having a reason seem to me like applying human interpretation to Determinism.
- Balgair 3y agoI mean, such an epic proof would bias one to think that the world is rational. Spending that much time in logic-land would do that to anyone. I think that his assumption that: 'meaning' and 'causation' are the same thing, is similarly tied to his works. For someone like Godel, I'd imagine that he has no conception that they could be different.