4 ms·
Statutory antitrust law in the US is extremely broad, to the point that it relies on the courts to interpret it to not prohibit anyone from so much as entering
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
Statutory antitrust law in the US is extremely broad, to the point that it relies on the courts to interpret it to not prohibit anyone from so much as entering into a 30 day purchasing contract because it would restrain the buyer from patronizing a competitor for 30 days. By its terms that would nominally be a violation.
As a result most of what you have to look at is case law. But antitrust cases are rare to begin with and ones dealing with this kind of "huge conglomerate that ties its products and services together with computer code" -- try to name one dealing with a company of that nature other than Microsoft. Maybe AT&T? It's not a lot of precedent until you're looking at cases of much smaller companies doing much narrower things, which leaves plenty of room for the judge to "distinguish" them (i.e. do whatever they want in this case).
> In general, companies have no duty to deal with competitors.
It seems like a major difference here isn't just that they won't deal with competitors, it's that they don't allow their customers to deal with competitors. This is quite stark when you're looking at their products -- someone who owns an iPhone can't reasonably modify or replace the system software to integrate a competing payments system (or, for that matter, app store) because Apple doesn't allow it even on a piece of hardware they sold and is now owned by someone else.
You could make that argument for services, i.e. iMessage, but there are at least two other ways to get at that. First, iMessage is tied to their other offerings and so then you get them for the tying. Second, maybe routing something with a network effect through a centralized service is a different kind of thing than refusing to provide your competitors with delivery service when you don't have a monopoly on delivery service. Maybe it's more like refusing to provide your competitors with delivery service when you do have a monopoly on delivery service.
> I'm looking forward to seeing the actual complaint when it is filed so we can assess whether the Justice Department is working within existing frameworks or is instead attempting to push the envelope of antitrust law without Congressional authorization.
Congress pretty much authorized the courts to do whatever they want on this. The real question is what they want to do. You have to go back to Congress if they do something dumb.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- akira2501 3y ago> to the point that it relies on the courts to interpret it The courts have been used to chip away at the very simple and straight forward anti trust laws that were established in this country after years of having grappled with the problem in it's unchecked form. > But antitrust cases are rare to begin with This is a feature of _recent_ history and does not at all fairly represent the large body of jurisprudence that has been issued on this subject. People really seem to misattribute much of our modern system of commerce to modernity and ignore the laws and decisions that were laid down nearly a century ago. > try to name one dealing with a company of that nature other than Microsoft. Iqvia holdings. > Maybe it's more like refusing to provide your competitors with delivery service They have a monopoly on the device and the app store. So, they create their own monopoly over the delivery service. They're not competing with "delivery" in general, but with "apps that are allowed to use these special features on the iphone and are directly approved by apple's own internal process." This seems exceptionally clear cut. > Congress pretty much authorized the courts to do whatever they want on this. No, they have not. Congress has ignored the courts interference int he law and has made no effort to clarify their statues. This is not the same as "authorizing" the courts to "do whatever they want."
- pests 3y agoThe exception makes the rule.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> The courts have been used to chip away at the very simple and straight forward anti trust laws that were established in this country after years of having grappled with the problem in it's unchecked form. The problem with simple and straight forward is that it's a law prohibiting something. If you buy the output of some factory which is the input to your own product, is that in restraint of trade? Does it matter if it's 10% or 50% or 90% or 100% of the industry's production capacity for that input? What if it's only 10% but it's the last 10% and the other 90% is already locked up in contracts with companies in other industries? There's nothing in the statute to answer questions like that so the courts have to make something up. There's a pretty good argument that they've narrowed the antitrust laws too much over time but it's hard to claim that Congress didn't leave things open to interpretation. > This is a feature of _recent_ history and does not at all fairly represent the large body of jurisprudence that has been issued on this subject. People really seem to misattribute much of our modern system of commerce to modernity and ignore the laws and decisions that were laid down nearly a century ago. A century ago there wasn't an internet-connected computer chip in everything that allows the vendor to exercise control over a product even after they've sold it. > Iqvia holdings. This appears to be a case about a merger between healthcare companies. Which part of it are you implying is relevant to what Apple is doing? > They have a monopoly on the device and the app store. So, they create their own monopoly over the delivery service. They're not competing with "delivery" in general, but with "apps that are allowed to use these special features on the iphone and are directly approved by apple's own internal process." They're presumably going to argue that you can create an account with AWS and install whatever applications you want on your cloud server and access them from your iPhone, or something like that. > Congress has ignored the courts interference int he law and has made no effort to clarify their statues. This is not the same as "authorizing" the courts to "do whatever they want." Let's put it this way: If the courts want to find Apple in violation, it would be difficult to argue that this is outside the scope of what Congress intended based on the wording of the laws Congress passed.